It was round two for opponents of the Westridge golf course community to make their concerns known to the Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission Wednesday morning. In a two-hour hearing before three of the five commissioners, private citizens and local activists directed the commission's attention to a variety of talking points on the proposed 800-acre development, to conclude a round of opposition testimony which began a week ago.
Lynne Plambeck of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment (SCOPE) testified that, among other issues, SCOPE was questioning the revised Environmental Impact Report (EIR) regarding water sources for Westridge.
"The old EIR indicated that Valencia Water Co. had 25,000 acre feet of water available, which was deemed inadequate," Plambeck said. "The revised EIR said they now have 45,000 acre feet, so there's no problem with water. But the question is, where did they get the additional 20,000 acre feet?"
Plambeck said that isn't made clear in the revised EIR.
Darla Hoback, who serves on the city planning commission, but said that she was speaking only as a private citizen, also said she found inadequacies in the EIR, particularly in terms of seismic hazards in the designated Westridge area. Hoback said the United States Geological Service "has not been asked to make comment on the EIR and I think it is appropriate to ask for their response."
Hoback said she was concerned about building houses on cut-fill lines (a filled-in canyon) because of the damage her own home suffered in the 1994 earthquake.
"Our neighbors' homes are built on a pure cut," Hoback noted, saying that her house was substantially damaged while her neighbors' were not.
And Hoback talked about a water tower on the site, atop a hill overlooking a housing tract; if another earthquake hit, the water tower could rupture, Hoback said, flooding the homes below.
"Those lots should be eliminated," Hoback told the commission.
Hoback, and several others, questioned the need for another golf course in the area.
"We have or will have six golf courses soon," Hoback said.
Hoback also joined the chorus of dissenters, from this week and last, who opposed the extension of The Old Road. She told the commission it was "unnecessary. As stated in your general plan for SEA's (secure ecological areas) to be graded for a road, there must be a present or imminent need. There is none."
The Newhall Land and Farming Co., which seeks to develop Westridge, sent representatives to the hearing, including corporate spokesperson Marlee Lauffer.
Lauffer said that Newhall Land "is very much looking forward to our rebuttal" at the next round of hearings on Sept. 9.
"There was a lot of misinformation in these last two sessions," Lauffer said.
Lauffer denied that there are any seismic faults on the Westridge site.
"State geologists have been all over the property and confirmed there's none on the site," Lauffer said. "It's all in the EIR."
Lauffer added there were no natural springs within the development either, as had been alleged to the commissioners.
"All of that has been reviewed," Lauffer said. "Sometimes they're discovered during the grading process, but absolutely none have been identified during the geology process."
Lauffer also dismissed the contention that Westridge was an unnecessary development.
"Anyone who's a golfer will be surprised to find SCOPE thinks there are too many golf courses in the Santa Clarita Valley," Lauffer said.
City Councilman Frank Ferry has asked that the issue of The Old Road extension be put on the City Council's agenda for August 25, and Lauffer said she was sure representatives from Newhall Land would attend the meeting.
Ferry appeared at last week's meeting and told the commission the council favored The Old Road expansion, though the current council has yet vote on the issue.
"Councilman Ferry is correct that citizens of this valley want as many roads built as possible," Lauffer said. "It's not acceptable to use some of the roads SCOPE has suggested (as alternatives), such as Rockwell Canyon and Tournament. The Old Road is a county master plan highway, and has been for 30 years. There's one section missing ... and it can be designed in a way that's sensitive to the ecological area. ... We've worked with the county to save the maximum number of oak trees possible."
