Court Commissioner Thomas White on Thursday ordered three Canyon Country men to stand trial on charges of assault with a deadly weapon, rejecting allegations of attempted murder in a reputed drive-by shooting in March.
Alberto Juarez, 18, Raul Ballesteros, 19, and Miguel Hernandez, 21, were held to answer on the lesser assault charge with the allegation that the three are gang members who used a weapon in the commission of a crime inflicting great bodily injury.
The allegations, if found true, would still add 25 years to life to any sentence should they be convicted, court officials said. The enhancement is possible under a new law that went into effect Jan. 1 targeting gang-related crimes.
"They are still facing virtually the same amount of time as before because of the gang allegation," said Deputy District Attorney David Jacobs, specially assigned to the case. "The way the case is charged — that the reason the crime was committed was for the furtherance of their gang and the infliction of great bodily injury in the use of the weapon — is still intact."
Authorities contend the three drove Ballesteros' parents' tan 4-door Honda to the 19300 block of Stillmore Street on March 6, pulled out a shotgun and opened fire on rival gang member Arturo Romero in an act of retaliation. Romero, struck in the neck and shoulder, testified as a hostile witness in a preliminary hearing Thursday in Newhall Municipal Court.
Slouching in his seat on the witness stand, Romero denied being shot from a moving car that sped away and denied knowing any of the defendants, including Ballesteros who lives on his street.
"You don't want to be here, do you?" Jacobs asked in direct examination.
Romero: "No."
Jacobs: "Why not?"
Romero: "I just don't want to be here."
Jacobs: "Were you shot?"
Romero: "Yeah."
Jacobs: "Had you had a confrontation earlier with the defendants?"
Romero: "I never saw them before in my life."
Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Deputy Tony Miano, lead investigator in the case, said Romero recanted prior statements made to deputies because "he's more concerned about being labeled a rat than anything. He did what I'd expect a gang member to do."
Miano testified as a gang expert that the shooting was the result of ongoing rivalry and retaliation between the two Canyon Country gangs.
Miano said Juarez told him he went with his cousin (Ballesteros) and another alleged gang member in the Honda to Stillmore Street where they saw several rival gang members. The third man got out and chased Romero, who allegedly picked up a bottle and threw it, hitting the man in the head.
Just before 11 p.m., Ballesteros and Juarez, who was allegedly driving, returned with Hernandez, Miano testified.
"Alberto said Miguel and Raul got the shotgun from the trunk," Miano said. "They passed the weapon back and forth, ending up with Mr. Ballesteros. Mr. Juarez was told to slow down. Mr. Ballesteros rolled down the window and took the weapon and fired twice into a group of people."
Miano further testified he overheard a conversation between Juarez and Ballesteros while they were in custody.
"They discussed Mr. Juarez's testimony," Miano said. "Ballesteros suggested he should lie and say he was forced to say what he did because he was scared, and that (Hernandez) wasn't there."
Ballesteros allegedly told Juarez "don't let these ... cops brainwash you. Just say you made a mistake," Miano said.
Under cross examination by Jack Janofsky, attorney for Ballesteros, Miano admitted he also had heard conflicting versions of the story, including one in which Hernandez fired the shotgun.
Miano testified he did not know whether the car was moving or stopped at the time of the shooting, whether the shooter was inside or outside the car, whether Ballesteros or Hernandez pulled the trigger, or whether the shooting occurred immediately after the bottle-throwing incident.
"This is a case that is fraught with factual discrepancies," Janofsky said. "Detective Miano was very forthright and said, 'We don't know what happened.' The interesting thing is that they have evidence that goes both ways.
"This case, in my opinion, can not be proved," said Janofsky, whose bid to put on an affirmative defense Thursday was denied because prosecutors had not been informed of his intended witness.
Outside the courtroom, Janofsky denied Miano's allegation that Ballesteros is a gang member.
"You can't label everybody a gang member because they know somebody who is a gang member," he said. "We'll attack that at trial. He's not a gang member."
Juarez, Ballesteros and Hernandez are being held in lieu of $500,000 bail pending arraignment July 10 in San Fernando Superior Court. A fourth defendant, 19-year-old Daniel Proschuk, is accused of harboring Hernandez while he was a fugitive and remains free on $15,000 bond.
