A judge Friday ordered Joshua Sherman of Newhall to undergo a psychiatric evaluation before he is sentenced in the death of aspiring artist Michael Barnett.
Sherman, 19, will be transferred to state prison for a 90-day diagnostic study, which could result in a recommendation that he be granted probation or be sentenced to prison.
Deputy District Attorney Marsh Goldstein said orders for such studies are "a rarity" and that the psychiatric workup would be made without regard to any issues of punishment.
Sherman was scheduled for sentencing Friday. But after defense attorney Leslie Abramson requested -- and was granted -- the diagnostic study, Judge Ronald S. Coen postponed sentencing until the evaluation is completed.
Goldstein said Abramson asked for the evaluation because the results of a probation report were not favorable to Sherman.
"They asked for it because they disagree with the factual findings of the probation report," Goldstein said. "They disagree with the probation summary of what happened and its lack of focus on the defendant and the defendant's version of what happened."
Abramson did not respond to a request for comment.
Barnett died April 14, 1997, one day after he was found unconscious and badly beaten in a parking lot at Grace Baptist Church in Placerita Canyon. Sherman surrendered a few days later and was charged with murder.
Prosecutors maintained that Sherman killed Barnett because he was jealous and obsessed with Barnett's girlfriend, Roxanne Roy. The two men met in the early morning hours of April 13 in the church parking lot and fought, resulting in Sherman inflicting fatal blunt force trauma to Barnett's head and then leaving him there to die, prosecutors said.
But Abramson argued Sherman fought in self-defense, believing Barnett was a martial arts expert. He had no duty to help Barnett when the fight was over, she said.
After more than a three-week trial in San Fernando Superior Court, a jury convicted Sherman on May 22 of involuntary manslaughter for his involvement in Barnett's death, rejecting counts of second degree murder and voluntary manslaughter. Coen withdrew Sherman's bail and remanded him into custody.
Sherman faces up to four years in state prison on or before Sept. 11, his sentencing date, on the completion of his psychiatric evaluation.
