Heading the biggest school district in the Santa Clarita Valley is a big job. Robert Lee has been in the thick of it for three years.
Lee is superintendent of the William S. Hart Union High School District: four junior highs, four mainstream high schools, two alternative high schools, nearly 14,000 students and lots of issues.
Born in Long Beach in 1945, Lee moved with his family to Sunnymead, Calif., now Moreno Valley, as a toddler. He moved to Utah as a teen-ager.
Lee, 52, began his career in education as a teacher and later as a school administrator. He returned to Moreno Valley as the superintendent of its unified school district, a position he held for a decade before assuming the Hart district's top post in June 1995.
Signal education reporter Nicole M. Campbell sat down with the father of seven and grandfather of two, asking his opinion on issues including school boundaries, the often complicated relationship between districts and developers and classroom curriculum.
* * *
QUESTION: What's the hardest thing about being superintendent?
ANSWER: Attempting to keep the professional and educational aspect in a perspective that allows the teacher to teach and the community to understand that each teacher is there on behalf of the kid.
Q: We like to think our civic leaders are real people too. What are your interests outside of the job?
A: Be with my family, play a little golf, go to cultural events, musical things, especially relating to the school district. A good date is dinner and a movie with my wife; we're very common people. I like studying the Scriptures. Being with my family is probably first and foremost. We have two grandkids and a third on the way. Seeing your child become a parent is a wonderful, wonderful thing.
Q: How do you forge relationships with your employees, especially teachers?
A: One thing that is difficult is the detachment. It's not a common practice for 650 teachers to walk through the building on a weekly basis — that's just impractical. I try and go out to the campuses. I try and be present at school functions. I periodically attend faculty meetings. My calendar governs my life. It's a more difficult task than I would want it to be, to break away, to get out, but that's how it is.
Q: What's one thing that has proven false about education that you held as a truism when you first started your career?
A: I will tell you one. I remember my junior year in college, probably spring of '67. I can still remember sitting with my buddies in the cafeteria, and we were talking about our future and talking about what we wanted. I already knew who my wife was going to be, I was dating her and married her. And I thought, if I can make $24,000 a year, it would take care of all my worldly needs. And at that time, $24,000 was a very comfortable living. And I got my first teaching job, and I was making around $6,300 a year. And in time, I surpassed that $24,000, and I was still short of reaching my dream. And that's probably what pushed me into administration.
Q: You've been superintendent for three years, but only recently moved to the SCV. What's your take on the interaction between various neighborhoods out here?
A: We are the city of Santa Clarita by name, but we are separate communities in reality. We're separated by name and title — Canyon Country, Saugus, Valencia, Newhall, Friendly Valley, Happy Valley — we're separated by gated communities, we're separated by new and old. There are more things that separate us, from a community standpoint, than unite us.
Q: What troubles you most about the boundary situation in the Hart district?
A: Boundary change is the most common approach to dealing with growth, and many parents don't want to deal with the change most often with their kid. In my former district (Moreno Valley Unified School District), we went from seven to 22 boundaries, one junior high school to nine, one high school to four high schools, in nine years.
Change is, most of the time, good. It's not dangerous. It gives us a chance to unite and reunite with each other. And kids get through that (change) in a matter of days — a new school, a new teacher, a new friend. A guy sees a new girl on campus, and it's all downhill from there. (Laughs.)
Q: If you had a magic wand, what would be your ideal boundary situation?
A: We could deal with the size equity, making sure there's equity in ethnicity, socioeconomic equality.
Q: Did you agree with the board's recent decision to allow children from the S&S tract to stay at Arroyo Seco Junior High and Saugus High? Why or why not?
A: My agreement or disagreement to me is not as critical as feeling that whatever was done was done with the best of process, and I don't feel that it was as good as it could have been. We should have put up a few more caution signs along the way, and I'll fault myself for that. The community that questions the board's decision doesn't understand that the impact won't happen in 1998-99. It will happen the year after. I think the impact will be 50 kids the first year and maybe 90 kids the next year, and the first year isn't this year.
Q: What do you think about unification of all the districts out here at some point in the future?
A: There's a side to me that's an advocate of unification, and there's a side to me that, having been here for three years, knows the elementary school districts and realizes they're competent. I think that sometimes, with unification, you can get too big, too fast. I saw it in my former district. We went from 9,300 to 32,000 kids ... but I think it's possible there will be two or three unifications out here (in the future.)
Q: Do you foresee multi-track in the Hart district's future?
A: At least for the junior highs ... I really suspect there's a good chance some of our yet-to-be built schools will be year-round.
Q: Did your predecessor give you any advice? What advice would you give your successor?
A: There were actually three predecessors — Dr. (Dan) Hanigan, Dr. Walt Swanson and of course, Dr. (Clyde) Smyth. Clyde's been a tremendous support. I can pick up the phone any time and ask him what he was feeling during certain times.
Q: How would you characterize the status of negotiations with The Newhall Land and Farming Co. (over the Newhall Ranch project)?
A: We'll hopefully be posting for a meeting on (Thursday) to accept a mitigation agreement, so when I say it's close ... we'll know probably by Monday for sure. I mean the terms and conditions have been met, been agreed to. It's working on the language now and all the exhibits, and it's hoped that we'll be done by Monday, Monday afternoon, and then have a meeting on Thursday to sign it.
Editor's note: An agreement was reached Friday, with details to be finalized
Q: We often hear about the negative aspect of development in terms of schools. What benefits do you see to growth as it relates to education?
A: First off, there are more benefits than there are negatives. And when I say more, I mean that the benefits to growth, for the most part, are long-term. The negatives sometimes are short-term. Many of the negatives surround change, and you talked about a boundary issue, that creates change. That sometimes creates some anxieties and all, but in the long run, it's a plus. New school, new teacher, new friends, new opportunities. I think at Valencia High School there were kids there that were provided educational, leadership, athletic, academic opportunities that, chances are, they would not have had as much if they'd been at a larger school. So that first school, that smaller school, they create a culture, that ability to become the first of anything: the first student body president, the first cheerleading squad, the first academic decathlon team, the first. Those are memories, high school memories, that those kids will have that other kids will not be afforded. The other thing about growth is you get the infusion of new parents, the new views. You get, often, that whole melting pot concept, which from a world or a lifetime experience is good for kids. ... I grew up in a military community where I lived in the same town where I went to elementary school, went to Riverside in junior high and for my first year in high school, but I went to school with kids that were military, and they would talk about going to school in Nebraska, New York, Alaska, Italy, Germany and quite frankly those kids were better rounded, as far as dealing with life, than I was. They were better ready for it, the aspect of life and its changes and its challenges, and so growth brings that.
Q: In the wake of the recent fatal school shootings in places like Oregon and Arkansas, there have been suggestions of implementing prayer, or at least some spiritual or moral program, in schools. What's your opinion?
A: Anything that would go on of that nature, first is probably going to be informal, and needs to take into consideration the different denominational religious views and feelings that the community we serve has regarding prayer. Prayer is a way of expressing internal feelings for one person, it's a way of conversing with a deity for another. And for one person, one type of prayer is offensive to the other. And in some cases, prayer is more ritualistic, a ritual rite. For another person, it's more just an expression of your soul. Prayer is a personal issue. I believe that there are people in this community that pray for the quality, pray for our teachers and pray for even myself and those feelings of expression are certainly appreciated and I think have an effect upon our success, upon our abilities. I believe in, deeply, the value of prayer, in my personal life and even my professional life, but as far as anything that would go on in the school system, it's going to be more informal and collected around kids of common ground, common faith, common beliefs, something of a voluntary nature.
Q: How would you like to improve academic programs in the Hart district?
A: Obviously, one of the factors of our academic program has to be centered around making sure that our academic programs are realistic, or that they're real life. We're teaching something that is going to challenge the mind, expand the thinking processes and be some kind of connection to the next stage in life, or the next opportunity that comes along and, where in the elementary areas you're establishing foundations — foundations in mathematics, foundations in reading, foundations in your oral and language development — here we're building the walls, and we're starting to decorate, if you will, the home and making it a presentation for someone to come in and be a part of. Providing a curriculum that is challenging to all the needs is, by far, one of the greatest challenges that any teacher has. You have a heterogeneous class of 32 kids, and you have ability levels times 32, and you have cultural issues, sometimes, maybe not 32, but times five or six, you have economic issues, you have kids with tremendous desires to want to learn, and then you have, on the other end of the scale, the kid that is totally apathetic about life, and you're expected to have every kid at grade level. That's just a tremendous, tremendous challenge for a classroom teacher.
Q: What about social opportunities for students — how would you improve upon those?
A: Certainly our school-to-career program and job shadowing, bringing the real world to the classroom and the classroom out to the real world. I think we've talked about and we're exploring having, as part of a graduation requirement, a community service component to A) let the community realize that we have some wonderful, wonderful kids that are not necessarily those that they see on the 5 o'clock news or that they read about in the tabloids or sometimes get stuck on the front page, and with these kids come some wonderful parents, and they are, in their own right, very giving and very caring. It amazes me how many of our students are swimming instructors, lifeguards, AYSO coaches, give music lessons, baby-sit, do errands for senior citizens — I mean, a lot of our kids are into that, and it's primarily because of the focus of the home, and I think we could support that better, by having some sort of community service component.
Q: What do you think of the drug-sniffing dogs that will be on campus periodically beginning this fall?
A: Deterrent. Serious. Sad that we've got to get into it, but it's also a societal issue. We were talking today at lunch how overall, we believe that the school district in this last year has maintained or excelled in its quality of education, and we've done it in an environment where we've kept more kids here because our dropout rate has been reduced. We have a larger population, and many of those kids have only been here for, now, a year or two, so they're still kind of socially trying to get adjusted to the community. Our teachers are doing that in an environment out there that is more difficult to be good today than it was two years ago. There are greater influences — drugs, alcohol, the things that a better economy brings, the concerns and fears that surround the gang culture or the gang environment. And so kids are living in a world that has more detractors today than ever. For us to really truly believe we're doing (something) effective, in some cases a quantified better job, our hats go off to our teachers. Our hats go off to the community, to our parents because of their ability to keep their kids focused. Now the sad part of that is that isn't every kid. If we could get every kid, we could be a little utopia.
Q: How do you try and ease the bureaucracy of a school district?
A: First off, I try to keep as much of the bureaucracy away from the educational setting. If I am successful — I believe I am in this area — as much as possible, keep the politics away from the school. If I can keep it centered here, then by my dealing with it the principals, the teachers, the campus supervisors and all, they can deal with kids. They can deal with the education.
Q: What are trends on campus that leave you shaking your head?
A: The social acceptance of immorality that our society has portrayed in so many different ways to where the innocent minds of kids see it and want to enact it, and don't even understand that they're transgressing, when in fact they think that they are doing what is their freedom of expression. Is it connected with the right factors, the factors of sensitivity and love and compassion, when they're connected with self-satisfaction all those kinds of things? And then the knowledge that our community, and our kids within that community on any given Saturday night, that there are kids who are socially abusing alcohol, which becomes the welcome mat for drugs and then intimate sexual activities and everything else that leads to it. Many of our teen-agers have not left a whole lot of excitement into their adult life. They've had those experiences at times, when in my mind they were not mature enough to deal with it, but they had. And when maturity comes along and the mind and the body is ready for it, in some cases it's not what it should be. And it's anybody's kids. It's my kids, it's my next-door neighbor's kids, the minister's kids. The influences are tremendous.
Q: If someone was considering a job in teaching, how would you persuade them to take up the career?
A: I would try to share with them many of my experiences. Some of my many successes and even some of my failures. And I would let them know that there are many, many self-fulfilling prophecies and rewards in teaching that go beyond the paycheck, the weekends off, the vacations. There are tender, tender moments that good teachers have with kids and with parents that by the end of your career you will have filled a journal, you will fill a diary. If you were one who was creative in writing you would write books on those life experiences. Teaching is, in my estimation, one of the most rewarding experiences. Whether it's teaching your little kid to walk and experiencing that to teaching them to say their first word, to watching them get on the bus as a kindergartner to the ultimate of watching them walk across the stage as a senior in high school. There are many, many emotions attached to the educational system and to the educating of kids and to be a part of that, its ups and down, its highs and lows and goods and bads. To be a teacher, if someone realizes at the ultimate moment, you can change a life. And we have teachers who do that. They capture that moment many, many days of their career.
