The recent deregulation of the electricity market in California has yielded a seemingly endless stream of questions from every side of the issue.
What is electricity deregulation? How does it affect electrical service rates? And what exactly is Proposition 9, the Utility Rate Reduction and Reform Act initiative, really all about?
According to information provided by the California Public Utilities Commission, which regulates the state's electricity, natural gas, telecommunications, transportation and water industries, the state significantly changed the way the electricity industry is regulated in California as a result of legislation passed in 1996.
Referred to as "deregulation," the state instituted new legislation to deregulate the generation of electricity. While deregulation affects the generation of electricity, it does not alter the transmission or distribution of electrical power.
Approved by the state legislature and signed into law by Gov. Pete Wilson during the summer of 1996, Assembly Bill 1890 was designed to create a competitive market for California's electric utilities companies.
"The purpose of deregulation is to offer a more competitive market for the commodity of electricity," said Glen Becerra, regional manager of Southern California Edision for Santa Clarita, Simi Valley and San Fernando. "Once you remove the burden of government regulation, the companies can be in a more competitive mode."
Under one of numerous provisions of AB 1890, the state implemented regional Independent System Operator (ISO) entities throughout California to ensure the availability of power as well as the reliability of the electrical system.
"There were provisions in the bill to ensure that everyone got at least partially what they wanted," said Becerra. "AB 1890 was designed by every interest group involved, not just by the electric companies, and that's why it was such a large and complex bill."
According to Becerra, supporters of deregulation include a variety of business, consumer, labor and environmental groups, such as the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce, Consumers Coalition of California, Los Angeles County Federation of Labor and the Wind Energy Coalition.
"AB 1890 had one of the most diverse list of supporters that almost any bill has ever enjoyed," he said.
The statewide "restructuring" of the electrical service industry primarily affects the state's three major private electric utilities companies, which are Pacific Gas & Electric, San Diego Gas & Electric and Southern California Edison.
Prior to deregulation, these electric utility companies were allowed to recover the costs associated with generating electricity through the rates they charged their customers, as long as the rates were deemed "reasonable" by the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC).
"Deregulation was structured to change the industry from a government-regulated monopoly to a more open and competitive market," said Becerra.
Under deregulation, which went into effect Jan. 1, electrical service rates that customers pay are no longer set by governement-approved standards. Instead, the electrical rates are to be determined in a newly competitive market.
Deregulation also allowed the electricity companies to refinance their outstanding debts at lower interest rates through bonds provided by the state, according to Becerra.
"The amount of money the three companies were able to save was one billion dollars, which was returned to our customers in the form of a 10 percent rate reduction," said Becerra. "We're giving that savings back to the consumers."
In addition to the reported 10 percent rate cut, deregulation also established a "rate freeze" on electrical service fees, according to Becerra. The current freeze, which will hold prices at 1996 rates, will remain in effect for the four-year block of time set aside as the deregulation "transition" period.
Becerra said the transition period was instituted to allow the electric utilities companies to restructure their operations in order to implement all legislative provisions of AB 1890. He said the larger companies "really won't see any benefit for themselves until the transition period is over."
Following the four-year transition period, prices are expected to drop below existing rates, according to Becerra. "What we're trying to say is let us get through this time frame and create a competitive market," he said "Give it a chance to work."
While many consumers still remain unclear about the specifics of deregulation and its actual effects, if any, on their electrical bills, recently proposed legislation concerning the electricity service market is causing further confusion for many Californians across the state.
Proposition 9, the Utility Rate Reduction and Reform Act, is a "surgical reform measure which will allow consumers and small businesses to share in the benefits of competition," according to a public statement issued by the "Yes on 9" campaign coordinators.
"Presently (consumers) who wish to choose a different company than the three former monopoly providers still must pay a subsidy tax to the old monopolies," reads the statement. "By ending these anti-competitive subsidies, Proposition 9 allows other electricity producers to compete and offer their electricity to their consumers."
Doug Heller, a Santa Monica-based campaign coordinator for Prop 9, said he and countless others do not believe the "competitive market" and rate reduction claims being made by deregulation advocates. Heller said the 10 percent rate reduction mandated by AB 1890 is actually being funded by billions of dollars in bonds issued to the "big three" electric utilities companies.
According to Heller, the companies enacted a $28 billion utility tax to finance the costs associated with the mandatory rate cuts as well as their "uneconomic" power plants, including "white elephant" nuclear facilities.
"It's a very basic question; should utility companies be allowed to pass their billion-dollar mistakes on to consumers?," said Heller.
According to Moire Murray, also a Prop 9 supporter, the costs associated with financing the bonds exceed the savings promised by deregulation advocates.
"We get a guaranteed 10 percent rate reduction but we'll be paying for the bonds used to finance them for 10 years," she said.
According to a "pro-vote" outline regarding Proposition 9, a sampling of anticipated benefits associated with the legislation include the following:
Block the $28 billion utility bond "bailout" tax from being imposed on consumers and small businesses.
Provide an immediate 20 percent rate reduction for electrical service.
Create a competitive electricity service market for all electric utilities companies and consumers in California.
Lift the existing rate freeze to allow electricity service companies to set competitive rates. (According to a study by the California Energy Commission, rates are expected to drop as much as 32 percent under Prop 9).
Protect individual privacy by banning the sale of consumer information without consent.
Ensure that consumers have access to the information needed to choose an electric service supplier "while maintaining a safe and reliable electric system."
"This is a battle," said Heller. "The utility companies have unleashed the dogs to fight this initiative."
He said the primary opponents of Prop 9 are California's "big three" electricity companies: Pacific Gas and Electric in Northern California, Edison International (also known as Southern California Edision) and San Diego Gas and Electric, which serves the San Diego area.
"Those companies would benefit to the tune of a $28 billion bailout if Proposition 9 fails," said Heller.
According to Heller, supporters of Prop 9 include the League of Women Voters, the Sierra Club and a wide variety of others.
Despite Prop 9 allegations, Becerra said that customers are not paying new or added fees related to issued bonds.
"(The bonds) are costs related to running a business and, just like any other business, there are debts," he said. "Most companies are financing debts related to running their businesses. Those costs are always included in the product or service they provide."
In addition, Becerra contends that the bonds issued to the electric utilities companies do not total $28 billion and negates the proposition's claim that the existing 10 percent reduction is a "not true discount."
"They should really be honest because (the bonds) actually equal one-quarter of that amount," he said. "And if you use the same amount of energy today as you did in 1996, your bill will be 10 percent lower."
Carlos Guerrero, a five-year resident of Canyon Country and social studies professor at California State University at Northridge, said his electrical bills do not appear lower despite the 10 percent rate reduction.
"I haven't seen my 10 percent rollback yet," said Guerrero, who plans to vote "yes" on Prop 9. "The tax payers are going to have to fork over the money for the bonds that were used for deregulation."
Lynn Brown, a stay-at-home mother of two and a four-year resident of Castaic, said she has "no clue" how deregulation has or will affect her electricity bill. Although she said she is planning to vote in the upcoming election, Brown admits that she has yet to read any information regarding the ballot initiatives and said she is unfamiliar with Prop 9.
"I don't even pay the electricity bill at my house," said Brown. "My husband takes care of the bills. I'm way too busy taking care of our two kids to pay close attention to those things."
