Santa Clarita Limited Liability Corp., a subsidiary of Remediation Financial, Inc., found themselves at odds with the Santa Clarita City Council when they purchased Porta Bella, a former munitions testing site in the heart of the city which had, for years, been owned by Whittaker-Bermite . The location has been heavily contaminated by years of high explosive and rocket testing, and the City Council has consistently rejected plans to develop Porta Bella until he entire site is declared safe by the California Environmental Protection Agency's Department of Toxic Substance Control. Recently, though, the council agreed to a phased clean-up and development, specifically to allow the building of Golden Valley Road across a section of Porta Bella, to accommodate the construction of the new Golden Valley High School.
Jerry Swerdlow, a senior vice president with RFI, with assistance from David Collett of Morrison Knudsen Corp., one of the firms actively involved in the Porta Bella clean-up , sat down with Signal political reporter Chris Dickerson to discuss Porta Bella's future development and the plans for rendering it safe.
QUESTION: Did you do a full study of all the contaminants and the clean up required by the Department of Toxic Substance Control before purchasing Porta Bella?
ANSWER: Yes, we spent the last 15 months or more investigating all of the information that was available from the seller and from the DTSC. We met with the DTSC many, many times over that period of time to determine what they would require as far as additional information so that we could characterize the site accurately and begin the clean-up and make it safe.
Jerry Swerdlow is senior vice president at RFI. [Photo by Dan Watson/The Signal]
Q: When did you first look at the property, and then purchase it?
A: We closed on the property in January of 1999. We looked at the property in 1997, at the end of the year.
Q: Were you aware when the property was purchased, that the City Council had taken a stand against any development of Porta Bella until the entire site was cleaned?
A: Yes, it was very clear in the development agreement that that was the requirement. However, when we looked at it, we realized that it was necessary to formulate a more effective way of handling this site, and we knew a lot more about the site than anybody had prior to the time. The road issues were also different, and the fact that perchlorate had come to the forefront, those things weren't known when the development agreement was entered into. So I believe the City Council did as best as they could at the time and working with the owner of the property, who had actually contaminated the property, we voluntarily acquired the property and are voluntarily working on solving the problems and making the property safe.
Q: What is Whittaker-Bermite 's current ownership position vis-a-vis Porta Bella?
A: Whittaker-Bermite sold the property to us. We own free title to the property. They just maintain a position at the final disposition of the property, which depends upon the success of the property and the total clean-up of the property at the time.
Q: EPA says that Whittaker-Bermite has a cradle-to-grave liability for the 1,000 acres of Porta Bella. What is your interpretation of Whittaker's responsibility?
A: When Whittaker accepted that liability or it was determined that it was their liability, the DTSC or the EPA do not really let them totally off the hook, although we have voluntarily accepted the responsibility and the liability. If in fact something happened and we were not successful in cleaning it up, then Whittaker would be brought back into the issue.
Q: Given the pending sale of Whittaker Corp., who will take responsibility for the liability coverage?
A: That generally goes with sale of the company, when there's a liability issue. Sales between companies go on all the time, and when there's a sale of a company, the liabilities and assets of that company go along with the sale. This would be no different. Unless there were an agreement otherwise, that's exactly what would happen. You would have to assume that any company that was financially able to acquire Whittaker would be in better financial condition even than Whittaker was.
Q: Hamid Saebfar of DTSC stated at the last City Council meeting that there isn't yet an effective technology for removing perchlorates from soil. What's your reaction to his statement?
A: There is not an effective technology for necessarily removing it, but there are effective technologies for handling it, including isolation and containment. These types of technologies are used all over the country, at different sites, not just for perchlorate but for other contaminants too. He is correct that there is not something you can immediately just drop it in, a magic potion.
Q: What other sites in California has RFI been involved with cleaning?
A: We have assembled a team of experts that have worked throughout the country, not only in California, but experts like Morrison Knudsen Construction Company, have worked all over the world. They were involved in Chernobyl, they were involved in the Rocky Mountain arsenal in Colorado. And other contractors that we have, like CET Environmental Services have been involved in California. They're an EPA-approved contractor. A couple of our contractors have worked at the Burbank Airport, at the Lockheed facility, and they worked at both soil remediation and ground water issues.
Q: What sort of contamination was on these sites, and how large were the areas?
A: For Morrison Knudsen, I know collaterally what Hargis has done, they worked up on a helicopter site on the California-Arizona border. I'm not sure of the whole scope of that from the standpoint of size, but I know that perchlorate was one of the contaminants there. They have actually received an award on that particular site for dealing with perchlorate contamination. This is the first time that Morrison Knudsen and RFI have worked together on a contaminated site.
Q: DTSC has expressed a concern about the possibility of live ordinance buried on the site. What's the process for detecting and removing those?
A: We're dealing with that right now at a site in Colorado, the Rocky Mountain arsenal. The Rocky Mountain arsenal has similar types of issues there and there's a whole procedure, including starting with health and safety plans for recognizing ordinances, all the way to what you do when an ordinance is recognized. It includes bringing in ordinance experts that are generally trained by the Army or the Navy back in Maryland, specifically for ordinance disposition and ordinance removal.
Q: How can people — children particularly — be kept out of the area until it's declared safe?
A: Currently, the property has a fence around it. No fence is really adequate to keep people out. During our development work and during the remediation work, we're going to have lots of people on the site and we will be able to watch it a lot better than it has been over the years....
Q: What housing developments has RFI built in the past?
A: We don't actually build housing developments. We are a remediation contractor and a developer. What we do is, we're a private company that seeks out, we actually identify, environmentally contaminated properties. We underwrite the risks, we bring in a team of experts who really know what they have to do with regard to each of the problems that exist on the property, and we then acquire the property.
Q: For a practical financial return on your investment, does RFI need to build on the property during a phased clean-up ?
A: That's one of the reasons we need to build on a phased clean-up . It is economically necessary to do that. The other reason is to get the property developed sooner. The perchlorate problem exists and now that we know it exists, the important thing is to eliminate the source and to get on with the clean-up . The sooner we can do that the better it is. It really brings benefits to the community sooner too.
Q: Are you offering a 20 percent rate of return to investors?
A: We have many investors that invest with us over projects that we bring in. Our investors have a very good comfort level with the kind of work that we do because of the integrity and the fact that we have successfully cleaned up previous projects. The return that we provide to them is a little bit better than normal market returns because there's a perceived risk, even though we believe that we have underwritten a project properly, there's always a chance that there may be additional funds.
Q: What's the process for cleaning up Porta Bella?
A: The first thing to understand is that by developing it in all views, it allows you to bite it off in manageable chunks, if you will. That's why what you've seen recently is this operable unit proposal for addressing the site in manageable chunks, that are bounded by ridgelines and drainage bases. We don't want to cut those in half. ... Whittaker had already completed a remedial investigation of the site and there are comments from DTSC where additional information is necessary to round out that investigation. So, a supplemental remedial investigation needs to take place. That starts with a work plan that goes through DTSC. They approve it and we respond to their comments until we finally get to the field. We implement the investigation, including drilling, trenching, etc., a pretty extensive effort. Once the field investigation is completed, we then take the information that was gathered in the field. That's of course processed, analyzed to determine what you've got where. You correlate laterally on the ground to try and understand what the extent of the chemicals are. Then ... a report is issued. A feasibility study is then prepared after that, which essentially looks at alternatives for addressing what you found in the investigation, and then a recommendation is made for what the proper alternative is for the contamination. Parallel with that, a risk assessment is prepared. ... Once that's done, a remedial action plan is prepared. ... That document goes before the public, for public review. Comments are taken from the public and then responded to by DTSC, and then a final remedial action plan is issued. ... Once that's done, you prepare designs based on the alternative that was selected. ... That's really in a nutshell. That occurs in each of the (operable units).
Q: To whom is the clean-up subcontracted?
A: What we do when we bring in contractors and consultants, is layer them. Morrison Knudsen is going to be running the project. They are the master contractor. We have a soil contractor that will be doing the soil remediation work. ... We have ground water experts who will be doing the ground water work. And then we have two environmental engineering firms that work for Santa Clarita LLC and they do the overview. They make certain that all of the plans that are being prepared are prepared appropriately. It's a double check...
Q: How long has RFI been in business, and where and when was Santa Clarita LLC, a subsidiary, formed?
A: RFI, under the name RFI, has been in business for about six years. ... RFI is based in Phoenix, Arizona. Santa Clarita LLC was formed to acquire the Santa Clarita Porta Bella property.
Q: Santa Clarita LLC: The "LLC" stands for "limited liability company," a designation which has made some, particularly on the City Council, nervous. What exactly does "limited liability" mean?
A: That means that it is a separate company, and that it accepts no liabilities from any other companies or any other sites that we may have. So that if we were working on another site, it wouldn't effect what's being done here and what this company does doesn't effect any other sites that we're currently working on...
Q: When were you informed of the need for Golden Valley Road?
A: I believe it was just prior to closing or just after closing (January)...
Q: The time frame for the road construction and the opening of Golden Valley High School seems convoluted. DTSC has yet to complete their investigation, yet the city planning commission and the council has been told that construction has to begin right away to accommodate the school's 2001 opening date. How can all these elements come together — safely — in time?
A: What we did is we completely changed our entire development plan. The area over which Golden Valley is going to run, was one of the last pieces that we were going to develop. We changed our plans, and now made it the first piece that is going to get cleaned, and make certain that it is safe. ... What we have done is put all of our assets in, and made certain that it can get done on time. The DTSC has also committed whatever people, whatever time is necessary, in order to review the submittals that we have made and get that done on time. We've actually broken OU1 (operable unit one), which we created for Golden Valley, into smaller portions so that if we can't provide the entire area to the builder who's going to construct the road, we can at least provide portions of it, safely, to this developer so he can start to grade the road, and store dirt if it's necessary. I think the bottom line is that nothing is going to be built until it's made safe. That's not in anyone's interest. The way that it's been separated out is that the smaller pieces allow it to be separated by drainage basins, so that that way where there really is contamination that we know of in that area, is isolated from the other portions that have been separated out. ... We have done a lot of jumping through hoops.
