ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Was Al Weil urged to resign?

Former Hart softball coach's backers call for reinstatement

Al Weil's resignation from his head softball coaching position at Hart High was accepted by the William S. Hart Union School District two weeks ago.

And as far as the district is concerned, that resignation will almost assuredly stand, despite the best efforts of a growing legion of supporters who want Weil returned to the coaching position he held for 13 seasons.

Although no one at the district will specifically comment on the matter, citing public employee personnel considerations, the belief among many in the Santa Clarita Valley's educational community is that Weil's resignation may have been urged by the district after former players' allegations that the coach breached a player's confidentiality and an ex-assistant coach at Hart made sexually inappropriate remarks to that same player, possibly with Weil's knowledge.

If true, that would violate guidelines of the district's Athletic Coaches Handbook and Resource Guide and district policies based on state and federal laws.

"The board is firm in its resolve that the highest level of professionalism and sportsmanship be adhered to ... and that the district guidelines be adhered to," said John Hassel, one of five members of the district's school board. He added that he could not comment specifically on Weil's situation because it is a personnel matter.

Weil has declined comment on the situation.

Vanessa Raschella, a Hart player from 1994 to 1997, said she leveled the allegations in a closed-door session of the district board meeting April 15.

Accompanied by her father, Jack Raschella, and Bill Socha, father of former Hart catcher Danielle Socha, Vanessa Raschella said she told board members and other administrators in the closed-door session of alleged sexual comments made by a former Hart assistant coach three years ago.

Raschella also told administrators that, during the 1997 Hart softball banquet, Weil distributed among guests copies of personal letters to Raschella from Butler (Ind.) University softball coach Jeryl Neff denying her a scholarship. At the time, Raschella had accused Weil of sinking the scholarship and, she said, the distribution was an attempt to clear the suspicions with other players and their parents.

"I think he was looking to make himself look like the good guy in this," Raschella, now 19, said of the incident. "But it made him look even more stupid.

"Those were my personal letters. How he got a hold of them and who he got a hold of them from, that's what made me mad. It was wrong. He had no right to do that."

Earlier that season, Raschella believed she had sewn up a scholarship at Butler, a Division I softball program that competes in the Midwestern Collegiate Conference. She believes Weil killed the scholarship by telling Neff that the outfielder wasn't fast enough to be a leadoff batter.

When players and parents learned of Raschella's accusation, their rumblings led Weil to ask for copies of the correspondence from Neff to Raschella, which he then reportedly distributed at the banquet in an attempt to clear his reputation. He may never have realized that the distribution violated the Hart district's code of conduct.

Almost a year later, on April 15, when Weil met in his own closed session with administrators following Raschella's accusations, he was questioned about the correspondence, according to a source in the Hart district. Weil immediately produced copies of the letters from a three-ring binder to show administrators, the source said.

Of the alleged sexually inappropriate remarks, Raschella said the ex-assistant coach twice directed comments toward her, once during a game against Saugus and another time during practice. She said Weil stood close enough to likely hear the remarks in both instances.

She added that Weil never made inappropriate remarks.

Mike von Buelow, assistant superintendent of personnel for the district, declined comment specific to Weil's case. However, he emphasized that "Mr. Weil was not being disciplined for any immoral or criminal conduct," and "is not subject to ongoing investigation."

Raschella said she reported the ex-assistant's alleged remarks to Hart administrators near the end of her senior year in 1997.

But why wait three years?

"I was 15 or 16, playing on (Hart's) softball team, trying to make it on that team," Raschella said. "What was I supposed to say? I'm trying to earn a starting spot and I have to worry about a coach making comments about my chest?

"Let people believe what they want to believe. I know in my heart that it's true. Mr. Weil knows that it's true, too."

Raschella said she reported all incidents to Hart administrators a couple of weeks before graduation. By that time, Raschella said she was so disturbed with Hart's program that she urged her younger sister Gina to transfer to Valencia. Gina Raschella transferred the following school year.

Raschella said she had put her playing career at Hart behind her until she happened to meet Socha early last March at a fund-raising event for a traveling softball team for which they once played together.

Socha, fresh from getting cut by Weil along with fellow senior Jackie Bailey, told Raschella that her family had spoken to an attorney about possible legal action against Weil.

Socha, who could not be reached for comment, then told the former Hart right fielder of the then-upcoming April 15 meeting with the school board. Raschella said Socha urged her to come forward with her story.

Raschella agreed.

* * *

It's unclear exactly when Raschella spoke to district administrators in closed session, because her name never appears on the meeting minutes that are available to the public.

But sometime following Raschella's allegations, administrators met with Socha and her parents, then Bailey and her parents.

Immediately following those two closed-door sessions, administrators met privately with Weil for approximately 40 minutes.

A district source said board members Paula Olivares, John Hassel, Dennis King, Gloria Mercado and Patricia Hanrion, along with district administrators Robert C. Lee, von Buelow, Leslie Crunelle, Bill Maddigan and Hart Principal Gary Fuller, asked Weil questions about the cuts of Bailey and Socha, then about newspaper articles concerning the cuts.

The source said they also inquired about his philosophies of coaching, of the game and about scholarships. Weil answered every question, often producing written evidence to back his statements, including the letters from Butler, the source said.

The source said administrators then asked Weil if he knew about the allegedly inappropriate comments his former assistant coach had made to Raschella three years previous. Weil immediately told administrators that he had not.

Questions then returned to softball, the source said. The meeting was also attended by Hart assistant softball coach Gordon McKay, Hart track/cross country coach Larry David and Jim Seeley, head negotiator of the Hart District Teachers Association.

Hassel said the board never took action on the matter. If it had, that action would have been taken during the public portion of the meeting.

Seven weeks after that, Weil handed his resignation to Fuller.

Weil has had no comment on the resignation. Fuller said Weil resigned, citing "personal reasons." But many coaches and players' parents accused the district of driving Weil to resign because of complaints by Socha and Bailey, bitter and vindictive because they were cut from the team.

Von Buelow said that any formal allegations of inappropriate comments made to a student or a breach of student confidentiality would be "thoroughly investigated by this district."

Hassel also would not answer specific questions concerning Weil, instead couching his answers in generalities and district policy.

"I cannot comment on whether (Weil) was investigated or not," Hassel said. "But if any allegation of misconduct in that regard was brought up against any district employee it would be investigated fully."

Asked if he was satisfied by the findings of every investigation conducted by the district this year, Hassel said that he was.

* * *

Riding a tide of support during the past few weeks from players, parents, peers and Hart alumni headed up by Tom Fortune, father of Hart junior pitcher Amanda Fortune, Weil has asked Fuller to be reinstated as softball coach.

AMANDA FORTUNE

Weil Supporter

Fortune had gathered more than two dozen letters by the middle of last week. In general, the authors wrote that Weil was a caring, knowledgeable coach, garnering enormous respect in his 28 years with the district.

Last week, Fortune said he would have upwards of 100 supporters at tonight's meeting in an attempt to convince board members that Weil should remain Hart's softball coach. Fortune is scheduled to address the board at tonight's meeting.

Thus armed with backers and an instance of successful grassroots activism behind him, Fortune planned strategy meetings through the weekend in preparation for tonight's showdown with district administrators at the school board meeting.

But it appears unlikely the board will reinstate Weil, no matter what arguments his supporters raise.

Said Hassel: "I don't see any compelling reason to do so. I'm elected by taxpayers for a very unique position — as a trustee to the district for the exclusive benefit of the students and their needs. This responsibility does not allow me to give sway to the body politic."

That body politic being any popular movement to reinstate a resigned coach?

"Right," Hassel said.

* * *

Even among the coach's critics, the general attitude seems to be one of wanting to quietly move Weil on so the Hart program can move forward.

After all, some say, Weil has talked of retiring as softball coach for the past two or three years, and it may be in the program's best interest for Weil to discreetly do so now.

Roland Wrinkle called his daughter's time as a player for Hart "a horrible experience for her." Kim Wrinkle pitched from 1995 to 1997 for the Indians, skipping her senior season last spring.

He would not specify what made for his daughter's poor experience.

A San Fernando Valley-based attorney, Wrinkle said he has supported and contributed to the Hart program and will continue to do so — regardless of whether Weil returns to coach the team. His biggest gripe against Weil had to do with what he called the "public humiliation" of Socha and Bailey when the pair were cut from the team. He also alleged that blue-chip senior shortstop Christina Chao, who left the team before last season started, was driven to quit.

Wrinkle spoke in support of Socha, Bailey and Chao during the public portion of the April 15 school district board meeting.

"Those three girls were publicly humiliated for their severence from the team and that's what I wouldn't stand for," said Wrinkle, citing a Signal column by sports writer David Shefter agreeing with the cuts of Socha and Bailey. "My role was to defend those girls when they were wronged."

Wrinkle said that he has known Socha and Chao for some years, having coached both on youth teams.

"Youth athletics is a very important thing," Wrinkle said. "It's purpose is to enrich lives. When it's not enriching lives and going in the opposite direction, that's the antithesis of what it's supposed to be doing."

Despite his displeasure with his daughter's experience at Hart and the cuts of Bailey and Socha, Wrinkle said he had no opinion on whether Weil should continue coaching at Hart. It simply is not his place to determine, he said.

According to Bill White, athletics administrator for the district, any determination on a coach's tenure rests with the school's principal.

"Principals don't need to force a coach to resign," he said. "They just don't assign them to that coaching position again. Coaching is not like a teaching position. The district gives counsel (to principals) from time to time regarding (coaching) assignments. But it's the principal that makes the final decision."

White said he spoke with Socha and her family soon after the catcher was cut, then spoke to Weil. He said the cuts were Weil's prerogative.

"It's a coach's responsibility to establish their own squad on any team," White concluded.

College recruiters fawned over Chao from her time on travel and club softball organizations. It didn't matter that she left Hart's team before last season started. She is considered bright and talented, both academically and athletically, and Stanford University snapped up Chao on a softball scholarship.

Chao said she left the team because of a nagging arm injury suffered during basketball season. The ride to Stanford secured, Chao thought it best to keep healthy.

She insisted that her decision to sit out her senior season had nothing to do with the cuts of Socha and Bailey. In fact, Chao said, she's had little contact with the pair since last winter.

Yes, she looked forward to playing her senior season with them — especially Bailey, whom she said had improved dramatically in her three previous seasons at Hart. And no, she didn't quite grasp Weil's decision to cut the pair.

She merely accepted it as the coach's decision.

"I just didn't understand," she said. "I had a meeting with Mr. Weil and all he said was that he wanted to get a handle on the attitudes that year. We both pretty much didn't want to talk about it. I don't know why they (Bailey and Socha) were attitude problems. They made the practices fun.

"They had very carefree attitudes. They were Socha and Bailey. They were always telling me to cheer up, that I always took things too seriously. They worked hard and definitely played hard. It was important to them. They loved playing."

Chao did not attend the 1997 banquet, instead playing for her travel ball club. She knew few details of Weil's alleged distribution of Raschella's correspondence from Butler, saying only that she heard the incident happened.

Of the ex-assistant's alleged sexual remarks to Raschella, Chao said she heard them, but thought them "only jokes." But Chao said she understood how Raschella could be offended by the remarks.

Others remain less understanding.

Socha could not be reached for comment. The last known number for the Socha family was disconnected.

Raschella at first hesitated to talk about the situation, then her words and emotions welled up against Weil.

"He (Weil) puts players through mental torture," she said. "He plays favorites. If you're not kissing his butt every day then your only spot is on the bench. He does not teach the players. He does not ask players. What he says goes. I don't believe he should be allowed to coach anymore."

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/main/0898/082698a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,402 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:v2_datefile_main
  • text:valley_names [7 distinct/8 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Saugus, Hart High, Hart district, William S. Hart, Hart Union]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By DAVID KECK]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 8, national 0