Recently released findings by the state Legislative Analyst's Office have added more fuel to the debate over the car tax repeal.
The LAO's analysis, released Thursday, stated Gov. Pete Wilson's proposed vehicle license fee cut would result in budget deficits upwards of $850 million beginning in the year 2000. Wilson's proposal to cut the fee by 75 percent, starting with a 50 percent cut on Jan. 1, would amount to a $3.6 billion tax cut when fully in place.
The findings predicted the current $4 billion surplus -- which sparked calls for the car tax repeal -- would be used up and the budget would eventually run into a deficit. Such a deficit could cause lawmakers to cut other areas of spending to balance the budget.
PETE WILSON
Wants Tax Cut
Republicans supportive of the car tax reduction decried the findings, saying a cut is possible without disrupting funding for other programs. Opposing Democrats used the report to fuel their call for more educational spending instead of a tax cut.
"These new figures confirm our worst fears," said Speaker of the Assembly Antonio Villaraigosa, D-Los Angeles. "The Governor's massive tax cut proposal will make it impossible for Californians to ever provide their children with the kind of public schools they deserve."
The LAO, a nonpartisan governmental office which analyzes the state's budget issues, based its findings on projected growth and spending over the next five years. The LAO did not foresee the $4 billion surplus expected this year by Wilson. Instead, its estimate showed $1 billion in extra revenue.
Based on that, the LAO predicted a deficit of $419 million in the fiscal year 1999-2000, growing to $848 million during the fiscal year 2000-2001 and reaching over $1.1 billion the following year when the car tax is completely phased out.
Assemblyman George Runner, vice chair of the Assembly Budget Committee, said he believes the analyst's figures are flawed.
Runner, R-Lancaster, said the analyst's report makes erroneous assumptions about future economic growth and state spending. The LAO's revenue projections are too low, and its cost of living estimates for state workers are too high, he said.
Wilson's plan, however, already contains a merit increase, Runner said.
"We predict a $3.2 billion surplus with the governor's fully implemented car tax program," he said. "We think there's plenty of room for car tax and raises."
