A department ridden with distrust and disorganization is the picture painted of the county Department of Children and Family Services, in an audit by PricewaterhouseCoopers' at the request of the county board of supervisors and released Tuesday morning.
The audit, which PricewaterhouseCoopers called only a "first phase," focused on DCFS's aspects of "leadership; planning processes; administrative processes and organizational structure."
The company announced that a second phase of the management audit would be released at the end of September.
The current report brought to light three key elements which it said need to be changed in Peter Digre's beleaguered department.
"The leadership and management of the department are too heavily concentrated in the director position," the audit stated. In view of the size and complexity of the department, the report said, the need exists for a "chief deputy director position (to be) reinstated" to focus on operational and administrative activities of DCFS.
DCFS was forced to eliminate the deputy director position several years ago, due to budget cuts, according to Judy Hammond, county public spokesperson.
The audit noted that DCFS "does not have a strategic plan" for its vast and complex operations.
The report also said the department's "employees... expressed concerns with the credibility of the department's leaders." The various reasons mentioned included "promised programs that were not implemented"; overall, the conclusion was that DCFS needed to "regain credibility by enhancing its administrative strength and stability..."
DCFS agreed to prepare a response to the report and submit it to the board of supervisors within 30 days.
The board, however, reacted immediately.
Fifth District Supervisor Mike Antonovich said, "With 70,000 children in their care, it takes an audit to discover basic things? That they have no strategic plan? That they don't have a chief of staff?"
Antonovich called the results "shocking... a shame" and DCFS's policy failure's "irresponsible."
"The audit is a wake-up call that verified concerns about the department's ineffective management," Antonovich added, noting that "this lack of organization led to situations like the recent Coombs case, where (a DCFS) employee covered-up a mother's criminal history of drug abuse and prostitution... and cost taxpayers $300,000 in a lawsuit filed by the adoptive parents."
The Coombs sued the county after a child for whom they'd been guardians was taken from their care and given to the birth mother. When the judge discovered the mother's history, he reversed himself and returned the child to the Coombs. A DCFS social worker had withheld the mother's information from the court.
Antonovich further pointed out that no disciplinary action has been taken against the DCFS employee.
Antonovich also voiced frustration over DCFS's "pathetic" response to board instructions to improve service on their child abuse hotline. Last fall, the board ordered an end to hour-long on-hold waits on the hotline and unanswered calls reporting endangered children. But, Antonovich said, "despite the seriousness of the conditions, improvements were not implemented until April, 1998."
The board voted to immediately implement the report's findings, and to begin a nation-wide search for a DCFS chief deputy.
Antonovich said, "This concerns thousands of children whose future is being impacted. This is a shame... to those we represent, on all levels."
