While Randy Axell was reading his newspaper on a Sunday morning, he came across a submission from a local congressman in the op-ed section.
HOWARD P. McKEON
Opposes Inclusion Of Local River In Initiative
The article, which was written by U.S. Rep. Howard "Buck" McKeon, warned about federal involvement in the Santa Clara River. McKeon stressed the American Heritage Rivers Initiative would bring an unwelcome federal agency into what should be a local issue — preserving the Santa Clara River.
Axell, who owns 57 acres of land in the Santa Clara in the city of Santa Paula, said McKeon hit points that he and other property owners in the Santa Clara area have been saying all along — additional federal involvement is not wanted.
"I was thinking, 'Gee, this is the first time that I have ever agreed with a congressman,'" Axell said. "It's about basic property rights. Property owners are getting hammered by government regulators from every angle and we don't need their help, thank you."
The issue has divided river land owners who oppose the AHRI because it could potentially invite federal involvement from residents and government entities that believe the AHRI complements their goals of preserving the river's beauty and natural history.
The situation seemed to have been solved when the river was dropped from the initiative's list last month, but it resurfaced at a Santa Clarita City Council meeting when a resident said there was a possibility for the list to be expanded.
The Santa Clara is one the last free-flowing rivers in Southern California and Santa Clarita has invested more than $2 million toward planning the passive use of it, part of the river policy it set in 1990.
Rob Frost, who represents the Ventura Cattlemen's Association, which has opposed the initiative since it was authorized in September, said the Santa Clara isn't a river, but a wash.
"The government doesn't take care of it and private property is destroyed in rains," he said.
Most of the land along the river, which runs about 85 miles from its starting point in the Angeles National Forest to the ocean south of Ventura, is privately owned.
In the city of Santa Clarita, about 400-500 entities own property in the 11 miles the river travels through it, according to Joe Inch, Santa Clarita's park development coordinator.
One of the major river stockholders is The Newhall Land and Farming Co., which Inch said owns about 30 percent of river territory in Santa Clarita.
With its proposed 25,000-home development between the Ventura County line and the Golden State Freeway still being considered for approval, Newhall Land's opposition is obvious. But other land owners are opposed because they say the vaguely written initiative would invite an additional layer of bureaucracy.
Already, property owners along the river are inundated with county and state regulations.
If someone wanted to protect their land from flood waters, they would need permits from the Army Corp. of Engineers, the Dept. of Fish and Game, as well as a flood control permit.
The entire process can take about a year, according to Inch.
Axell said a lot of property owners, from Piru to Ventura, lost property from the recent rains and that there was nothing they could do about it when the river was flowing because of the government regulations.
Some land owners say well-meaning residents and government bodies, like the city of Santa Clarita, who petitioned for Santa Clara's inclusion in the AHRI don't understand how detrimental the federal government's involvement would be because they don't have a personal stake in the issue.
"People can easily be duped in thinking there is free money and 'Boy here's our chance to do something hot' when there is not a vested interest," said Bob Pinkerton, who owns property along the river and is the co-chair of the Santa Clara River Property Owners Association. "But they are not stake holders and they don't pay taxes. They don't suffer from damages of the property caused by trespassing, flash floods or anything else."
However, property owners seem to be in the minority on this issue. The cities of Santa Paula and Santa Clarita, as well as Ventura County support the Santa Clara's inclusion in the AHRI, thinking it would do just what it says — preserve and protect rivers and their adjacent communities.
The AHRI was an executive order President Clinton signed in September. The initiative would not interfere with state, local or tribal governments, but it would designate a federal mediator who would facilitate the preservation goals and needs of communities along chosen rivers.
The mediator, or river navigator, aspect of the initiative is what concerns opponents of the AHRI.
"I can't understand why a fed person needs to be employed to assist people along a river in dealing with federal government agencies, people can see what agencies they want to see," Pinkerton said. "The solution is to fix the bureaucracy, not to hire more guides."
McKeon wrote a letter to Kathleen McGinty, chairwoman of the Council on Environmental Quality, the federal governing body that oversees the selection of the rivers, asking her to exclude any stretch of the boundaries that fall in his congressional district.
After the Santa Clara had been chosen as one of the 20 semifinalists out of hundreds of other nominees, it wasn't included in the final list of 10 rivers submitted by the Council on Environmental Quality.
Some blame McKeon's letter, as letters from residents in Ventura and Los Angeles counties poured into newspapers, blasting his action.
Just when the issue seemed to fade, Allan Cameron, a local activist, told the Santa Clarita City Council that the river had a chance to be included in the initiative if McKeon endorsed it along with Sens. Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein.
On the basis of Cameron's remarks, the Santa Clarita City Council voted to request him to change his mind because the council hadn't made clear its position to him.
In December, Santa Clarita sent a letter supporting the AHRI, joining Santa Clara's council as well as Ventura County.
However, the Fillmore City Council declined to endorse the initiative in December, with one councilman citing that it would give the federal government a larger role than the local government.
And the other government major player, Los Angeles County, hasn't even made a stance on the initiative because no one has asked the Board of Supervisors to do so.
Dave Vannatta, assistant to Supervisor Mike Antonovich, said the county's liaison to the Santa Clara River Task Force, the Dept. of Water and Power, hasn't reported whether the task force has taken up the issue.
Another issue for property owners about the initiative is that the idea wasn't brought up to them.
"Ninety percent of the river is privately owned and no one asked our opinion about the American Heritage Rivers Initiative," Axell said. "I'm getting tired of being denied due process."
