A state environmental agency obtained a search warrant to look for evidence of destruction of a state-protected flower on The Newhall Land and Farming Co.’s planned Newhall Ranch site.
The California Department of Fish and Game asked the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office to issue a permit allowing the agency to scour a portion of the site for the San Fernando Valley Spineflower— a species once believed extinct— and “for the unlawful take of an endangered species” and “to ensure the protection of any existing populations.”
The district attorney’s office granted the request last week, and the agency spent three days collecting samples, taking ground and aerial photographs, and creating digital and topographical maps.
Newhall Ranch is planned as a 22, 000-home community in a 19-square-mile region west of Interstate 5.
The spineflower was discovered on the site in May 2000, and Newhall Land reported it to the fish and game department. It has since received state protection as an endangered species.
According to the warrant, the agency believes Newhall Land tried to destroy the flower’s habitat when it illegally graded part of the site last September.
“(It) is my opinion that the cultivation is another ruse to destroy habitat that meets the requirement of sustaining populations of the (spineflower),” stated Penelope Liotta, a licensed biologist with the Department of Fish and Game, in the warrant.
The San Fernando Valley Spineflower is a member of the buckwheat family that blooms with white and yellow blossoms. The cactus-like species is considered an herb that is native to California and was presumed extinct in the 1920s.
The county Department of Public Works cited Newhall Land for grading without a permit in November, on a portion of the site called Airport Mesa.
Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer said the agency’s allegations are false.
“We have continued farming operations that have been historically done on that site,” she said.
Lauffer said agave crops and cattle grazing still occur on the site in question.
Liotta states in the warrant that Newhall Land has failed to obtain grading and erosion plans, which it was supposed to do by Jan. 11. Lauffer said the company is waiting for a state conservation agency to finish its portion of the erosion plan.
“We’re in the process of getting that permit,” she said.
The warrant also implies that Newhall Land didn’t cordon off the flower’s habitat like the company said it would when the species was discovered in May 2000.
Liotta states that in a flyover the property in late December, no protective barriers were spotted near the habitat. Liotta also states that she made numerous requests to Newhall Land to get on the property and observe the protective barriers.
In January, a Newhall Land representative e-mailed a photo of protective barriers to Liotta, the warrant states, that showed horizontally-placed redwood poles protecting the habitat.
“There is no evidence of weathering on the poles,” Liotta states. “Poles that had been exposed to two seasons of winter would exhibit uneven coloration due to fading. It is my opinion that these poles were new and had recently been embedded into the ground.”
Lauffer said Liotta’s assertions are wrong and the company installed barriers after the flower’s discovery.
“We knew that it was an issue of importance,” she said.
Fish and Game spokesman Steve Martarano said he couldn’t comment on the investigation or offer a timeline when it would be concluded.
If the agency finds any wrongdoing, it can file charges against Newhall Land with the district attorney’s office.
* * *
Members of the local environmental community weren’t surprised with the department’s findings.
“I don’t think this kind of behavior is a surprise to us,” said Lynne Plambeck, vice president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment. “They don’t have a very good record protecting habitats.”
Plambeck said the local ecology needs to be preserved to maintain a strong community.
“It’s all a combination that creates a healthy community. When you have a developer that disregards the health of the habitat, they are disregarding the health of the community,” she said.
Barbara Wampole, vice chair of the Friends of the Santa Clara River, agreed.
“Whatever we’ve done over the last few years, we’ve been notifying (the government agencies) about when we think there’s a problem,” she said.
Wampole said she sent a letter to the fish and game department one day before the agency requested the warrant.
“I’m glad the resource agencies are stepping in and doing something about it,” said Plambeck.
* * *
Newhall Ranch has been in and out of courtrooms for the past two years.
A slew of environmental groups and Ventura County sued Newhall Land and Los Angeles County, claiming the project’s environmental documents were flawed.
The case was moved to a neutral court. A Kern County judge told the landowner to re-evaluate the traffic and water documents related to the project before Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors could approve or deny the project.
The planning commission unanimously approved the project in October.
However, upon completion of the supplemental documentation, a lawsuit against the Castaic Lake Water Agency halted Newhall Ranch from moving ahead because a state court declared the agency’s water plan concerning the project was inadequate. CLWA based its water supply projections on those contained in a separate agreement that was deemed inadequate by the state Supreme Court.
The board of supervisors postponed a vote in January because of the CLWA lawsuit but is scheduled to consider the project on Aug. 27, depending on approval of all water documents.
If Newhall Ranch is given the green light, it will be the largest planned community ever approved by the county.
