The latest controversy to hit the city concerns a plan which is proposed outside the city limits, but which officials fear could have serious impacts on the region's air quality and water supplies. Transit Mixed Concrete Company is seeking approval to surface mine 83 million tons of sand and gravel from a 460-acre site over a 20-year period. The proposal has been submitted to the Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission, and is facing opposition from residents and the Santa Clarita City Council, which recently voted $50,000 to examine the company's draft Environmental Impact Report and is seeking support in its opposition from county, state and federal representatives.
Brian Mastin, environmental affairs manager for Transit Mixed, recently answered questions from Signal political reporter Chris Dickerson about the project and its impact on the Santa Clarita Valley.
QUESTION: Right off the bat, describe the project and its location.
ANSWER: It's located in Soledad Canyon, right off of Soledad Canyon Road, out of the river and south of the Antelope Valley Freeway and west of Agua Dulce Canyon Road. These materials are extracted from the site and processed into the sand and gravel products for cement and concrete. For example, the sidewalks and the roadways that you build contain construction aggregates of sand and gravel. What we do in this operation is extract these materials, process them and then truck them to the marketplace.
Q: Give us some background on Southdown Corporation, the parent company of Transit Mixed. It's based in Houston, Texas. Is it exclusively a mining operation?
A: Southdown is a major supplier of construction materials to the market, nationwide. We primarily are engaged in the business of producing cement and we have a number of operations throughout the United States. ... We also have aggregate production operations here in the San Gabriel Valley and in Simi Valley. We have ready-mix operations in Ventura County, L.A. County and Orange County. We also have ready-mix operations in Florida. Ready-mix concrete is the material that is delivered in the transit mixer trucks, which is comprised of a combination of Portland Cement, which is the dry, gray power, and it is combined with water and construction aggregates or sand and gravel to form ready-mix concrete, which is mixed in these mixer trucks and delivered to the site. Then that concrete is placed into curbs and gutters, freeways, sidewalks, all types of things.
Brian Mastin, environmental affairs manager for Transit Mixed Concrete Company, says the company's mining plan in Soledad Canyon would be of great benefit to Santa Clarita. [Photo by Dan Watson/The Signal]
Q: How long has Southdown (Transit Mixed) been intending to mine the site?
A: We bid on this site in 1989 and we were declared the successful bidder at that point in time. We've been in the project development/permit review process since that time.
Q: Who owns the property?
A: The property is what is known as a severed estate. The United States government used to own the property in its entirety. Back in 1934, they issued a patent, whereby they released the surface rights to the site, but retained the mineral rights to the site, with the right to re-enter and occupy so much of the surface that may be required to develop the mineral rights. The mountain itself, the gravel in the mountain, belongs to the United States government. The surface estate was acquired by Canyon Country Enterprises, which is (locally owned) Curtis Sand & Gravel.
Q: What's the relationship between Transit Mixed and Curtis Sand & Gravel?
A: The United States government wanted to put these minerals up to bid. They entered into litigation with Curtis Sand & Gravel on that issue, and there was a settlement agreement between the United States and Curtis Sand & Gravel, prior to (our) '89 bid. The '89 bid was the result of the settlement agreement, because the federal government had to put these minerals up to competitive bid in order to release them. There had been prior mining, but it became clear from a U.S. Supreme Court decision that those minerals were reserved to the United States, so the United States had to put them up to public bid. ... Because our dollar amount was higher, we were awarded the contents.
Q: What's the process the company has to go through to get permission to mine the site?
A: ... The County of Los Angeles is the lead agency for the state of California on the local permit process. Basically, we will go through the EIR process... and then when we get all the (public and government agency) comments, and they approve the mining and reclamation plans at the county level, then we can keep the same mining and reclamation plan at the federal level.
Q: Does Cal EPA get involved in this and if so, in what regard?
A: They do. The state also has some jurisdiction here. In fact, it's mainly under the state mining and geology board and the office of mine reclamation. They have an office of mine reclamation that reviews the mining and reclamation plants. We're getting reviewed at all three levels of government.
Q: How many rounds of testimony have you given so far to the County Regional Planning Commission?
A: We made one presentation. ... June 14 is the (commission's) field trip to the site, and July 14 is the next hearing, where opponents of the project can make their views known to the planning commission.
Q: What's the time frame for getting the mining operation under way, if it clears all the hurdles?
A: ... We would like to start operations next year, if we can get the approval.
Q: What benefit would it be to people in Santa Clarita for this operation to be there?
A: ... Aggregate is a necessary component in all types of public works construction, as well as private and commercial construction. ... You're going to have a very large population increase here of a quarter of a million people over the next 15 years, and that requires a lot of construction aggregate to provide the needs of those people— for traffic, developments primarily, and also for the actual private enterprises. We figure about 50 percent of our aggregate winds up in public works construction. I think all the taxpayers of the county and the taxpayers of this city and of this valley can be impacted on this issue. This is a bulk commodity. ... If we have to bring that material down from Palmdale, which is the only other location that would be able to provide it... then the transportation differential is like $3 a ton. On 56 million tons, you're looking at $170 million. ... It would definitely impact the cost of aggregate in this area. The other cost is an environmental cost. That is, to bring that material down, the 56 million tons that would otherwise be mined in this pre-existing location, would cause us to have to drive another 100 million truck miles. ... That generates a lot of diesel exhaust, over 2,000 tons of diesel exhaust over 20 years. ... It's critically important to urbanizing areas that they have close sources of material for both financial and environmental reasons.
Q: The city staff recently reviewed your company's draft EIR, and found some concerns regarding the operation's impact on the environment. What is your reaction?
A: I read that letter but I haven't analyzed it in detail yet. ... They are also continuing to review the EIR. In general, we find that the more people that look at the EIR, the more satisfied they become with the information in it. I think it's important to note that we are two miles east of the city limits and we're not within the sphere of influence for the city. ... Further, I would say that the fact that the state of California has designated these resources as regionally significant, to be protected from urban expansion, is an important issue. The reason why the state took the time and trouble to go out and identify these resources... was so that the need of the cities and counties could be met. The county, currently, is consuming 30 million tons a year of aggregate. This county is projected to be completely depleted of aggregate reserves by the year 2016.
Q: The mining operation will involve blasting?
A: That is correct.
Q: How much water will be used in the operation?
A: In phase one, we are projected to use 442 acre feet a year. That's equivalent to about the amount of water which would be utilized by a golf course. Each acre foot is about 326,000 gallons. Phase one is going to be for the first 10 years. In phase two... we would be at about 746 acre feet a year.
Q: Where will the water come from?
A: It comes from the underflow of the Santa Clara River. ... We have applied to the state water resources control board, division of water rights, for a permit to extract water from the underflow of the Santa Clara River, by using wells that are drilled down through the river aquifer.
Q: Is it Transit Mixed's position that such a large mining operation will have little or no impact on groundwater resources and air quality in the valley?
A: The water utilization has been determined under the environmental review process and EIR. ... We have committed to habitat protection programs for the riparian habitat, and the endangered three-spine stickleback fish, which lives downstream on the site. ... There's no significant impacts on downstream water users. ... On the issue of air quality, blasting is a component which is necessary in this situation because this particular (material) it's not just... a loose material which can be found in stream beds. ... The type of blasting we're doing is going to be a low-yield blasting, which is not like many mining operations. ... In terms of air quality impacts, we have mitigated all the impacts on this project, to the maximum extent feasible, including air quality. ... The air quality processes that we use are the best available control technologies on the processing plant itself to keep the dust down, control of the blasting operations, and control of all operations during high wind conditions.
Q: Your company representatives have attended several public meeting with residents. What's been the response to the plan?
A: We have met with a number of different groups, the Agua Dulce Town Council, the Sand Canyon Homeowners Association, the Pinetree people. We're scheduled to meet with the Acton Town Council. We have had a range of reactions form the people. Some people have not been too concerned, some people have been concerned.
Q: Residents have also expressed concerns about the truck traffic on State Route 14. Is it correct that you'll have heavy trucks running 24 hours?
A: That is correct. There's going to be truck traffic on that freeway one way or another. San Fernando Valley is producing and consuming nine million tons a year, about a third of the county's consumption. ... The only other source of supply is Palmdale so, from the intersection of Soledad Canyon Road and the Antelope Valley Freeway, the trucks are going to be on there with or without a (local) project. There is going to be more truck traffic without a project because there will just have to be more trucks going all the way up to Palmdale. The easiest way to talk about truck traffic is just outbound trips, and on our phase one, we would have 347 outbound trucks per day, on average. And during the peak morning hour, we would have 29 trucks going out during the peak period. That road is not very busy during the middle of the day, but there is a peak period of commuters that use Soledad Canyon as well as the Antelope Valley Freeway. Phase two, 582 trucks per day, outbound.
Q: Why this location?
A: Mother Nature just didn't put aggregates just anywhere. This region has been blessed with good aggregate resources. ... This particular site was chosen by the Bureau of Land Management to be offered for sand and gravel sale because of its setting. Because the state had designated it as a regionally significant construction resource area, and that is based upon two criteria, the first is the material quality marketable, and they do a physical determination of the marketability of that material. Second, is (whether) that material potentially developable from a land use basis. (Whether it's) available to be developed.
Q: What are the plans for lowering the ridge line?
A: Under our proposed plan, the ridge line will be reduced 125 feet on average. Two hundred feet from the highest point to the lowest point would be the maximum. But on average the ridge line would come down 125 feet.
Q: Is the federal government supportive of this operation? And has anybody from your company spoken with U.S. Rep Howard "Buck" McKeon or any representatives from his office?
A: Definitely. At the last hearing the federal government requested that the planning commission approve the project as proposed. I have not (spoken with Buck McKeon) but I'm sure our company has. I know that there have been meetings with him over the last decade on a routine basis, about the process.
