The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints might have its status as a tax-exempt organization investigated as a result of its support of Sen. William J. “Pete” Knight’s anti-gay marriage initiative.
The request for such an investigation was made by Mark Leno, a member of the City and County of San Francisco Board of Supervisors, to City Attorney Louise Renne and state Attorney General Bill Lockyer. Leno claimed the church sent letters to approximately 740,000 members statewide, seeking time and financial support for the measure, which will appear on the March 2000 ballot.
“I just wanted to make sure that they haven’t crossed any line,” said Leno, who is gay, adding that no precedent has been set for how much involvement organizations carrying the status of “charitable organization” are permitted to have in political matters.
Leno said he met Wednesday with the city attorney general, who thought there were some “gray areas” in the matter, and expects to get a response by Monday. If there is something, Leno said, he will go to the Internal Revenue Service.
Leno questioned Knight’s motives for seeking passage of such a measure, pointing out the only marriages all 50 states currently recognize are marriages between men and women.
“What we’re saying is that it’s intrusive, that it’s unfair and unnecessary,” Leno said. “This is, in its intent, an essential threat to the gay and lesbian community. There’s no need for it.”
Knight, R-Palmdale , was of the opinion that the church was doing nothing wrong, that Leno was merely trying to block support for the Protection of Marriage Initiative.
“I suspect the opposition to the initiative is going to do everything that they think is reasonable to try to discourage support for the initiative,” Knight said. “But I would suggest it’s well within the church’s obligation to support or oppose things that affect the morality of the community.”
Knight has twice attempted to pass legislation through the state government that would prevent the state from recognizing same-sex marriages. The last such bill was defeated by one vote in the Senate, with the tie-breaker coming from then-Lt . Gov. Gray Davis.
The initiative is necessary, Knight said, because when the U.S. government passed the Defense of Marriage Act in 1996 the federal government would neither recognize nor provide benefits to gay marriages, leaving the decision up to the states on whether to recognize same-sex marriages as being valid.
“We can deny that marriage if we believe in California that that is significantly in opposition to our public policy and that is perfectly within our rights and that’s what I’m doing,” Knight said.
Gay marriages, Knight added, “(change) the definition of marriage and I think that’s totally wrong in that the definition of marriage has been between a man and a woman for thousands of years, and it has served society well.”
Rob Stutzman, the initiative’s campaign manager, said Leno was “misinformed or he’s intent on trying to prevent people of faith from participating in the campaign. He’s asked the state to investigate a federal issue, which would be the first clue that he doesn’t know what he’s talking about.... He’s made accusations to get press.”
Stutzman also doubted the validity of the claim that 740,000 letters— a number he said he obtained from an area newspaper— had been sent out statewide, explaining that the number is close to the number of total membership church officials had reported for the state.
Gary Condie, the church’s public affairs director for the Valencia area, agreed with Stutzman’s skepticism.
“I have to believe that number is probably way off,” said Condie, who added that he has yet to receive such a copy of the letter in question. “The church doesn’t even send out letters like that as far as I have seen.”
Condie said that when the church encounters an issue, such as gay marriages, considered to be of a moral nature, each member is encouraged to act and become involved as a citizen— not a church member— and follow his/her conscience.
“Those are the guidelines that I have seen before,” Condie said.
