Officials at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital have insisted on the presence of a federal mediator at the bargaining table during ongoing contract negotiations between the hospital and unions representing the hospital’s registered nurses, technicians, service and maintenance personnel.
“Management has canceled scheduled bargaining sessions and refuses to meet with us without a federal mediator present even though we were making progress in bargaining,” said Diane Hirsch-Garcia , a negotiator for the California Nurses Association. CNA is the union representing the hospital’s registered nurses.
CNA began the bargaining process last November, Hirsch-Garcia said. United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers of America, the union that represents the hospital’s technical, service and maintenance workers, began the bargaining process in April and teamed up at the bargaining table with CNA in June, said Fernando Losada, an international representative of UE.
In an unusual move, the two unions joined forces to press hospital officials for a first contract covering more than 700 employees.
So far, the hospital and the unions have reached agreement on various matters, including grievance and arbitration procedures and vacation benefits, said Hirsch-Garcia . However, unresolved issues consist of staffing, wages and training opportunities.
According to Hirsch-Garcia , the hospital has not responded to demands of higher pension benefits or wages in the last few bargaining sessions. She believes the hospital called the mediator in hopes of stalling negotiations.
The hospital employees voted overwhelmingly in favor of union representation due to what they claim are poor benefits, a decline in patient care and lack of employee incentives, such as pay raises.
Members of the two unions held a press conference Monday afternoon at the Hilton Garden Inn in Valencia to discuss the negotiations and to appeal to the public for support.
According to Losada, a strike is not being ruled out as a possibility if the issues are not resolved. Both UE and CNA members would vote on the strike.
With tears in her eyes, licensed vocational nurse Shirley Augustine described the working conditions at the hospital.
Although the hospital was once “a wonderful hospital,” she said, “We’ve seen a deep erosion in patient care. Cutting in staffing makes it hard for us to take care of seriously ill people.”
Patients constantly complain about bedside assistance lights not being answered on time and other lagging service issues, she said.
“I’d like to see Henry Mayo the hospital it was 10 or 15 years ago,” Augustine said.
According to registered nurse Suzanne Anaya, 140 registered nurses out of 206 at the hospital have less than three years seniority.
The hospital, she claims, spends a significant amount of money training its nurses and then the nurses often leave to go to other hospitals that have better wages and benefits, leaving a shortage of qualified nurses there.
“We have nothing to show for our dedication to the hospital,” said a longtime hospital employee. “We have no matching retirement fund.”
According to Hirsch-Garcia , the number of registered nurses in the hospital’s intensive care unit last year was 33. Now, that figure is 23— a decline of about 33 percent, she said.
According to Rose Marinas, a registered nurse at the hospital for almost 20 years, the hospital makes up for the shortage by using “travelers,” or temporary fill-in staff.
Sometimes, she said, the hospital’s night staff is comprised of no core staff members, and it is generally 50 to 75 percent travelers.
The hospital’s retention level is among the lowest at all of the hospitals that CNA represents, claimed Hirsch-Garcia .
In addition, she said, there is not a big enough emergency room staff to handle the level of activity in the hospital.
These types of problems, she said, are becoming more and more common as hospitals have become more concerned with money rather than patient care.
According to Janice Newbold, spokesperson for Newhall Memorial, the hospital is prohibited by federal law from discussing negotiation-related matters.
However, she said, hospital employees are paid competitive wages, and staffing is adequate.
The hospital meets regulation requirements for staffing and sometimes even exceeds it, she said. The nursing shortage has been affecting hospitals throughout the nation and is not just an issue affecting Newhall Memorial, she said.
In addition, the hospital turnover is similar to that of other hospitals, she said.
The hospital also has “competitive pay packages that are reviewed” and a merit system that is based on employee evaluations. Eligible employees can earn pay raises between 1 and 4 percent, she said.
In addition, the figures that portray the number of qualified longtime nurses retained at the hospital may be inaccurate as some of the nurses may have been in the field for a long time but started elsewhere.
However, Newbold acknowledged, the costs related to retrofitting the hospital as well as declining reimbursements by health maintenance organizations have depleted the hospital’s reserves. However, she acknowledged that the hospital is “trying to deal with all of those issues.”
Despite the claims of nurses in the union that patient care has declined, patient satisfaction scores have gone up 10 points in the last six months, Newbold said. Scores, she said, are at 90 percent.
“Patients seem to be happy with the service,” she said.
Despite all of their disagreements, however, there is one thing that both the union members and the hospital agree on— a quick settlement of the negotiations.
“We’re hoping the negotiations are settled soon,” Newbold said.
