A Los Angeles Superior Court judge issued a tentative decision last week stating the City of Santa Clarita did adequately examine the impacts of building new roadways in the city.
Judge Robert O'Brien denied the petition for writ of mandate filed by the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, which challenged the environmental impact report done on an amendment to the city's Circulation Element.
"The community and SCOPE should see this as a victory that the city does rigorously adhere to state environmental law," City Manager George A. Caravalho said.
SCOPE filed the lawsuit Jan. 13 calling the EIR on the circulation element, which maps out methods of transportation within the valley, including roads, an inadequate report that violates state law.
SCOPE President Michael Kotch, president said the group was disappointed by the ruling.
"We think we had a good basis for the action we filed," he said. "If you look at the circulation element and the city's general plan, they're not consistent," he said. "Part of what we asked for was that these be consistent."
The amendment in question was the proposed expansion of The Old Road running between McBean Parkway and Valencia Boulevard, an area known as a Significant Ecological Area containing 1, 200 rare Valley Oak trees. SCOPE contended the EIR did not address the damage expansion would cause to those trees.
Other opposition to the expansion prompted the City Council to delete the extension from the element, however the County of Los Angeles still has it scheduled. The council has expressed its opposition to the expansion.
The extension, however, was not deleted from the EIR, which could allow another party to build the road without review.
City Planning Manager Jeff Lambert said Judge O'Brien found that was not the case.
"We did not do the level of analysis that would let that road be built," Lambert said, adding the judge ruled the analysis that was done was adequate for its purpose.
The EIR being done for the Westridge Project, currently underway by the County, is delving much deeper, he said.
The decision made by Judge O'Brien is not final however, and SCOPE may file objections. Kotch said doing so may be a possibility.
"There was some indication from our attorneys that there's a good basis for appeal," he said.
