The Bureau of Land Management announced plans Friday to further investigate the discovery of southwestern arroyo toad tadpoles near the Transit Mixed Concrete Co. mining project in Soledad Canyon.
In response to a city of Santa Clarita study, and because of pressure from local and federal legislators, the BLM has asked U.S. Fish and Wildlife to prepare a supplemental biological assessment that will evaluate potential impacts on the arroyo toad, according to officials from the BLM.
But whether new environmental studies will be limited to the arroyo toad or to all endangered species on or near the site became a point of contention Friday afternoon, with city officials and BLM officials disagreeing whether it will be the entire Environmental Impact Statement or just part of the statement that will be redone based on the new information.
BLM State director Mike Poole said in a statement that the process will involve a thorough review of the recent findings by a city-commissioned biologist that revealed three clusters of tadpoles in separate locations. The BLM will then send those findings to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which will commission its own study on the impacts to only the arroyo toad.
But city officials say different.
A press release issued by the city Friday afternoon stated that the BLM and Fish and Wildlife “confirmed with the city” that the agencies plan to “reinitiate their biological assessment and opinion on the entire Transit Mixed Concrete mining project...”
“This is contradictory to a press release issued today” by the BLM, the release stated.
Stacy Miller, city intergovernmental relations officer said in conversations between the entities, the city was led to believe that impact studies would be done on all endangered species, not just the arroyo toad.
“In those conversations, our impression was that the BLM would be reinitiating surveys on all biological opinions,” Stacy Miller said. “Their EIS stated there were no toads, our concern is what else could have been missed.”
“We’re saying here’s one example. You should go out and do the rest of the surveys,” Williams added.
And while the EIS made mention of the spineflower and the unarmored stickleback, Williams said other endangered species, including the arroyo toad, were never studied.
Jan Bedrosian, with the BLM, said the existence of arroyo toads was discussed in the project’s EIS.
“They were referenced in the EIS and in the Record of Decision we acknowledged that issues did exist regarding the arroyo toads,” Bedrosian said.
However, during the federal environmental studies, no toads were discovered on site, Bedrosian said.
Whether new studies would be limited to the arroyo toad or to all species could affect the timeline of the project.
Poole said it will take about 30 days to complete the review of the city study, which will then be submitted to Fish and Wildlife Service along with a request for a formal consultation.
Fish and Wildlife will then prepare a biological opinion, reviewing BLM’s assessment and determining whether or not the project would have adverse effects on the arroyo toad.
“... This new information identifying tadpoles in a pool on the site clearly needs to be evaluated. Until we receive a formal biological opinion from the (Fish and Wildlife Service), it would be premature to speculate what effect this discovery will have on the project,” Poole said.
But if the studies are not limited to the arroyo toad, it could take much longer.
“A biological assessment of the species as called for (by the city) will require that the species be thoroughly studied,” Deputy City Manager Rick Putnam said. “This process, if done accordingly to the Endangered Species Act, will take much longer than suggested by the BLM, even if this project is expedited.”
If studies were needed on more than one species, that timeline would be based on the nesting patterns of the species, Miller said.
“Our concern is that if the EIS is re-initiated , we want to make sure it’s done at the appropriate times,” Miller said. “The fact is some of these species may not be visible during different times of the year.”
But despite the delays, both current and potential, involved in this process, city officials say their intent is not to bog down the project— they just want to see that all impacts to the local environment are studied and fully mitigated.
“The city’s not in this to delay the project,” Miller said. “We’re in this for all environmental studies to be done properly.”
“We are concerned that they are done correctly,” she added.
U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, wrote to the BLM Thursday asking for the review by the BLM and the Fish and Wildlife service, citing the recent discovery of the toads, said the new studies will accurately show the project’s impacts to endangered species within the Santa Clarita Valley.
“I appreciate the BLM’s responsiveness to my request to review the Transit Mixed Concrete proposal,” McKeon said. “Environmental laws must be enforced consistently based on sound science and fact. In this case, there can be little dispute that this massive mining project at least poses a potential threat to an endangered species.”
And in light of the new information, Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich has taken the position that the BLM should open the EIS up for more public input, and that the entire document should be re-circulated .
“These issues need to be fully investigated,” Conal McNamara, aide to Antonovich, said. “It makes sense to try and do it right,” McNamara said.
“We also want to make sure that the public has some input in this,” Antonovich spokesman Chris Dickerson added.
Bedrosian said the BLM has not committed as to whether the environmental documents will be re-circulated for more public comment, based on any new data.
“We have not made a decision,” Bedrosian said. “That depends on the information Fish and Wildlife gives us based on what their studies show.”
“The biologists opinions will determine if the impacts will be significant enough to jeopardize the survival of the species,” she added.
Transit Mixed has proposed to mine 78 million tons of material to yield 56.1 million tons of sand and gravel in Soledad Canyon over a 20-year period.
The city of Santa Clarita and other stakeholders have contended that a project of that size and scope would be detrimental to the ecosystem of the Santa Clarita Valley, including the Santa Clara River— a key source of groundwater to the community.
The project was approved on the federal level in August 2000 by the BLM, which owns the mineral rights to the land. That approval was based on the completion of a public review period for the Environmental Impact Statement, a federal version of the Environmental Impact Report required by the county.
Based on the contract between the BLM and Transit Mixed, the company has agreed to pay $28 million in fees to the government, of which roughly $560,000 would go to the county, according to EIS.
The site would also include a ready-mixed facility that will produce Portland cement concrete for construction in the local market area.
The remaining aggregates would be shipped to other parts of greater Los Angeles, among them other ready-mixed concrete facilities in the San Fernando Valley.
The city of Santa Clarita filed suit earlier this year under the endangered species act against the BLM and Fish and Wildlife regarding violations provided under this act. The city’s complaint is that those two entities did not follow the mandates of the Endangered Species Act in approving the BLM’s lease for the project.
