Before a courtroom audience choked with emotion Thursday, a judge convicted drunken driver James Bent of gross vehicular manslaughter, rejecting a more serious charge of second-degree murder in the death of Saugus High School senior Lauren Blaire.
"The court has heard and considered what took place in trial," San Fernando Superior Court Judge Meredith C. Taylor said as she explained the basis of her ruling. "The court has to base its decision on facts and law."
She then recounted evidence presented in the one-and-a-half-day court trial.
At about 1:30 a.m. on Jan. 11, Bent was driving while intoxicated on Bouquet Canyon Road, Taylor said. He ran a red light at the intersection of Plum Canyon Road and struck a car driven by 18-year-old Blaire, killing her. Blaire had been turning left from Plum onto southbound Bouquet on a green light.
Bent, 29 — a resident of Saugus who was familiar with the road — was driving at about 60 mph, which is "not an unusual speed for the area," Taylor said, adding that Bent's "judgement and ability to drive were impaired because he was under the influence of alcohol. It appears that the defendant was drinking while he was driving."
Taylor noted that Bent was convicted in Maryland of drunken driving in 1990 and of reckless driving in 1995. He was again arrested for drunken driving in November, 1995, for which he was convicted on a lesser "wet reckless" charge in March, 1996.
But the judge was not convinced Bent's prior record proved malice, a necessary element of murder.
"It is true that the defendant was indifferent to his act. However the court does not find implied malice here. Not guilty as to Count one (murder). Guilty as to Count two (manslaughter)," Taylor said.
Upon hearing the verdict — which means a term of four, six or 10 years in prison rather than 15-to-life sentence for second-degree murder — Bent wept.
"He was crying out of relief, not remorse," said Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Deputy Mike Shapiro, lead investigator in the case. "I believe, based on when he started crying and after seeing him over the last eight months, he was crying out of sheer relief. He never looked at the Blaire family and he has never said he was sorry."
Defense attorney Craig Robinson refused to discuss the case. Bent's family — present in court every day and clearly distraught — also declined comment.
"I feel we presented an extremely strong case," Shapiro said. "It came down to one point — whether his driving record showed malice. The judge didn't think it did."
Blaire's family and friends also were disappointed in the verdict.
"We're not completely satisfied," her father, Nick Blaire, said. "Obviously nothing is going to bring Lauren back. We have to accept the judge's verdict. He killed our daughter and we hope he'll get the maximum sentence. It was very difficult to hear the trial and go through things again."
Several members of the Blaire family said they plan to make impact statements when Bent appears for sentencing Oct. 6. Bent was remanded into custody without bail.
