There's a revolution in Venezuela. Saddam Hussein is acting uppity again. The refinery outside San Francisco just had to shut down production because of an explosion.
All of these are commonly understood as factors that can affect the price drivers pay when they fill their tanks with gasoline. The accepted philosophy is that unforeseen events like these typically disrupt the flow from the oil fields to the refineries to the corner gas station. Then the law of supply and demand takes over and, when there's a scarcity, the price goes up.
But there have been no refinery fires, no sinking tankers and no fresh wars in the Middle East. According to those who work in and watch the petroleum industry, the factors that move gas prices up and down are not based on the simple economic principle of supply and demand.
Instead, what Santa Clarita Valley motorists pay for gas — what all Californians pay — is based more on the principles of competition and the question of what the market will bear, according to gas station owners and their advocates.
Virtually all SCV consumers have noticed that prices here are more than those in the San Fernando Valley, by anywhere from five to 10 cents a gallon.
That is because the major refiners — Chevron, Shell, Exxon, Mobil, Union 76 and Arco — set the price of the product they sell to gas stations through a network of zones. The SCV is in its own zone and because there are fewer gas stations than in the other valley to the south, there is less competition from corner to corner and the price is adjusted upward.
Gas prices also vary because station owners receive discounts from their supplier depending on whether or not they actually own the station, meaning the land under it and the pumps, or lease it from the petroleum company in a franchise-type of arrangement.
An informal canvass of SCV gas prices during the middle of last week found a low of $1.08 for the 87-octane unleaded gas at an independent Ultramar station in Newhall to about $1.30 at some gas stations near freeways. Gas at off-ramps, like the ones in Castaic, is close to $1.30 a gallon for the same grade, because drivers on long trips who need to refuel are not in a position to search for competitive pricing.
Typically, though, gas in the SCV is priced between $1.13 and $1.23 a gallon for low-grade unleaded. The three stations at the Soledad Canyon Road/Bouquet Canyon Road intersection are all between $1.13 and $1.17 a gallon
But the zoning is hurting a lot of station owners because, they say, their would-be customers know they can drive south out of the SCV and save a dollar or more on a fill-up.
"It's killing me," said Glen Morey, who owns Morey's Chevron at the intersection of Soledad Canyon Road and White's Canyon Road in Canyon Country. "We're a bedroom community and people here work in the San Fernando Valley. They see gas is cheaper there and buy it there. And I have no control over it."
Morey said the dividing line for the pricing zone is Roxford Street in Sylmar. Every pump north of that line is six cents more expensive than ones south of it.
"When my dad owned the station it was eight cents," Morey said. "And it's multi-billion dollar oil companies that are setting the prices."
George Mayer, the long-time owner of Mayer's Freeway Shell near the Pico Canyon Road interchange off Interstate 5, has a printout of a survey of Los Angeles area Shell station owners that shows he is being charged 71 cents a gallon for the gas he purchases.
In contrast, Shell station owners in places like Downey, La Mirada and Westminster are paying about 58 cents a gallon, Mayer said.
Anyone traveling to other parts of the country notices the discrepancies in gas prices almost immediately. One Santa Claritan who vacationed in South Carolina this summer said gas was 89 cents a gallon.
But California's gas is the nation's most expensive because it is the heaviest taxed and regulated. A motorist handing over $10 for to a station attendant is actually paying about $6 for gas.
The other 40 percent go to state and federal taxes, each of which are about 15 cents on the dollar. California motorists also pay more environmental fees to pay part of the cost of oil spill and underground tank cleanups. A station owner can expect to make little more than 7 cents profit on a gallon of gas.
Additionally, California regulations that mandate cleaner-burning fuel is an expense for California refiners, and that cost is passed on to consumers.
Those laws that ordered cleaner gasoline had another effect on consumers. According to Dwayne Bernard, a director of the Automotive Trade Organization of California, the laws forced about half of the refineries in the state to close earlier this decade.
"A lot of little independent refineries didn't want to spend the money on an update," said Bernard, who owns three Union 76 stations in the San Diego area. "There are a lot fewer refiners now than there were in 1992. Six companies now make 90 percent of the gas."
ATOC represents more than 1,000 independent station owners and has frequently butted heads with the major oil companies.
Bernard said the oil companies know California culture is based on the automobile and charge "whatever the market will bear." Usually prices rise during the summer because motorists are planning vacations and have no choice but to pay an inflated price.
"Right now crude costs are just so low and there's plenty of product," Bernard said. "Iraq has cranked up its supply and the Asian market has slowed so there's less consumption."
The glut of product sometimes ends up with discount retailers like Ultramar, which is called the "unbranded" market because Ultramar and other smaller retailers sell gas but do not refine it. This can be a problem to competitors like Canyon Country's Morey, who is across the street from independent USA but is forced to sell his gas for a full dime more per gallon.
Morey said he also struggles because his station is considered "third-party ownership," meaning he owns his business but Chevron actually owns the land, the pumps and the underground tanks. Competing stations are owned by second-party owners who own the land and the pumps, and these owners purchase gas at a discounted rate.
"There are a lot of unfair things the gas companies are doing," Morey said. "It makes me look bad."
Freeway Shell's Mayer said much of the excess gas being refined lately is being piped to Arizona.
"It's much more profitable for refiners to pipe the overruns to remote areas," Mayer said. "The market doesn't control the price. The refiner controls the price. They have an economic stranglehold on the dealer, and the incentive is not there to present a more competitive market.
"This is a terrible market. Gas should be no more than $1.05 or $1.08 a gallon. There's no reason for me not to be able to buy and resell gas for the same price as a dealer in Torrance."
Mayer said that, competition being as steep as it is, if he lowered his price, the competing Mobil station on the other side of Chiquella Lane and the Arco up the street would probably follow suit to stay competitive.
Some stations do reduce the price to draw customers. Arco created a spectacle in the early 1980s by abandoning the company credit card program to pare costs, passing savings to its dealers and attempting to make it up in volume. In fact, many Arcos do not accept the major bank cards, either
The Arco station on Sierra Highway in the Friendly Valley area is one of cheapest fill-ups in the SCV, and owner Dan Close said he needed to attract motorists on a commuter route.
"We're a little bit off the beaten track, so I think we try to keep the keep the price down to compete, and operate on a little smaller margin," Close said. "And we've been here for almost 13 years."
"We are in the most lucrative gas market in the world," Mayer said. "There's nothing else like it."
