The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors will decide today whether to approve permits for a sand and gravel mine in eastern Soledad Canyon.
City of Santa Clarita officials are looking for a third vote that would either kill the project or approve one with mitigations to decrease the environmental impacts of the mine.
Transit Mixed Concrete Co., a subsidiary of Houston-based Southdown Inc., plans to mine 78 million tons of material to produce 56 million tons of concrete aggregate from a 460-acre site in the eastern Santa Clarita Valley.
A representative from Second District Supervisor Yvonne Brathwaite Burke, one of the two swing votes the city is targeting, said the supervisor hasn’t made up her mind on how she’s going to vote on the project.
“(The supervisor) does not have a position on it,” said Glenda Wina, press deputy for Burke.
Wina said Burke is waiting to see what options are presented to the board and the arguments made today before he makes a decision.
Burke abstained from voting on a continuation request made by the city last week in which the board voted 2-2-1 against putting off the vote until January. Wina said Burke abstained because she thought that the project had been put on hold enough.
In all, there have been five continuances, the last being after the discovery of southwestern arroyo toads— a federally protected endangered species— on a site adjacent to the project.
Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich and Third District Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky have made it known that they intend on voting against the project.
First District Supervisor Gloria Molina’s district is home to the headquarters of Transit Mixed, based in Azusa. A press representative from Molina’s office didn’t return phone calls from The Signal on Monday.
Fourth District Supervisor Don Knabe is the other vote the city is seeking to win. However, an official from Knabe’s office Monday couldn’t confirm how the supervisor intends to vote.
During the board meeting last week, Knabe seemed concerned about the traffic impacts on state Route 14. Knabe press secretary John Musella said the supervisor is aware of how important the issue is to Santa Clarita and the surrounding communities but wasn’t available Monday for a comment.
All the supervisors with the exception of Yaroslavsky took campaign donations from Southdown and Don Newquist, a vice president with the company.
The Signal first reported when the project came before the board last year that four supervisors took donations from Southdown in 1999. However, records from 2000 and 2001 show Burke received two $1,000 contributions from Southdown, one in 1999 and one 2000. Wina said the supervisor receives thousands of dollars in contributions from different companies.
“The contributions wouldn’t have anything to do with (the supervisor’s) vote,” she said.
Knabe in total has received $1,500: $1,000 from Southdown and $500 from Newquist. Molina has received the most in donations, a total of $3,000 over two years. She received $1,000 in 1999 from Southdown, and another $1,000 in 2000, as well as $1,000 from Newquist.
Antonovich hasn’t received a donation from Southdown or Newquist since August 1999 when the supervisor received a $175 check from Newquist. Southdown also gave $1,000 to Antonovich’s coffers.
“I was not aware of a contribution by Transit Mixed Concrete to my campaign. However, people who contribute are supporting my philosophy, I am not supporting theirs,” said Antonovich when The Signal spoke to him last year about the donations.
The Signal could not contact Newquist Monday to comment on his contributions.
Records from the county clerk’s office from January 2001 - June 2001 don’t show donations from Southdown or Newquist to any of the supervisors. Campaign reports from the second half of the year are not due until Jan. 31, 2002.
* * *
The project was approved by the Bureau of Land Management— which owns the mineral rights to the land— in 1989, but is required to obtain several permits from county, state and federal agencies including the State Water Resources Board, U.S. Fish and Game and Los Angeles County.
In exchange, Transit Mixed has agreed to pay $28 million in fees to the government, of which roughly $560,000 would go to the county, according to Final Environmental Impact Statement prepared by Transit Mixed for the BLM.
The site would also include a ready-mixed facility which will produce Portland cement concrete for construction in the local market area, while the remaining aggregates would be shipped to other parts of greater Los Angeles, among them other ready-mixed concrete facilities in the San Fernando Valley.
Santa Clarita has recognized that it does not have a say in approving the project, but is fighting it, along with several other local agencies, boards, organizations and individuals, of which 20 have filed appeals with the BLM.
The Santa Clarita City Council has set aside more than a million dollars to challenge the project, which city officials have said will have a “devastating” effect on the community.
Transit Mixed officials have made it clear that the decision on the project has already been made, but have acknowledged that the county’s role is to provide reasonable environmental mitigation.
Southdown, the second largest producer of cement in the United States, was purchased last year by international cement giant Cemex Inc., based in the northern Mexican industrial center of Monterrey.
