George Caravalho is the only city manager Santa Clarita has ever had. As the city's chief executive officer who carries out policies, he's presided over ten years of favorable economic development in the area and low crime. Before coming here, he was the city manager at Bakersfield (1984-88) and San Clemente (1980-84). He just celebrated his 10th anniversary as Santa Clarita's boss, an anomaly for city managers, who are subject to the whim of councils that frequently change personnel. In fact, before coming to Santa Clarita, Caravalho was fired by a newly elected council. A couple of weeks after Caravalho celebrated his anniversary, we caught up with him and asked him about the management style that has made him so successful here, as well as his experiences here and at other places.
* * *
QUESTION: You've worked in five different cities before you came here. What's unique about Santa Clarita?
ANSWER: It's got tailwinds. That is that there are a lot of positive forces that are kind of pushing you along to get things done. People are interested in seeing things happen. You don't have a lot of the restraints that you find in many governments, where there are numerous obstacles. They spend tons of time processing. ... Many governments, that's all they do. They process, they process, they don't accomplish anything. Well the thing that I like about Santa Clarita is that we have positive energy. We have an enthusiastic council and work force. We have great people. And many of them want to get things done. So we see things happen and a lot of people are happy about that.
Q: Your philosophy, according to a newspaper report, is "if it's not broke don't fix it." But when you came here in June 1988 Santa Clarita hadn't figuratively been built, so how did you go about figuring out the direction this new city needed to go in?
A: I think I used to say "if it ain't broke, break it." Because like in Bakersfield it was always, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it," and I got so tired of hearing that. When you read about the gurus, in terms of public management like Tom Peters, they always talk about rapid change and anticipation and that the competition and the challenges that we face today, you cannot be reacting to it. You cannot be reactionary, otherwise you're going to be behind the curve. You take ... youth issues, of which I'm a strong proponent about, if I sit and wait until we have tremendous gangs and problems like that, we're going to be reacting to a problem that is going to be very difficult to overcome. But seeing that early on and anticipating that we have to do something at the forefront is what makes the difference. ... I wanted to get in front of that. I see that as being an environment I really enjoy, and I think its working here.
Q: What were the immediate needs of the city that you noticed?
A: Well actually before I came here I noticed (the area was) substantially lacking in infrastructure. Parks, drainage systems, roads were very lacking. The communities were disjointed. Each of them had their own identity, their own persona, and there needed to be linkages of bringing those folks together. The community was overwhelmed with development. There was a lot of concern about the hillsides and the trees that were being cut down. And so they wanted to deal with that. There was a lot of concern about the lack of beauty, and so we planted thousands of trees, did the center medians, did sign ordinance. We're talking now about architectural standards. So there's a lot of things now that we've been striving for.
Q: It's been said that Los Angeles County's neglect of the area — regarding circulation, housing developments and park planning — led to problems that still exist today. Would you agree with that?
A: Well I think that many people would say they agree with that, but I have a little different perspective on it. I think you have to look at L.A. County in the context of their role. County government tends to take a very micro perspective in terms of what's happening, and we are just a small piece of the pie in L.A. County. So how they deal with those problems are different than a municipality. A municipality takes a micro perspective on development; we look at it block by block, neighborhood by neighborhood. We tend to plan the urbanizing areas, and that perspective makes for a difference. We struggle with the same lack of infrastructure that they did because it's a matter of paying for it and going through the incremental process of putting in place the lead time for many of these large infrastructure needs. I mean you don't build large roads in 2 or 3 years. Its 5 to 10 years. Many of these bridges take a lot of time. If you have sensitive open government, it even makes it longer because you have to consult with people. You gotta develop consensus, and as you do that, it eats away at the time it takes to do that. City government tends to spend a lot more time doing those things to try and get projects in place, with minimum amount of conflict.
Q: What other challenges does the city face in dealing with L.A. County? Should there be one city government for the whole valley, including Stevenson Ranch?
A: Well I think obviously the largest challenge is developing a consensus as to the ultimate growth in the valley. So there is substantial unincorporated lands that have approvals of various developments already that impinge on the city and because of the topography of the valley, the canyons that flow down to the river, the river itself, the railroad. There's limitations in terms of how you build infrastructure. We cannot have a grid system here. And it's very costly. So how you plan for that needs to be done systematically because coming up with the revenues for a circulation system is something that has to be dealt with valley wide, county and city. Because they flow into the city, whether it's water, or sewer of traffic or any one of these things. They come down into the lower parts of this city. We will have to contend with that. You can even look at it from an economic perspective as the economic fabric of the city is emerging. You can see that emergence around (Interstate 5), what we call the center city, which is essentially from the (Saugus) Speedway area going west to just west of Magic Mountain is the core area. And so from an economic point of view, much of the commerce will take place in this area, and people will live all around the fringes. When you look at resources for developing a future city, the ultimate city of 300,000 or more, you can have a quality city if the resources that come from that go to pay for the services within that area. However, if you have a divided city/county, if you have multiple cities, then what you do is you create these different power groups that compete for resources. I think that ultimately you will end up with a group of mediocre cities.
Q: Reading through some old newspaper clips from June 1988, Bakersfield Councilman Dan Ratty said you would be perfect for a city that you could organize and put your stamp on without having to change the existing structure. Was that what attracted you here?
A: That was one of the things I was really interested in. I had worked with Bakersfield that had had an old bureaucracy that was very entrenched. ... I made a lot of changes. So when you make a lot of changes you tend to be short term because people have difficulty in adjusting to change. Change is a paradox in the sense that we seek change, and we talk about wanting it, but then when you have it, you say, "Well gee that's not quite what I wanted." So going through that in a city like Bakersfield you had headwind. You do a lot of processing to convince, to educate, to bring people along, which is more difficult and the old guard tends to become a real problem because the old guard frequently doesn't want the change. Here you have a very new community. There's a lot of people, they like the education system, they move out here for security. They moved out here for good schools, and so it presented a great opportunity, and I tend to be a visionary person. I try to look down 15 years and say, "Wow how can this be then and what can I do now to put systems in place that will bring that about?" And in that sense, maybe Dan Ratty was correct, although a city that is going through a kind of recycling kind of stage, from an old city to a new city, can also do that too. You can have a vision for a new community that is run down. It is more difficult. Take redevelopment for example, consolidating property, condemning property and doing those kinds of things is tough business. You have to be really aggressive, and there's a lot of political flack over those kinds of things.
Q: How would you describe your management style?
A: I think in some ways I am laissez-faire. That is I try to hire bright, talented people, create a vision of what needs to be done and then turn them loose and say go get it done. In some ways I'm a task master because I have deadlines, and I try to get tangible results done. So I think to some extent I'm situational. When the earthquake required more direct leadership, then that's what we did. But we also created a lot of teams, we had 22 teams that did different kinds of things, and they had a lot of latitude to make decisions and get things done. Right now we do a lot of strategic planning, which enables people to participate in the decision making process but also come feeling empowered that they can make a host of decisions based upon having the big picture. And I don't really tell them how to get it done, it's their intuition, their talents, their skills, as to how they actually do the job. I'm a coach.
Q: You've been called heavy-handed, dictatorial and abrasive in handling your duties in Bakersfield, yet here the council has obviously been pleased with your performance. Why do you think there is such a difference in the way people have perceived your performance?
A: I think those comments are totally fallacious and political in nature to justify the fact that they had to make a change. The reality is that all the time I was there I never had a bad review. The newspaper supported me, the chamber of commerce supported me, the minority community supported me and all came out to the meeting when they discussed the change. ... All I can say is that comments by Mark Salvazio, who I felt was paranoid/schizophrenic, he would meet with me for hours and it was a great relationship and then the next meeting you wonder if you're meeting with the same person. Tom Paine, also the mayor there, was an ex-police officer. He ran for mayor and then he spent his whole time complaining about the job. That it didn't have pay, it didn't have a car. So we got him a car. He wanted to go to Japan. Every day that I met with him, ... all he did was complain about his job. So to me those kinds of people were not in the job for the right reasons and I just can't have any respect for people like that.
Q: Did you learn anything from that experience?
A: Well its very hard since three new people came in that didn't know me, I didn't know them, and they wanted their own manager. So it's very hard to react to them. In terms of a couple of them, that like I said was schizophrenic, I don't know. How can you do better? The manager is trying to please 5 or 7 or 9 people, whatever you have. I think one thing I learned is, that no matter how bad things got, there's always a better opportunity elsewhere. And so you can try your best and do your best, but if it's not working, then maybe you ought to say to yourself, if I left yes I could be worse off, but I could also be better off. And most certainly within a year of being here, my wife and I sat down and we had a list of ten things that we put as to whether we were better off from leaving Bakersfield or not. And on 8 of them we were definitely not better. You know, our kids were very ill from asthma — the dust — and they would spray the cotton and the people put up with that, but my kids were always sick, so it was difficult from their health point of view (that) we were better off. My wife hated the place, but never really told me that. So all in all it all worked out. You know, (U.S. Rep Howard) Buck McKeon negotiated with me and when you deal with a professional, he was a manger, he ran a company and the negotiations went very easy. And then you go in with the council, and they say, "We want you to start tonight," and I said, "Gee I've got other commitments and I didn't want to start tonight," and within 10 minutes we worked it out. When you have that kind of relationship you say, "Wow, these are the kind of people I want to work with." They're empathetic, they're sensitive, you develop trust. I think the strongest thing we got going for us in this city, from the council on down, is the word trust. And because of that we're enabled, we're able to do a lot of things. Everybody makes mistakes but there is that trust and hopefully as people learn from these mistakes — they're not fatal mistakes, they're mistakes that everybody makes — they mature in the process in their jobs. We have that kind of environment here. But I think it's also that the government has to have high credibility with the public. And if you lose that, then it's very, very difficult to do projects as we have to as a growing city. We have to put in roads and stuff like that and when you have distrust it's very difficult to implement these things.
Q: The council talked recently about drug and alcohol abuse among junior high and high school students. Why have cities, schools, parents and law enforcement agents been unsuccessful at curbing the problem?
A: I think first of all, the fact that the school is involved; it's an institution and an institution with responsibility for young people a great part of the day. The responsibility for these issues is a societal responsibility. Their parents, their churches, their businesses, their schools, law enforcement-we all have to take responsibility for this. Why have we been unsuccessful? I think to a large extent many of the institutions have been unsuccessful because society has changed a lot and the institutions have not kept pace with it. For example, there was a time in our culture when a parent was home all the time. The mother was home and the father worked and there was nurturing going on all the time. And that has changed dramatically in the last 10-20 years. Now there are neighborhoods you rarely see adults during the daytime. And kids go to school on their own, they come home to an empty house. We have substantial burglary crime, drug dealing that occur between 2:30 and say, 6:30 at night. There have been communities where they've had these truancy ordinances. There is a direct correlation between the drop in burglaries because they've taken accountability for the young people on the streets during those hours. When you look at it, the family is very different, there isn't that nurturing. The neighborhoods are different. Not only are they not home but both parents working causes a preoccupation to work and the time that is devoted to it, I mean quality time, has diminished. You have television that is taking time away from the interaction that they have in the family and also the material on TV. These Nintendo games that get your brain dead. They stay for hours and hours playing these games that are just repetitive things of shooting something down, or whatever. So I think those things have impacted. In our institution of recreation and government and law enforcement and maybe even the schools , are adjusting to that and trying to say okay what would be our role here. Are we gonna be the surrogate parent from 6 or 6:30 in the morning when they leave home until they come back at 6 at night and therefore society has to change and during those 12 hours provide a host of services beyond just education? Do we have to provide childcare? Do we have to provide computer training? Do we have to provide homework? Do we provide music and art and sports and all those kinds of things? Is that what it's gonna take? And many communities are headed in that direction. They're talking about extended day programs, after school programs, to be successful. The question is if you have young people occupied that way, then can you really get them away from cigarettes, away from alcohol, and away from drugs or experimenting with that. I think that remains to be seen.
Q: The city has numerous programs which are aimed at crime and alcohol/drug abuse prevention. The statistics released yesterday indicate drug-alcohol abuse is as high as its ever been at the William S. Hart Union High School District. What more can the city do?
A: I think the key word that I would use is mobilization. That we have to mobilize. We have to get people off the couch, we gotta get people out of jobs, working with kids. That means businesses need to provide time for the employees to go and relate with the kids and spend time coaching or doing stuff with the kids. We must have adults working with the schools, before and after school. We must have people taking responsibility for not only their children but their neighborhood kids because what they do can impact your kid on the bus or in the park or something if they're angry and hostile kids. I think that's the word I'm talking about, not go down to the school administration when there's a problem and say "you guys are not doing your job." As parents they are not taking responsibility for their own behavior, for their own role-model or lack thereof. Or for helping others to help deal with that situation. I think for us, we have done a lot in the last 5-10 years in programs, etc. but I don't think that it has mobilized enough people, enough attention to actually have the kind of action that needs to take place to get good, solid results. In spite of what we say about all this, this place is very safe. The parks are safe compared to many places and when you look at test scores across the country, our schools do very, very well. I think the fact that we are trying to increase the awareness and consciousness on the part of the people goes back to my earlier comment. If you want to be in front of this and not wait until the become 15, 16 ; we do it now. There is 1 million new teenagers coming, a wave coming more than what it was just a few years ago. In this state we're going from 3 million to 4 million teenagers, from roughly about 4 years ago. So you take 4 years ago till maybe another 5 years. The number of teenagers, because we know the demographics for the young people, is going to go up. And just by demographics alone, then crime would resume to go up an equal amount. Therefore it makes sense, can we accept by numbers alone that kind of crime and the answer is no, and that why we should make the investment now. Besides that you look at the numbers we spend for police officers, the courts, incarceration, etc., it is significant. You're talking about a society, our state that had 20, 000 people in jail in 1980 and last year it had 145,000 in jail, at $30, 000 a year. So its big dollars we are talking about. So from our perspective making this investment in the front end, not only makes good sense from a security point of view, from salvaging human resources, but it also makes good sense from an economic perspective.
Q: You co-founded and are chairman of the Investing In our Youth Task Force. What's the goal of this task force and can it point to any successes?
A: Years ago when we started this, I think it was over 5 or 6 years ago, I was struck by the lack of attention to the problems that we were having in this country. With homicides, especially juvenile homicides. In one year, we had 24,000 homicides in this country and when I was on the board of directors of the League of Cities I pointed out to my fellow board members if they were aware that in the 12 years of the Vietnamese War we lost 50,000 Americans over 12 years and that issue was on television every night. We saw young people on campuses demonstrating all the time. They were absolutely enraged about that issue. Yet just last year 24,000 were murdered in this country. Where are the demonstrations? Where is it on TV, where this is an issue? So because of that we formed this task force, which was to invest in young people because the peak age for property crime is 16 and the peak age for violent crime was 17 1/2, on murders, assaults and rapes and so forth. What has the task force done? I guess that the most significant thing we did was to increase the awareness of this issue across the state to 480 or so cities across California. We provided demographics about the cost of denial that we were having this problem. We talked about how much it cost us because we were not taking care of the young people. To incarcerate them, to re-train them, the victims and so forth. We also then developed a video to share with all the cities in the state which was 9 minutes long on pointing out this problem and trying to educate people. We then developed a policy for the League of California Cities and asked every city in the state to develop that. Because of that we took this to the International City and County Management Association. We had them adopt it and because of that it went to the National League of Cities, and the Johnson Foundation called together these various groups, including state and local government people. There were seven major national organizations and they developed a policy for doing preventive work for doing afterschool programs, doing more for helping young people to become employable, develop skills, to go to work and not become a member of a gang or a tagging team. So those are some of the things that we did over the years. To try again, mobilize people to do something.
Q: Will there be a dump built in Elsmere Canyon? Why or why not?
A: No. First of all, county officials tell me it was not going to be built; that they had to have something in the plan. Secondly, I think there was a very clear message on the part of the citizenry here when 3,000 people showed up at a public hearing that they had here that they did not want that dump here. Thirdly, I don't think its needed. I think there's sufficient capacity to handle what we have and that what we need to do is comply with AB939 and look for alternatives to landfills. Recycling, remote sighting, whatever it is. I think we have learned over the years that burying trash where people are that possibly could contaminate the water or create injury or harm to their neighbors is not a good public policy and that Los Angeles County, being the largest county in the United States, ought to be a leader. We ought to be demonstrating to people that we have the will, the vision, the capacity to take on tough issues like this and come up with better solutions and I think we will.
Q: Newhall Ranch. There's speculation that something is going to be approved in the next few years. What does Santa Clarita have to do to ensure that the new community doesn't infringe on its quality of life, in terms of circulation, school overcrowding and unsupervised development?
A: There's a number of things in that project that creates concern. First of all, it's one of the largest project being proposed anywhere in this state. Secondly, it is leapfrogging and that is very costly when you have leapfrogging development. I mean there's overwhelming research done in both the public and the private sector that what you do for roads in terms of extending roads, then the police cars need to drive more miles, then you have to put more pipes in the road for water and sewers. When you have leapfrog in development you do not take advantage of the investment in the current system that can really reduce the cost of that development. So that is a concern. They have concern about the open space in the highlands, concerns about encroaching on the river. We have concerns about circulation and the capacity of the roads. And getting into the greater LA area over the hill as you develop this valley into a major metropolitan city with only the I-5 going over the hill. However there's some good things about that project too. I think the design has many fine qualities. It is preserving a substantial amount of open space. They recognize that the river is of value and they're trying to serve it. We have some areas of disagreement but I think on the river we're making good progress. We have concerns about circulation. I think that can be addressed also. I think that when you look at it in terms of taking advantage of public transportation, providing recreation and providing the needed schools. Those issues are being addressed. So ultimately I think the project will have some good qualities and naturally when you have a large project like that there is a controversy and a difference of opinion. But I think it will be approved some time down the road.
Q:You've been here 10 years, twice as long as any other of your stints in other cities. Do you plan to retire here?
A: I don't know. I have no plans to retire. I don't know whether I'll retire here or not. Its too soon for me to tell. We'll see.
Q: Other careers that you'd like to pursue while your relatively young?
A: I enjoy teaching and have done a lot of teaching, that is a possibility. I also have interests in international economic development and I may want to do that in the future. I may even join the Peace Corps. There are a lot of things to do. I've got two young boys and they like sports and I like sports. So I like to things that are outdoors. A lot depends on what they do. And what my place will be in their life. If they don't need me, then I'll go do something else.
Q: What are some of the accomplishments that you're most proud of?
A: I think the most difficult thing and the satisfaction of getting through that issue was certainly the earthquake and dealing with the aftermath of the earthquake. It was tough times and we worked very hard and it was very difficult. I think it's very satisfying to see the results. The thing I also like without any emergency, that I would put way up there is that we created a philosophy for investing in youth as a top priority. When all is said and done, and you're dead and gone, what are people going to remember you for? Are they going to remember you because you dressed well, or had a nice house or drove a big car? No way. They're going to remember you for the investment you made in people and whether you have disciples. And whether your kids grew up to be good citizens. That's what they will remember you for.
Q: Do you have any regrets?
A: Sure. I think it's sad that the redevelopment agency is so small that it doesn't produce any money. From my perspective it should have been a little larger than it is. I think it's sad that we don't have a huge acreage in central part of this city that 100 years from now could be a beautiful central park. I would like to see 1,000 acres in the central part of this city. I tell the staff all the time I travel around and I always go look at the parks, up in Washington and Oregon they've got nice parks. And I always go and look at what the park looked like when they bought it. And you go and look at the pictures and there's nothing there. And I'm standing there today, 100 years later and it is gorgeous, absolutely gorgeous. I mean they've got all kinds of trees, and paths and statues and little amphitheaters. And I think that 1,000 acres in this city would have been the cure when 1500 years from now the city is 300, 000 or 400,000 people and they'll say the forefathers of this community were wise people and did a good thing. I regret we don't have 1,000 acres.
Q: What do you think the city's biggest challenge will be in the next 5-10 years?
A: One valley, one city. I think good communication, good cooperation, collaboration, mutual trust and respect between developers, the county, the city and its neighbors will help us achieve this.
