ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Waterworld

The Santa Clarita Valley's future growth and lifestyle depend on one thing: water.

On the surface it appears to be the simplest of transactions: Castaic Lake Water Agency is charged with the responsibility of finding water for the residents and businesses of the Santa Clarita Valley.

As a wholesaler, CLWA makes that water available to four retailers: Valencia Water Co., Newhall County Water District, Santa Clarita Water Co. and Los Angeles County Water District 36.

If you live in the SCV, one of those companies supplies what comes out of your tap. It isn't, of course, free. Water bill charges reflect the cost of importing water from up north to the valley.

And water is big business all over Southern California, and particularly in the Santa Clarita area. Fifth District Los Angeles County Supervisor Mike Antonovich made it clear last summer that Newhall Ranch, a project of The Newhall Land and Farming Co., and the largest proposed development in the history of this region, would not go forward unless the key issue of water supply was addressed to the satisfaction of the Board of Supervisors.

Come the Nov. 3 election, several self-styled "reform candidates" are seeking a place on the CLWA board. The reform candidates contend that CLWA is fiscally irresponsible, alleging, among other infractions, that the current water board intends to spend $41 million on additional water purchases to supply Newhall Ranch with water — an illegal act, as, under state law, CLWA can only secure water rights for projects which have been approved by the county.

CLWA denies such charges.

But one thing both sides agree on: The control of water means the control of growth, business and lifestyle in this valley. Those who oversee the water business play a major role in shaping the future of Santa Clarita.

Report raises developing question

In February, the Castaic Lake Water Agency released a detailed Integrated Water Resources Plan Water Demand and Supply Evaluation report, prepared by Montgomery Watson Bookman-Edmonston Engineering, based on data gathered by Reiter/Lowry Consultants for CLWA.

Some elements in the report raised questions with local activists, such as the stipulation that 60,701 acre feet of water is anticipated for use in "hillside management" — areas which traditionally remain undeveloped.

But partners Glenn Reiter and Gregg Lowry said the information is based on the county assessor's records. Certain areas which are designated "national forest," "open space," "floodway/floodplain" as well as "hillside" may not be hillsides or open space at all, and areas within those designations may be assessed for development, though the development could never happen.

"We don't deal in 'what if,'" Lowry said. "We're dealers in fact. We look at what's on the assessor's records, whatever's on file at the time we do our tabulations. Some of these are generic names, designators."

There are areas which, Reiter said, the county "paints with a broad brush. ... There are regions designated hillsides which are actually flat as a pancake. In the General Plan, 10, 11 years ago, there were areas which were undeveloped, but as time moves on, things happen with the property. True, there is a lot of vacant property, and 60,701 acre feet of designated water is a lot of water. Will it be developed? We don't know. That's not our business."

Lowry agreed, "The county has not said the property will not be developed, and a lot of that property is flat terrain which could, under the proper circumstances and with county approval, be developed."

The same, the partners said, is true of the 3,182 acre feet of water designated under "national forest" and the 27,866 acre feet anticipated for use in "open space" areas.

"There could be several hundred parcels near Cleveland National Forest which the county planners have titled for future development," Reiter said. "And as for 'open space,' there's no prediction of houses on such party, but there could be, for instance, a golf course within the assessor's boundaries."

In fact, the partners agreed, planners actually "encourage the development of a golf course or park in a designated floodplain, 'cause if they get flooded, who cares?"

Lowry referred to the report as "a planning tool, to project for what's needed in the way of future water. CLWA has no land use or zoning controls whatsoever. They have to respond to what the county indicates for possible development. There are many, many potential acres which could change, which would change some of these designators."

— Chris Dickerson

Water For Newhall Ranch

David R. Vannatta is on Mike Antonvich's staff, in charge of parks, planning and development. Vannatta has organized and directed the meetings between Newhall Land and Farming, community activists and the county government staff regarding the planning and approval of Newhall Ranch. It was at Vannatta's suggestion that Antonovich made water supply for the new community development the primary element of its approval.

"We are going to require Newhall Land and Farming to identify (Newhall Ranch's) source of water," Vannatta said. "We're expecting the retailer to be identified, and we need to know that there's an adequate source of supply, or that they're going to use some other alternative (besides imported water)... We want some certainty the water's going to be there, not some nebulous assurance of 'Oh yeah, we have enough.' "

Vannatta added that the board is "being asked to support a project, knowing there's currently not adequate water supply" for the proposed 75,000 additional residents Newhall Ranch would bring to the SCV.

CLWA, Vannatta said, has told the board "they're out aggressively buying water."

But CLWA board president Bill Cooper is quick to point out that the water CLWA is negotiating to buy is not targeted for Newhall Ranch.

Bob DiPrimio, president of Valencia Water Co., the retailer identified in Newhall Land's draft Environmental Impact Report as the probable water supplier for Newhall Ranch, agreed with Cooper.

"Water utilities have a hard time focusing on one project," DiPrimio said. "We tend to look at the bigger picture."

Newhall Ranch, DiPrimio added, "although the largest (proposed development), is not the only one. CLWA and the local purveyors have worked in the last 20 years on long-term planning: not project by project, but in terms of total water needed."

And CLWA and the retailers work to make sure that, however much development may come to the SCV, current customers won't be left high and dry, DiPrimio said.

"We have specific rules and regulations to keep the water retailer from overextending itself," DiPrimio added. "It's basically going to have to a collaboration between the county, CLWA and the retailer as we move forward with development in this valley. There'll be more people moving to the valley. One project didn't create that. And we're accommodating that group by purchasing water now, when the water is available. Current customers aren't going to be burdened, new customers are. The costs will be allocated to new customers and new developers."

Searching for Water

Those costs, Cooper said, has to come from builders, which pass the expense along to new home owners.

"Existing users don't pay for future water," Cooper added. "The CLWA board has a fairness doctrine in place. The builder has to pay a connection fee to CLWA, which pays for additional pipelines and water purchases for those areas."

CLWA spokesperson Kiza Stratton said the agency "has positioned itself to buy 41,000 acre feet of (additional) water" at a projected cost of $41 million.

One acre foot of water is equal to 325,829 gallons, approximately the amount used in one year by five people.

"It's not going to cost nearly as much than if it has to be purchased later," Stratton added. "It could be double that, or triple that, or not available at all in five or 10 years."

Stratton said the water is coming from Kern County, which reportedly has some 130,000 acre feet available for purchase.

Where Water Goes

Some local activists, opposed to CLWA practices, contend the agency has a surplus of water, and that new purchases are targeted for the eventual construction of Newhall Ranch.

Allan Cameron, a co-founder of the environmentalist group SCOPE, questions CLWA's own Integrated Water Resources Plan, which was released last February.

The plan indicates a demand for 175,000 acre feet of water for use in the Santa Clarita Valley (with 8,468 acres located in Ventura County). Of that, 60,701 acre feet per year is designated for "hillside management," indicating landscaped hillsides which can not be developed; 3,182 acre feet falls under the designation of "national forest"; 27,866 acre feet for "open space"; and 5,606 acre feet for use in "floodplains."

"That's like a Zen water project," Cameron said. "If you have a floodplain, we will give you a floodplain. Are they trying to tell us they're watering empty, undeveloped hillsides? Irrigating open space areas? The national forest? This 175,000 acre feet demand, that is supposedly allocated for floodplains, open space, hillside management and the national forest is actually being stockpiled for Newhall Ranch, which legally they can't do. They're using the financial resources of their existing customers as a base to pay for the water needs of a single private landowner (Newhall Land and Farming)."

Cooper said the draft Integrated Water Resources Plan was the result of "a process we went through with two consulting firms to help put together an idea of what water demand for the future would be, and existing supplies, and recommend measures for bridging that gap."

On the questioned items indicated in the report, Cooper said, "I don't have the report here. Landscaped hillsides are irrigated in some form... Floodplain and open space could be areas that are zoned for agriculture... We don't sell to any retailers who supply the national forests. There could be areas in national forests that are set aside for recreational use... That's just off the top of my head."

Cooper said it's "absolutely incorrect" that CLWA is scouting water for Newhall Ranch before the project is approved, though he admits he's "not sure what that means" when Antonovich decreed the project wouldn't be approved unless the water was in place first.

"There's currently something like 50,000 (housing) units already approved and other land uses which have already been designated between the county and the city," Cooper said. "Water has been targeted for those builders. But some of them have been approved for years and not built yet. Now, if those developers don't build and another one comes along, the water would go to those projects."

Planning for such contingencies, Cooper added, is one of the reasons CLWA makes such purchases as the Devil's Den Ranch, north of Bakersfield, which it bought 10 years ago.

"The land came with the water rights, 12,500 acre feet of water," Cooper said. "We keep it in reserve for when it's needed."

The state allocates CLWA 54,500 acre feet of water per year, but Cooper said, "We're not guaranteed that every year. Maybe we only get 80 percent of that. So we buy water in excess to make sure enough is available. This valley's one of the few places we've never had to do water rationing because we've planned ahead."

The reform candidates for the CLWA board, Michael Kotch, president of SCOPE, Lynne Plambeck, Cam Noltemeyer, Ed Dunn and Bob Lathrop, are far from satisfied with Cooper's explanations.

"CLWA today is so inefficient that they lose money on every gallon of water they deliver," Kotch declared publicly. "Bloated expenses exceed revenue. The shortfall is made up by a property tax on all existing users."

Kotch added that the "reformists hope to wrest control of the CLWA... not to control growth, but to finally bring to Castaic, Canyon Country and Newhall the adequate, reliable water they have long wanted and never received under the incumbent board, and to ensure Valencia and Stevenson Ranch are not 'tapped out' in order to deliver water to Newhall Ranch."

"It's a fact," Cameron said. "It's been the whole history of Southern California. Controlling water is controlling development in the Santa Clarita Valley."

"Absolutely, they could do that," Cooper said. "But the obligation of this agency is to supply water. There are groups of people who think that, should they not go out and purchase water, they can stop growth. That's incorrect. Growth will come. The county planning agency will do the zoning to provide growth. If they (the CLWA water board) don't do their jobs, all it will do is create problems. The financial well-being of the valley depends on water."

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/main/1098/102598a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,074 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:v2_datefile_main
  • text:valley_names [12 distinct/60 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Valencia, Newhall, Newhall Land, Castaic Lake Water, Newhall County Water, Valencia Water]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By CHRIS DICKERSON]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Antonovich”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 9, national 0