A Santa Clarita resident escorted by a sheriff's deputy from the speaker's podium at a City Council meeting has filed a lawsuit against the city and Mayor Jan Heidt, alleging his constitutional rights of free speech and equal protection were violated.
During the public participation portion of an April 21 council meeting, Heidt directed John Steffen, 70, of Saugus, to refrain from making personal attacks against Mayor Pro Tem Jo Anne Darcy. When Steffen persisted, saying Darcy had run a dirty re-election campaign, he was removed from the speaker's podium.
"I started working on (the lawsuit the next day)," Steffen said. "It's not only about my rights. If my rights can be violated, anyone's rights can. I'm fighting for the rights of citizens to speak under the First Amendment of the Constitution."
Steffen filed the civil rights violations case in federal court. His attorney, Carol Sobel, said she is looking for the court to issue a preliminary injunction against the city to stop them from "enforcing the ad-hoc policy."
Sobel said Steffen had a right to attack government officials at a public meeting and that he could have called Darcy any name in the book.
"It's not (Heidt's) job to prevent slander," Sobel said. "In California, we have a special statute that provides an absolute privilege to anything you say in a government body."
Spokeswoman Gail Ortiz confirmed the lawsuit, but directed questions regarding it to Carl Newton, the city's attorney. Newton could not be reached for comment.
However, Tom Altmayer, the city's assistant attorney, said in April Heidt acted within her rights when she had Steffen removed. He has said Heidt is allowed to stop someone from speaking if that person could cause disruption by his comments or slanderous statements.
Three other speakers at the same meeting spoke about the election during the public speaking portion and also criticized Darcy. None of them were asked to leave the podium.
Steffen, who has lived in the area for 20 years, said he frequently has spoken at council meetings in the past, as well as other elected board meetings. He said most of his comments are made — directly or indirectly — against The Newhall Land and Farming Co.
According to a copy of Steffen's suit, he is seeking an injunction prohibiting the city from enforcing a policy, practice or custom that restricts speech on the basis of its critical political content during the public speaking portion of the meeting; a court declaration that a restriction of comments during the public speaking portion violated Steffen's right of free speech and right to petition the government; a declaration that such a prohibition is a violation of Steffen's rights to equal protection under the 14th Amendment; and a declaration that his removal from the podium under the threat of force violated his state rights.
Steffen is also seeking an unspecified amount of damages from the city, as well as personal costs and attorneys' fees.
While Steffen said this is the first time he's filed a law suit, he has had a previous run-in with a city official. In December 1995, he filed charges against Ortiz for assaulting him while he stood in front of City Hall during a city-sponsored 5K run.
Steffen was carrying a sign that read "Brother can you spare $3 million," protesting a recent City Council decision. The district attorney's office dropped the charges against Ortiz, who was five months pregnant at the time.
