After months of anticipating what direction Los Angeles County Supervisor Mike Antonovich would go on the massive Newhall Ranch project, he announced a proposal at Tuesday's Board of Supervisors meeting that satisfied the concerns most public entities had about the development.
Revisions to the plan submitted by The Newhall Land and Farming Co. include cutting the 24,351-unit project by 3,500 units, ensuring local participation in the management of more than 5,800 acres of open space, having a water supply identified when development tract maps are submitted, prohibiting use of ground water from the Santa Clara River and creating a wildlife corridor.
The board tabled a vote on the proposal until October, giving Newhall Land and county staff time to revise the plan and for the developer to continue negotiations with the city of Santa Clarita and Ventura County.
Antonovich, who didn't release details of his proposals until hours before he read it, placated many concerns of Santa Clarita and Ventura officials, who hailed the motion as a step in the right direction.
Councilwoman Laurene Weste said the motion gives Santa Clarita about 85 percent of the project modifications it requested.
"This gets us a great deal through (our requests)," Weste said. "Everyone benefits when we work this way."
Ventura County Supervisor Kathy Long, who said before the meeting Ventura County would take the developer and Los Angeles County to court to ensure its concerns about restricting pumping ground water from the Santa Clara River were met, said she was surprised at how far Antonovich's motion addressed her area's needs.
"It doesn't address all our concerns, but it gives us more time to work them out," said Long, whose district borders Los Angeles County.
Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer said the issues that were identified by Antonovich are resolvable.
"I think (Antonovich's motion) was tough on the project because it had to balance a lot of different interests," Lauffer said. "We think it was fair on how they did that."
The project covers 19 square miles between the Golden State Freeway and the Ventura County line. Five miles of the Santa Clara River meander through the northern end of the property and about six square miles of high country in the Santa Susana Mountains are on the southern portion.
Some, however, said Antonovich's motion didn't go far enough in reducing the size of the plan.
"I think a 3,500 unit reduction is inadequate," said Lynne Plambeck, the first vice president for Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment. "It is still 10 times over planned. Until the backlog of development units in the Santa Clarita Valley is absorbed, we don't need to do this one."
Allan Cameron, a community activist, said the plan was a starting point.
Cameron said there are still many faults with the proposal, including the fact Antonovich relies on Castaic Lake Water Agency's word that the agency can provide water for the project.
Noting that Newhall Land "has made significant effort to address a number of outstanding issues" since the project was approved by the Regional Planning Commission in December 1997, Antonovich said there were still a number of questions which need to be addressed.
"The two primary issues," Antonovich said, "involve the size of the project and the dedication of the 'High Country' to a public agency."
Under a current plan, the High Country is to be left as open space and undeveloped.
"Delaying the dedication of these lands to a public agency until several years in the future is not in the best interest of the (Santa Clarita) Valley," Antonovich said.
While Antonovich said he was not ready to set a target date for the dedication "because of other questions I have regarding the management of the property," he directed Newhall Land to "sit down with the community to discuss the issue" and come back to the board with "an accelerated dedication schedule," which he said would include "a vision of how the property would be managed."
Allowing local participation in the management of the land could allow the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy to become part of the process.
Newhall Land deeded the property to the Center for Natural Lands Management, a Sacramento-based organization that was supposed to take over the management of the open space once the project was approved.
The conservancy, a state agency that manages nearby open space, and the city have been negotiating with Newhall Land to have the conservancy oversee the High Country.
As to the size of Newhall Ranch, Antonovich said he was "concerned about the magnitude if the proposal and the impact upon both the public service systems and the environment."
Antonovich also cited "a number of other features which need to be revised" such as the variety of proposed land uses which border the High Country, including residential parcels "as small as 2,500 square feet."
Antonovich wanted that land use design revised to require "Estate" lots exclusively, averaging approximately 2.5 acres in size.
Antonovich also pushed for a design that will "provide a wider range of housing opportunities" in terms of more affordable housing than the base price $100,000 condos and upward to $700,000 single-family homes currently envisioned by the developers.
Antonovich also expressed his concerns over " sufficient water supplies immediately available to assure the completion of the development."
"The simple fact is," Antonovich added, "without these supplies, the development cannot go forward," though he said that Castaic Lake Water Agency "believes it will be able to provide the needed supplies on schedule through future acquisitions."
Antonovich also made it clear that the plan needs to be further amended "to make clear (Newhall Land's) responsibility to provide fully improved parks, libraries, and fire stations as part of the development of the various phases of the project."
