Improving the quality of California's educational system has been a growing concern among educators and the state's leaders for some time. How to do it, however, has become the center of great debate.
One suggestion, but not a new one, has been the implementation of a voucher system in which families are given public funding to attend the public or private school of their choice. The idea has been controversial — and has resurfaced as an issue in this year's race for California governor.
"There's always been talk of vouchers," said Dale Martin, a spokeswoman for the California Teachers Association.
Vouchers, or scholarships, would be given out by the government or private organizations to low-income students, allowing them a choice in where they receive their education. Many believe would it promote competition, forcing schools to better themselves in an effort to compete for funds. Others say it is not the answer.
Martin said the issue has not seriously come up in California since 1993, when it was placed as a proposition on the ballot. Then, the plan was rejected by voters. Occasionally the topic rears its head, and only a few other states have implemented or attempted to implement such programs.
"There's all sorts of public plans," Martin said.
One of the most notable has been school choice in Milwaukee, she said, which has been running since 1990. There has been mixed reaction to the program and it was recently challenged in that state's supreme court because its expanded program allows as many as 15,000 students choose between public and religious or private schools. On June 10 this year, the Supreme Court of the state of Wisconsin ruled that the program did not violate state and federal constitutions. The decision is expected to be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The topic has been revisited briefly by the two major parties' candidates for governor. Attorney General Dan Lungren has come out in support of vouchers as an option.
"The attorney general believes competition is a viable way to improve the school system," said Damian Jones, spokesman for Lungren, the Republican candidate. "If that competition is injected into the system, we're certain things will change."
Jones said vouchers are not the only way to change a failing system, however, and Lungren has no organized plan as to how he would implement the system in the state.
His Democratic opponent, Lt. Gov. Gray Davis, opposes vouchers for a variety of reasons, said spokesman Michael Bustamante. With 600,000 of California's students in parochial or private schools, which are already filled to capacity, and 6.1 million in public schools, there is no room to place kids in schools that are already crowded, he said.
"Moving kids around from one school to another doesn't solve the problem," Bustamante said. "There just isn't any room to attend private or parochial schools if they were given vouchers."
Davis, he said, chooses to focus on teacher training and accountability within the school districts.
Martin also agreed there are better ways to improve the educational system.
The CTA, she said, believes vouchers hurt schools in the process by taking money away from them. And in some cases, that money is taken out of the public school system altogether and put into private schools.
As for the belief that low achievers improve in such settings, she said, many of the studies the CTA has seen indicate the performance of these students was no better.
The voucher issue is not exactly at the forefront for Santa Clarita Valley schools. Districts such as the William S. Hart Union High School District have not really addressed the issue of late, said Leslie Crunelle, assistant superintendent for education services at the district.
"What we do have is open enrollment, which allows students the opportunity to choose," she said.
Each year a window opens up in which parents can apply for transfer to another school. Crunelle estimates 200 to 400 students district-wide have been involved in open enrollment.
"In general we have been able to honor those," she said, "It's worked quite well."
