A specter was haunting the United States in the years following both world wars. As each ended, the fear of communism was revived, and with it, the hunt for those who were seen as taking orders from party officials in Moscow. Covert investigations of party members by the FBI and prosecutions under the Smith Act, which made it a crime to advocate or teach the necessity to overthrow or destroy the government of the United States, permeated the country.
QUENTIN KOPP
Seeking To Eliminate Old Anti-Communist Statutes
By the early 1950s it was estimated over 74,000 citizens were members of the Communist Party and even more were estimated to be sympathizers. Aside from federal laws, some states enacted their own to protect against the "red menace," including California.
State Sen. Quentin Kopp, I-San Francisco, ran across one such law among a group of other seemingly outdated statutes while doing research at his law office.
"I thought, what are these doing there?" Kopp said.
It was time, he thought, to finally rid the old statutes. But what he believed was a harmless clearing of extra legal baggage has opened a pandora's box in the state Legislature.
While lawmakers seemed to care less about ridding those pertaining to war ration coupons, many have taken issue with the subject of communism. Kopp's bill to eliminate the laws, known as Senate Bill 1535, has proposed, among other things, repealing a law that makes it legal to fire public employees who are a members of the Communist Party.
Kopp said he was surprised by the reaction his bill got when he first introduced it.
"I thought nothing of it, but all hell broke loose on the Senate floor when the Republicans saw the section about Communism," he said.
The battle to pass his bill has now become one of clashing ideologies and a question of constitutionality, one with which Santa Clarita resident Kevin Keyes also took issue. While communism no longer seems to pose a threat, Keyes said, the principles behind it are what concerned him the most.
"I am a veteran and have traveled extensively," Keyes said. "I have seen the destruction communism has had in its belief that people are incapable of managing their own lives, and that they should have no say in their governments."
Keyes said he believes that ideology does not coincide with the ideas the U.S. Constitution encompasses and therefore, those people should not be serving in any governmental capacity.
Republican state Sen. William J. "Pete" Knight agreed, siding with his party on the issue. He voted against the bill when it hit the Senate floor.
"I believe that anyone that has allegiance to the Communist Party does not support the U.S. Constitution and government," he said. "I don't believe they should be working for the government," he said.
While many lawmakers understand the need for free speech, communism's principles have overshadowed the issue.
Roberta Gillis, president of the Democratic Club of Santa Clarita, said the issue is one of First Amendment rights and as a firm believer in those rights, she says the bill should be supported. Gillis, who grew up in communist Yugoslavia, said she is well aware of the legacy that government left behind.
"For someone who grew up under a one-party system, I have seen what it can do," she said. "It takes away all of your rights."
However, she added, it is no longer a serious threat which looms over this country.
"There is no fear that this country will go that route," she said, adding that the freedoms espoused by America should apply to everyone.
"We don't have to agree with any of their views," she said. "They should have a legal right to exist."
In the late 1950s, the legal system began to agree — attacks against communists began to wane and the United States Supreme Court handed down a decision that further discerned between advocating overthrow and merely discussing it or presenting it as an idea. Still, throughout that period, California's law has remained intact.
Kopp said similar sections of the law were deemed unconstitutional in two other states and former California Attorney General Evelle Younger had also declared the law unconstitutional in the late '70s.
Republicans, however, have held their ground despite it, he said, and much of the voting so far on the Senate floor has been almost split between the two parties.
Blind emotion, Kopp said, seems to be ruling in this issue. "We must listen to the Republicans proclaiming we must not eliminate unconstitutional provisions," he said.
The bill is currently on the floor of the state Assembly and is expected to be addressed this week.
