The fine line between enforcing the rules and regulations in a mobile home park and harassment and discrimination may have been crossed in a dispute between a former resident and the Cordova Estates trailer park in Canyon Country.
Lorraine Vail and her family lived in Cordova Estates for five years. Vail said she planned to live in her mobile home for the rest of her life, and had spent considerable money refurbishing and appointing her 1972-model trailer.
But last April, the Vails were hit with a 60-day notice to terminate possession, citing "failure of the homeowner or resident to comply with a reasonable rule or regulation of the park which is part of the rental agreement or any amendment thereto."
The California Civil Code under which the Vails were being evicted further provides "that if a homeowner has been given a Seven Day Notice to cure rules and regulations on three or more occasions within the preceding 12 months" no further notice was necessary, and Cordova Estates management noted five such notices to the Vails since March, 1997.
Lorraine Vail, though, had a letter from management saying she had complied with and rectified any "violations."
But there was still Vail's teen-age son, Isaac, and a supposed "guest," Candace Hunter, staying with Vail, and Cordova Estates said their behavior was such that the Vails had to leave. Lorraine Vail saw these charges as at least dubious.
"Candace Hunter was never a guest of ours, she wasn't staying at our home," Vail said. "And I made that clear to the management."
As for her son, Vail is the first to admit that her son is "no angel." But the seven-page list of complaints against Isaac Vail come primarily from one set of neighbors, and consist of such "violations" as talking too loud, crossing the neighbor's lawn, and riding his bicycle too fast.
Nevertheless, Vail felt she had no choice but to give up her home and move into an apartment while she tried to sell the trailer.
It was then, she said, that Cordova Estates tried to block the sale of her mobile home.
"They're the tenants from hell," C. Brent Swanson, attorney for Cordova Estates, said of the Vails. "We worked with them for months to get them to control their son. They were given not one chance, but many chances. There's no question we had the right to evict, but we don't want to create a hardship for folks."
Swanson said Vail owes $3,000 in back ground rent, and she has "no right to sell" her mobile home, despite the fact that Vail owns the trailer outright.
Vail, though, has a letter signed by the former Cordova Estates manager, returning a rent check and stating that, after the eviction notice, management would not accept further rent payments from her.
Swanson said of the five prospective buyers Vail has brought to the property, all have been turned down for bad credit, or an inability to meet park regulations.
A letter to one potential buyer from Cordova Estates said Vail's tenancy "was terminated... and therefore (she) does not have the right to sell (her) mobile home and have it remain in the park or transfer any tenancy rights."
Real estate agent Don Butler, who was working with Vail on the sale, said, "It's a real crime what they're doing to her. After that first letter, I told them (Cordova Estates management), you can't do that. I talked to our corporate attorney, and he said they didn't have the right to do it. I've never seen or heard of a letter like that, and I've been doing this for 20 years. It's like they want to buy her trailer from her real cheap."
Elvi Olsen, an attorney an authority on mobile home law whom Vail contacted, said, "I don't think justice is on (Cordova Estates') side in this. The park owner has a lot of power over you, but the mobile home residency law was enacted to protect park tenants. They can't just evict for no reason, and those reasons are limited... It doesn't sound to me like they've gone through proper legal procedures."
After Vail contacted Jo Anne Darcy, field representative for Fifth District Supervisor Mike Antonovich, she was put in touch with Fern Collins, a special investigator for Consumer Affairs. Vail said Collins is looking into the case from a variety of angles, including the fact that her son was a target of child discrimination.
Vail said she recently returned to Cordova Estates to check on her trailer and found a "Notice of Abandonment" on the door, which could mean the park could take over the dwelling.
But the management seems to have backed off from that stance, after being contacted by Collins.
"They didn't appear to meet the legal requirements for filing the Notice of Abandonment," Darcy said.
