The county Board of Supervisors approved Tuesday a 90-day continuance of Transit Mixed Concrete Co.’s public hearing to appeal an earlier denial of the Soledad Canyon mining project by the county Regional Planning Commission.
The decision will postpone the Oct. 24 hearing until January, and extend the review period for the Environmental Impact Report on the project an additional 60 days.
Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, who is an opponent of the project, said the continuance will give the agencies involved in approving various permits needed to start the project more information regarding the impacts of the project on the Santa Clarita Valley.
“(The decision) will allow residents of our community and local, state, and federal agencies the opportunity to learn about the dangerous environmental impacts the Transit Mixed proposal will have,” Antonovich said in a statement Tuesday.
Transit Mixed, a subsidiary of Houston-based Southdown Inc., plans to mine 78 million tons of material to produce 56 million tons of concrete aggregate, a material used in home and road construction, from a 460-acre site in the eastern Santa Clarita Valley.
The project has garnered the approval of the Bureau of Land Management, but still must obtain a handful of permits from county, state and federal agencies including the State Water Resources Board and U.S. Fish and Game.
City officials say postponement will help the Board of Supervisors, and others, make an educated decision on the project, and clear up any issues regarding what several consider questionable environmental documents.
Many say those documents do not reflect the latest information on the project, and that the state environmental documents are inadequate.
Deborah Prosser, legal counsel hired by the city for the Transit Mixed fight, said there are a few pieces missing from the EIR, including some key technical appendices concerning water studies and South Coast Air Quality Management District documents that “show the AQMD has a different position” than is reflected in the company’s environmental statements.
“The city believes this will help the board make reasonable decisions concerning this project,” said Laurene Weste, mayor pro-tem for the city of Santa Clarita.
Weste, Deputy City Manager Rick Putnam, and Prosser, attended the meeting with several other city officials, environmentalists and community representatives, and spoke on behalf of the city.
Southdown and Transit Mixed officials were present at the meeting, and seated at the opposite side of the Board of Supervisor’s hall.
Kerry Shapiro, the attorney representing Southdown, told the Board of Supervisors that the company objected to the continuance, saying it would be best for the community if the process were started as soon as possible. Shapiro said the company was asking for no continuance, or a 30-day continuance maximum.
Shapiro also said the documents have been available for review for some time.
“The environmental documents have been under review for 60 days,” Shapiro said. “All of these various documents specifically focus on the same project alternative.”
But Antonovich said the project would require more time to carefully consider all aspects.
“This is not a project that sailed through the Regional Planning Commission,” Antonovich said. “All five planning commissioners voted against it.”
The Board of Supervisors had concerns that 30 days would have put the next meeting too close to Thanksgiving holiday. Sixty days would put it too close to the Christmas and Hanukkah.
Fourth District Supervisor Don Knabe questioned whether a 120-day continuance may be too much time, to which 2nd District Supervisor Yvonne Brathwaite Burke asked if January would preferable.
The Board of Supervisors finally decided that 90 days would be sufficient, granting the continuance and the extended public review period for the environmental documents.
The project as it is proposed is an alternative to the North Fines Storage Area (NFSA), a sub plan in the Environmental Impact Statement prepared by Transit Mixed for the Bureau of Land Management.
The NFSA reduced the size of the project from 170 million tons mined in five phases, instead of 56 million tons in two phases.
The BLM issued two, 10-year permits for the project following a successful bid by Transit Mixed over Curtis Sand and Gravel, which currently operates the mine.
The company has not made it clear whether it would seek additional permits after the two permits are up, but Transit Mixed spokesman Brian Mastin has said it is a possibility.
Southdown, the second largest producer of cement in the United States, was recently purchased by international cement giant Cemex, which is based in the northern Mexican industrial center of Monterrey.
Mastin has said the take-over would not affect the project.
