In two weeks, on Oct. 13, the Santa Clarita City Council is expected to approve construction to begin on phase one of the long-delayed Central Park on Castaic Lake Water Agency-owned property on Bouquet Canyon Road.
But now a candidate for the CLWA water board has raised questions about the connection fees the city is paying CLWA for water on the property. And while sources agree no delays should be associated with building the first stage of the park, current CLWA board members and community activists are questioning the timing of public statements from CLWA candidate Ed Dunn and Santa Clarita City Manager George Caravalho regarding the fees.
Dunn, who said he "represents water in meetings with the city manager," said he brought the connection fees to Caravalho's attention at a meeting approximately a week ago.
"I was aware that there is a perfectly adequate well on that property," Dunn said, "and I questioned the city manager, and he seemed kind of upset about having to pay those connection fees."
The memorandum of understanding (MOU) between the city and CLWA, drawn up in 1995, stipulates that, for phase one of the park, the water connection fees are $366,167, which the city has paid; the figure for the entire 137 acres of park land could be $2.5 million
"I told (Caravalho) I don't think they should have paid that. I don't think it's honest and fair to pay those fees," Dunn said.
Dunn said he didn't know exactly what the fees were until Caravalho supplied him with the numbers.
CLWA board member Richard Green said Caravalho "has been involved in this process from minute one, now he's calling the fees steep? We created a detailed MOU, and the city agreed to those fees."
"There's nothing new about (the agreement)," CLWA spokesperson Kiza Stratton said. "The city agreed to pay the connection fee, which provides for service for that large expanse of land, similar to what a golf course would pay. It takes a great quantity of water; it'll be the largest community park in all of Santa Clarita. Connection fees are the means by which the agency finances its operations, and provides for the water needs for our community. It's standard."
The park, Stratton added, "is not being delayed in any way by CLWA demanding a connection fee. The water supplies have already been planned, and Santa Clarita Water Co. will be the retail provider. The main goal of the agency is for construction and completion of phase one to take place. ... There's no reason that shouldn't happen. ... If the city were allowed to not pay that fee, then the burden would fall on the community. We don't want that to happen. ... If our city manager has a disgruntlement over the fees, it should have been expressed years ago."
"I have a lease in my hand saying that the connection fees have been a done deal for an awfully long time," said David Ends, a member of the Youth Association board of directors. "I don't know what the motivation is for the snag, but George would be the one to clarify that, because he's the one who identified it."
CLWA board member Jim Gates said, "The agency and the city negotiated in good faith. It's a little bit of a surprise that George is taking this stance."
City spokesperson Gail Ortiz denied there would be any delay in augmenting phase one of the park.
"Phase one is going to go through as promised," Ortiz said. "There's not a snag."
Gates called the timing of raising the issue now, approximately a month before the CLWA board elections and two weeks before the start of construction, "a little dubious."
"The city," Gates added, "wants to put an expressway through the park, so if they say they can't pay for the park, then they can put through that roadway. It is kind of interesting timing."
Green, who is vacating his seat on the CLWA board, said he also had questions about the timing of Dunn and Caravalho's statements.
"Has this got something to do with Porta Bella, and a road that could go through that (park) property and connect up with it? It doesn't make sense," Green said. "I'm thoroughly convinced there's something wrong in the upper echelon (of city staff). It's a shame that somebody might be dragging their feet (on park construction), and it's not the City Council and it's not the CLWA board. All this has been dragged out for some other reason, but I don't know what."
Said Stratton: "When there's a CLWA election on the horizon, a great deal of misinformation is brought to the forefront."
Dunn denied that airing the issue of connection fees had anything to do with the upcoming election.
"That's not my way," Dunn said. "This is for the benefit of the public. We're just finding things out now in terms of the negotiations (between the city and CLWA). It was never brought up that they (CLWA) were going to charge those connection fees."
Ortiz also reiterated Caravalho's commitment to the park.
"There have been some discussions about subsequent phases of the park being moved," Ortiz said. "The city, including George, are absolutely committed to having a park. He would like to see more park rather than less. All he's ever tried to do is get more park land for the city. It drives him nuts that there are kids that have to be on a waiting list for a play area. I don't think (Bob) Sagehorn (CLWA general manager) or Caravalho would ever let their differences hurt the children in this valley."
