With an approximate $2.3 million annual discrepancy between reports prepared for the city and The Newhall Land and Farming Co. on the impact Newhall Ranch will have on Santa Clarita, the City Council directed the two sides to negotiate methods used in preparing the documents.
The council, at its Tuesday meeting, also included the city's financial impact report into the presentation Santa Clarita officials will make at the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors meeting that will discuss the project.
The Board of Supervisors was scheduled to hear the Newhall Ranch project July 28, but the matter may not go before them until the fall, aides to Supervisor Michael Antonovich said.
The financial impact report prepared by the city and Ultra-Research estimates the Newhall Ranch project, which proposes to build 25,000 homes west of Interstate 5 to the Ventura County line, could have an annual negative impact of $530,000 on the city.
The Newhall Land report, prepared by Levander Co. for the county and the developer, estimates the city would receive an annual $1.8 million windfall from sales tax revenue generated from future residents shopping in Santa Clarita.
Jim Harter, a vice president for Newhall Land, said the company wanted to work with city officials on the discrepancies between the two reports. The reports used different studies in establishing the amount of sales tax that future Newhall Ranch residents would bring to the city.
Regardless of the money, Councilwoman Jill Klajic said Santa Clarita residents' quality of life will be negatively affected by the project, mentioning that simple things like going to a doctor will be impacted.
"Everything will be crowded to (the point) where everyone will suffer," she said.
Harter said Klajic looked at the project from only one perspective. He said the proposal has enough land use designations to balance service needs of both Santa Clarita and Newhall Ranch residents.
"If you look at land use issues, we attempt to balance them with current services," Harter said.
According to Allan Cameron, a local activist, the project would impact the city's infrastructure by $250 million, which is targeted by the city's circulation element.
City Attorney Carl Newton said the two sides can agree for a payment for infrastructure that is impacted as a result of the project.
"Then we better ask for it, or we're going to be let off," Klajic said.
The city report said the Newhall Ranch project will generate $16.9 million in sales tax revenue over 25 years and $1.1 million a year after it is completed.
The project would cost Santa Clarita between $1.27 million and $1.63 million a year because of the drain on city services such as parks, recreation, government facilities and street maintenance.
According to the city report, the Levander Report estimated the completion of Newhall Ranch would bring in $35.1 million in sales tax revenue over 25 years and $2.3 million a year after it is finished.
The Levander Report said the city would have an average additional expenditure of $501,000 a year for street maintenance, according to the city report.
In other council business:
The council authorized additional funds to complete a thorough environmental impact report on the construction of Golden Valley Road, which would facilitate the building of another high school at the intersection of Golden Valley Road and Via Princessa.
The city will pay $35,000 for its share of the EIR cost that will also be assumed by the William S. Hart Union High School District and the developer.
Nine people spoke in favor of the proposal, including Hart Superintendent Robert Lee, who said the school is necessary to alleviate the overcrowding situation the district has now.
In three to four years, with the current four schools, the district will be at 180 percent capacity, Lee said.
The council voted to approve points of understanding between the city and Newhall Land for annexing land in north Valencia.
The council voted to expand the original 527-acre proposal to include West Creek area, which has 1,034 acres.
Some of the agreements included: the annexation of the North Park shopping center on McBean Parkway and Decoro Road; the Valencia Company, the developing arm of Newhall Land, would be responsible for preserving the natural river bank edge in San Francisquito Creek; Valencia Co. would sell the city land within the creek for $613,000 and the proceeds would go toward improvements to the upland preserve zone.
The points of understanding also were passed with a provision for developers to negotiate for the creation of a bridge and thorough fare district in the Valencia area.
The council approved a request for $75,000 from College of the Canyons and an aerodynamics company to help fund a program that trains students to run advanced programming equipment.
The council also voted to hold off deciding whether to endorse a separate San Fernando Valley Transit Authority until more information became available.
The SFVTA would separate from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and have its own governing body, but the MTA would still authorize funds.
Mayor Jan Heidt said the separation could cause another competitor for transit funds.
