Calling the Castaic Lake Water Agency board fiscally irresponsible and pro-development, five Santa Clarita Valley residents announced their candidacy Tuesday for the four seats at stake in November's election — officially kicking off the name-calling and accusations that will likely follow this campaign.
The five — Lynne Plambeck, Ed Dunn, Robert Lathrop, Cam Noltemeyer and Mike Kotch — gathered in front of CLWA headquarters in Saugus and brought an enlarged copy of a homeowner's property tax receipt.
Circled in a highlighter was the "special water" tax of $115.37 the homeowner, whose house was assessed at $189,451, paid from July 1997 to June 1998 for the Earl Schmidt water treatment plant and to buy water from the State Water Project.
Plambeck said property owners will have additional special water assessments, for added projects like buying $41 million worth of water from Kern County, if the incumbents are re-elected.
"I think we have to be clear what the message is, and what is involved here," Plambeck said. "This is a rate issue. It's a taxpayer issue. It's about the efficient use of taxpayers' funds."
Kotch said the agency consistently has been spending more money than it has been taking in.
"They've been operating like tax-and-spend liberal Democrats," Kotch said.
Responded Richard Balcerzak, the at-large CLWA member: "You expect that kind of stuff from those people."
He said the agency has not had a water rate increase in many years, even though the current rates don't cover the costs of operations and maintenance.
The five are challenging the seats held by Balcerzak in the at-large division; Randall Pfiester in division one; Richard M. Green in division two; and Donald Froelich in division three. Only Green is not seeking another four-year term.
Peter Kavounas, who has worked with the agency and has praised its policy decisions, is running for Green's seat.
The CLWA provides state water to the four water retailers in the Santa Clarita Valley. The agencies are the Los Angeles County Waterworks District No. 36, the Newhall County Water District, the Santa Clarita Water Co. and the Valencia Water Co.
Seven of the board's 11 seats are chosen by the public, with the retail water agencies each choosing a representative.
Noltemeyer and Lathrop will challenge Balcerzak for the at-large division race, as will Brian Roney. The at-large division encompasses the Santa Clarita Valley.
Dunn is running against Pfiester for the Division 1 seat, which includes parts of Saugus and Canyon Country with the western boundary at Bouquet Canyon Road. Plambeck is running against Kavounas in Division 2, which includes parts of Newhall and Valencia.
Kotch is running against Froelich in Division 3, which includes Castaic and parts of Saugus west of Bouquet Canyon Road.
In a press release, the five said the CLWA ignored requests for reclaimed water for Canyon Country residents and hasn't supplied water pipes to Canyon Country, although it was supposed to with the $132 million bond the agency took out for the Rio Vista water treatment plant.
Balcerzak said the CLWA is studying plans to build a water pipe to Canyon Country.
"As far as a water pipe to Canyon Country, we are now in a study with the Newhall County Water District to get additional water to the area," Balcerzak said. "We are very definitely going to do something as soon as we figure out the best way to go. So that statement, which was probably made by Ed Dunn because he's been saying it at all our meetings, is totally unfounded."
Froelich, who is the vice president of the board, said he expects the challengers to make numerous statements about the agency's performance because they have to come up with issues to target.
"They are trying to get elected and the only way to do that is to say the incumbents are doing a poor job," Froelich said. "They are trying to focus on issues and we have to wait and see what they are as things develop.
"They can't say we are doing a good job. Otherwise they won't get elected."
The five opponents have intertwined on various issues in the past. Four — Plambeck, Lathrop, Noltemeyer and Kotch — are members of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, an environmentalist group that has challenged numerous development proposals in the past.
Plambeck and Dunn were on the Newhall Water board before they were defeated in their bids for re-election in November. Kotch currently serves on the same board, but was appointed.
Kotch said the five are giving the public a choice.
"It's not going to be incumbents running unopposed," he said.
The Newhall Water board election was filled with contention, with the three incumbents, including Dave Rapoport, being ousted by three challengers who banned together in criticizing the board's management and alleged misuse of taxpayers' money.
The incumbents said the challengers were out to protect the interests of The Newhall Land and Farming Co. and the CLWA, and not the public.
Plambeck said the campaign will likely be marked with the same antics because the incumbents are again pro-developer, a charge that Balcerzak denied.
"We do not approve or disapprove of any developer," he said. "That is not our job. All we are here to do is to provide water that the planners say will be needed."
