Closing arguments began Monday in San Fernando Superior Court in the trial of Alex Yepes of Valencia accused in a pair of 1993 home invasion kidnap-bank robberies.
"On one side," Defense Attorney Joseph Gutierrez told jurors, "you have the FBI, the U.S. Attorney, the District Attorney, the LAPD and the Sheriff's Department. What does Alex have? He has the constitution ... the presumption that a defendant is innocent until he is proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt."
Gutierrez spoke at length about evidence in the case and testimony given by more than two dozen witnesses during the two-month trial. He detailed Yepes' alibi defense, saying again that Yepes was at the home of his friend, Julie Appel, on the night of June 10, 1993 when masked gunmen took over the Canyon Country home of a Trans World Bank employee and held her family hostage.
He was still at Appel's house the next morning, Gutierrez said, when the gunmen kidnapped the employee, took her to the bank on Soledad Canyon Road and forced her to open the bank vaults.
The employee and members of her family who testified during the trial that Yepes was among the kidnap-robbers were mistaken, Gutierrez said.
"The witnesses are feeling justifiable outrage," he said. "They want to believe the person accused of the crime is the person who did the crime. This man is innocent, ladies and gentlemen."
But Deputy District Attorney Susan Chasworth painted a different picture in her closing statements, which preceded those by Gutierrez.
Yepes, 30, was the guy in charge, Chasworth said. He and friends Darren Towers and Brett Pelch, and younger brother Chad Pelch pulled the June 1993 robbery and an almost identical heist three months later in Northridge, except with Donald Sallee in Chad Pelch's place.
Chasworth said the state has met its burden of proof, that evidence and testimony clearly points to Yepes. Also, common sense and Yepes own actions would indicate Yepes is guilty, she said.
Immediately after the first robbery, Yepes started living large — buying cars and taking trips he could not have afforded on his salary as a playground monitor at the SCV Boys and Girls Club. He paid cash for a $12,000 Ford Thunderbird on the same day as the robbery and, a few days later, booked and paid for a vacation at Club Med in Cancun, Mexico.
"After June 11, money was no longer a concern for Alex Yepes," she said. "He bought an $18,500 (sport utility vehicle) using money orders issued under false names without having to sell the Thunderbird or the (Mazda) RX7."
When authorities started to close in and he was under subpoena by a federal Grand Jury, Yepes bolted and started "living the life of a fugitive" rather than operating within the law to prove his innocence, Chasworth said.
Gutierrez is expected to conclude his arguments today, followed by a final summation by Chasworth and instructions to the jury. Deliberations should begin later this week, officials said.
