Los Angeles County has spent millions of dollars on courthouse projects that may never be built, according to findings released Tuesday by the California State Auditor's office.
GEORGE RUNNER
Prompted Investigation
The office, at the urging of State Assemblyman George Runner, R-Lancaster, looked into allegations of mismanagement and inefficient bureaucracy in the construction program and found the county had already spent $79 million on projects that have not been completed.
"We weren't really surprised," Runner said. "We assumed there'd have to be some sort of conclusion that the taxpayers' money was wasted."
He originally requested the audit after allegations that the county had spent $10.8 million in construction money for planning and unfinished design of the Antelope Valley Courthouse, which lies in his district, along with other courthouse projects that had never been finished.
According to the auditor's findings, since the construction program began in 1988, the county has spent $79 million on eight different courthouse projects. And while five of those projects have a slim chance of being built, the report said, $18.6 million has already been spent on planning, design and land which is currently being unused.
An outside consultant, the auditor's office found, had warned the county three years into the project that it could not finance all of the projects, but the county continued anyway. If the county reacted to the warning, it concluded, millions could have been saved.
State Auditor Kurt Sjoberg said funding for the construction is provided by a portion of fines levied for traffic violations. Two changes in the means of funding, he said, could affect the future of the revenue. A 1998 law increased fines on motorists running red lights, which would raise revenue and fines on uninsured motorists will expire in the year 2000, which would drop revenue amounts.
In order for the programs to continue, Sjoberg said, the county must be sure to maximize its resources and conduct a comparative needs assessment. Projects, he said, should then be based on the greatest need. The county should also keep an eye on its revenue.
"If it can sustain current revenue levels," Sjoberg said, "the county now projects it will have sufficient funds to complete one of the deferred projects, the Antelope Valley Courthouse."
Runner said he was pleased the A.V. Courthouse would finally begin receiving attention again. Plans for it, he said, began sometime around 1990, possibly even earlier. Because of delays and mismanagement, $5.2 million more is expected to be needed for its construction design, he said.
Los Angeles County Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich was also pleased by the news of the A.V. Courthouse. The Board of Supervisors, which voted unanimously June 29 to proceed with the courthouse, had long assessed it as a priority, he said.
"The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court who visited the Antelope Valley Courthouse concurred with the board on the need to build a new courthouse," he said.
Antonovich was critical of the system in which the courts are prioritized for construction, blaming the state, which mandated the system, as basing it on political needs and not community needs. He was also critical of the auditor's conclusion of waste on the county's court projects.
Antonovich explained what exactly happened to the $18.6 million the auditor said was "wasted" on five courthouse projects. Over $2 million of that money, he said, was spent on a unneeded courthouse in North Hollywood.
"This pork barrel project begun by former state Senator Allen Robbins was eventually deleted through county sponsored state legislation before additional millions went down the drain," he said.
An additional $5.5 million was spent on plans for four additional courtrooms in West Los Angeles when their completion was within budget, he said. And the remaining $10 million was spent on land and design of a South Bay Courthouse, a project, he said, that was delayed by the state's prioritizing system. That project, he said, is now scheduled to be built after the Antelope Valley Courthouse.
All of the findings in the auditor's report did not take into account recent changes made by the county to improve its project development process. The county had gone through a reorganization in 1995 and adopted a projects management process in 1997. The changes, Sjoberg said, were too recent to determine any impact.
Runner said he will ask for another assessment in 18 months to gauge the impact of those changes.
