To some, the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment (SCOPE) is a collection of tree-hugging, no-growth extremists, a group of people four-square opposed to any and all real estate development in the Santa Clarita Valley. SCOPE is perceived as the mortal enemy of The Newhall Land and Farming Co., the bane of certain members of the City Council, the scourge of the county Regional Planning Commission, a chronic headache to the county Board of Supervisors. SCOPE, certain factions contend, is an army of placard-waving crazies who never met a road they didn't oppose or an oak tree they wouldn't protect, no matter how important the road may be to the community , or that three oaks will be planted for every one displaced by construction. To those people, SCOPE gives "environmental activists" a bad name.
Then there's the other side, those with genuine concerns for the environment and the quality of life in the SCV. To them, SCOPE is a vital force for monitoring unchecked growth in the region, a constant watchdog keeping the government, the developers and the water companies responsible to the area's residents.
SCOPE president Mike Kotch, who is also running for a seat on the Castaic Lake Water Agency board, sat down with The Signal to clarify the goals of the organization , explain what he hopes to accomplish if elected to the CLWA board, and provide an overview of the world according to SCOPE.
QUESTION: Give a brief background of SCOPE and its history.
ANSWER: To understand where SCOPE came from, you have to understand the process with the county in the 1980's... Supervisor Antonovich had a planning advisory committee, which was a group of citizens that he appointed, that met once a month... When the city incorporation effort took place, Mr. Antonovich dissolved that committee... There was a grassroots feeling that something like the planning advisory committee should go on. And from that grassroots is basically where SCOPE got formed. We formed ourselves on a number of different basic principles, but they were all basically oriented toward environment, ecology and quality of life in the Santa Clarita Valley. The objectives were to be able to provide a forum for people to discuss these issues, to provide educational services so we could inform people about the process and the issues so we could, if necessary, take actions. We were unincorporated for about two or three years, and then we incorporated as a non-profit organization.
Q: How many members does SCOPE have?
A: Approximately 60 are active as contributing members. We have a mailing list that extends to about 1500.
Q: How would you define SCOPE's primary mission?
A: It's to provide a forum so people can discuss things, to provide education and to take action collectively as an organization where we feel it is necessary. A lot of people get impacted by development or get impacted by some of the aspects of development, such as traffic or school crowding. People... show up at a council meeting and they let their views be heard, which is the appropriate process. In a lot of instances, these people have not been part of the public process before. They haven't testified to a planning commission, they haven't testified to the city council. They haven't reviewed an EIR. One of the services that we provide is we can provide some experience, some guidance, some advice...
Q: What is SCOPE's vision for the Santa Clarita Valley?
A: That's a collective decision... I think if I were to characterize it, I would say it's to have a future within the Santa Clarita Valley in which we have the type of community that... we as a community have decided we want. There was the concept within the county's general plan, an idea of build-out of 270,000 people by the year 2010. And build out means build out. That means you're done... There was that implied contract with the community when the county and the city adopted their general plan... We're now planning for 355,000 or 470,000, and people see this endless cycle in which build out is never really achieved.
Q: How is your engineering background helpful in assessing growth-related development proposals?
A: Well, a lot of things are technical when you're talking about development. It's a technical process, it's a legal process, but a lot of it is technical... My engineering training has given me a general capability to be able to read these documents and interpret and try to see what is in there and to be able to make meaningful comments.
Q: Where does SCOPE get its funding for its legal battles?
A: A lot of it was raised on the grassroots. We've basically been able to be in a situation in which we have been successful in our legal struggles. We've been awarded court costs.
Q: Is The Newhall Land and Farming Co., in SCOPE's view, the Evil Empire?
A: No. They are difficult... There actually have been some Newhall projects that we approved of, and we've supported. To say they're the evil empire... the United States did establish a détente with Russia, and progress was able to be made in certain areas. In other areas, we agreed to disagree.
Q: What is your response to the contention that SCOPE only takes action against Newhall Land and Farming projects?
A: Oh, nuts! I think it's just been a matter of circumstances, in a lot of cases...
Q: What is SCOPE's position on Porta Bella?
A: SCOPE's position is, first of all, it needs to be cleaned... A fair argument and a reasonable argument could be made that if we've got 600 acres on the Porta Bella site, and if we've cleaned up these 100 acres over here, 10 percent certified by Cal EPA, so we can build Magic Princessa, should that project be halted, and should we have worse traffic until the remaining 500 acres are cleaned up? I don't think that's a reasonable argument... We did not either support nor oppose the project, and we were castigated for that by a number of people. They said that SCOPE had some deal with Porta Bella. We did not. We were getting secret funding from Porta Bella. We never did. Any number of accusations, all completely false... A number of people, including myself, feel that if you're looking at a concept of a city, having a city core, having a city center makes a lot of sense, because SCOPE is against urban sprawl... I've always felt that Porta Bella... is a prime candidate for creating the concept of having a civic center. And it could interact very well with Metrolink stations there, and with the rest of the community. It would be the pivot point around which Canyon Country, Saugus, Newhall and Valencia are defined.
Q: What do you say to others who contend that SCOPE would be opposed to Porta Bella if it were a Newhall Land project?
A: I have to disagree. Our position on Porta Bella is not based on ownership, but is based upon the aspect of the project.
Q: The City contends Porta Bella will irreparably impact ridge lines and have other adverse effects on the environment. Your reaction to that?
A: The City's administration of their hillside and ridgeline preservation ordinance has been extremely sporadic and weak, quite honestly. If they like the project, they'll ignore the hillside ordinance. If they don't like it, they'll use it as the excuse...
Q: Would you live in a house built by Newhall Land?
A: Not really. Not for any antipathy toward Newhall Land. I own ten acres up in Castaic, and I like the elbow space.
Q: What do you hope to accomplish as a member of The Castaic Lake Water Agency board?
A: There are so many things on the list. Well, I think there is an understanding that we need collectively good water planning within the valley, and that includes good communication with the people who are making decisions on development. Water is critical, in Southern California in general. And there are increasing pressures upon our water sources. And we're not developing new supplies. We're looking at reclaimed water as a new supply. We're in a situation, where like America in the 1970's, we're relying increasingly on exports. And we are increasingly vulnerable to having those exports cut off, so we don't get the water imported to our area that we need. What has been the practice so far, first of all, Senate Bill 902 was passed a couple of years ago that requires that developments over a certain size (about 500,000 or so) have to demonstrate an adequate water supply. There has not been one project in the Santa Clarita Valley that's been examined under that standard in the last two years. They all have claimed exemptions.
Q: Can CLWA meet its existing water obligations and still provide water for Newhall Ranch and other planned developments?
A: No. Not right now. The reason is, and this is reported by CLWA's own consultants, they can process 31 thousand acre feet per year in their plant. They're currently using delivering about twenty-two acre feet a year. So that leaves them 9,000 acre feet per year, left in their existing treatment capacity. And that 31,000 is quite a bit less than a 54,200 entitlement. So with that 9,000 feet a typical rule of thumb is to use an acre foot per house, to include commercial and industrial as well as residential. So that means they can accommodate 9,000 more units. That's certainly less than Newhall Ranch, and when you consider in the aggregate all the other approved projects, and I've heard figures anywhere from 20,000 to 40,000 units, you're not going to meet it. What we need is more water. Secondly we need the treatment capacity to be able to treat the water, because we can't even treat all the water that we're entitled to right now. Thirdly we need the distribution system, the pipelines and so on, and the energy costs related to that, to get the water out to where it's needed. The proposal that CLWA has in front of them right now, is to acquire an additional 41,000 acre feet at the cost of $41 million dollars. That 41,000 acre feet is well and good. But the proposal will cripple our budget to do it. We would gut our emergency reserves, practically to zero. We would use up all the capital funding, including capital funding from existing users, to make treatment expansions or water quality improvements, to provide for emergency storage reservoirs.
Q: Why does the Newhall County Water District want to alter the way it institutes rate changes?
A: I'm perfectly comfortable with the ordinance process. Water rate (increases) are very infrequent... The ordinance process doesn't really take so long... You need to hold a hearing, and then there is a 30 day interval in which if the people object, the people have the power by referendum to overturn the board. If we're changing that from an ordinance to a resolution, the people lose that power. The board can change that arbitrarily, they can change the rates every month if they wanted to. Probably make our engineer happy, but the people would only have a 30 day window... I don't see the compelling need for it.
Q: If you could turn back the clock, when would SCOPE have said "enough is enough" and stopped development in the Santa Clarita Valley?
A: I guess I'm of two different thoughts on that. There was an implied contract with the community when the plans were developed, that 270,000 represented build out. I think that would be one representation of "enough is enough." But, I would remain a little bit more open to saying that, it should never change if you're improving the quality of life... Planning is a dynamic process, but planning also is this implied contract with the community, which should not be dismissed lightly. And so far it has been dismissed very lightly.
Q: What are the viable alternatives to not extending The Old Road between McBean Parkway and Valencia Boulevard?
A: We've offered Rockwell Canyon Road as one viable alternative. I can drive from Castaic and get on Parker Road, and drive down the Old Road, and I can get all the way down to the San Fernando Valley without having to go cross country, between Valencia and McBean on the west side of the freeway. The streets are there... I can always go down Magic Mountain Parkway to San Fernando Road, I can go down McBean to Orchard Village, get back on Lyons, or go down to San Fernando Road. The Old Road itself can be realigned so it goes west of the significant ecological area.
Q: Where do you think Santa Clarita's next road should be built?
A: I think the proposal that's on the slate right now for Magic/Princessa is a good one. There is a need for a secondary east/west access road. I would like to see Newhall Ranch Road completed to I-5 to serve the industrial center, because the industrial center was designed with the most awful conditions.
Q: Will SCOPE sue to stop the development of Newhall Ranch?
A: We haven't determined that yet. It's an open issue.
Q: Do you drink water right from your tap?
A: I drink water right from my well. I'm one of the few water district directors that's not served by the Newhall County Water District directly. I've got my own well on my property, although I do pay the property taxes to CLWA.
