With 100 percent of the precincts reporting — though final absentee vote counts will not be tallied until Friday — the race for the Castaic Lake Water Agency board appears to be over, with only the contest between Ed Dunn and incumbent Randall Pfiester a close one.
ED DUNN
Won By 83 Votes
Dunn apparently squeezed by Pfiester by only 83 votes in Division One. The tally Wednesday morning was Dunn, 4,999 votes (50.42 percent of the vote) to Pfiester's 4,916 (49.58 percent).
For the at-large seat, Richard Balcerzak easily defeated opponents Robert Lathrop, Cam Noltemeyer and Brian Roney, drawing more than 67 percent, or 21,618 votes.
Peter Kavounas defeated Lynne Plambeck in Division Two, with 6,380 votes to Plambeck's 3,664, and in Division Three, Mike Kotch lost to Donald Froelich by drawing 4,879 votes to Froelich's 7,876.
"I forgot what famous politician said it, but 'losing sucks,' " Kotch said Wednesday.
Kotch, Plambeck, Lathrop, Noltemeyer and Dunn positioned themselves as "reform candidates" for the CLWA board, in an effort to, as they claimed, make the board more fiscally responsible. They also alleged the current board was too much under the control of The Newhall Land and Farming Co.
"It was a good effort. I think we ran a good, clean campaign," Kotch said of the challenge by the reform group. "We didn't have the phone banks or the large donors. With the money we were able to put together we tried to get the message out."
"I think it was predictable," Plambeck said of the outcome. "I knew it was a long shot. I was talking to somebody (election night) and they said they voted for the people with the big signs. ... I don't have the money to get the message out there to the people. ... They went for the big flashy fliers and the big signs and the ones who have money."
Plambeck's opponent, Kavounas, said, he believed the voters received his message.
"I think the voters appreciated my message more," he said. "Let's be responsible to the taxpayers, and let's be as open as we can about things. The board, as I've seen it operate, is a group of professionals."
Noltemeyer, though not affiliated with the organization SCOPE (Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment), of which Kotch and Plambeck are president and first vice president, respectively, aligned herself with the reform candidates, saying, "I think we tried to get the message out there, and I think Newhall Land and Farming's stock will go sky high. I hope the people won't complain about the overcrowded schools and the overcrowded roads now. ... The voters have had their say and they have to live with it. Newhall Land and Farming has all its puppets lined up now: the City Council, the water board, Buck McKeon, George Runner, they have all their ducks in a row."
As the incumbent who pulled the largest majority, Balcerzak said he was "astounded" by his wide margin of votes.
"I had a good ballot statement and I think I'm very well qualified to be on the board," Balcerzak said. "I understand the water industry and I think I put across that notion to the public."
But Balcerzak said he wasn't pleased about incumbent Pfiester's apparent loss to Dunn.
"Randy worked real hard on the campaign, and I just feel badly about him not getting in," Balcerzak added. "What won it for Ed Dunn was the ballot designation."
Dunn listed himself on the ballot as a water resources consultant, though he has declined to identify any of his clients, and neither CLWA, the City of Santa Clarita, nor any of the major water retailers in the valley have employed him as a water consultant.
Pfiester listed himself on the ballot as a research scientist, and said Wednesday, "That was probably a mistake. Mr. Dunn listed himself as a water consultant, and I regret not taking him to task over that."
While Pfiester gave Dunn credit for "walking almost the entire area" to drum up votes, he said "there was some misrepresentation. He said the $41 million (CLWA is expected to spend for an additional 41,000 acre feet of water) would be paid by current customers, and that's incorrect. But when you hit people with a 41 million dollar hammer and you strike fear in peoples' hearts, that's what you get."
Dunn could not be reached for comment Wednesday.
Kotch, who currently serves on the CLWA board as an appointed member from the Newhall County Water District, said that Dunn identifying himself as a water consultant "could have made a difference" in the Division One race.
"But then, four years ago, Randy defeated the incumbent in that district, so maybe in Division One, they're just more independent," Kotch added.
