The Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment has filed a Brown Act complaint with the city of Santa Clarita "for its discussion and approval of improperly agendized items regarding the controversial Newhall Ranch Project."
On Nov. 10, the City Council allowed discussion of a compromise proposal regarding management of the High Country and the Santa Clara River in Newhall Ranch, the largest proposed housing development in the history of the county. The item was not listed on the council's published agenda.
SCOPE contends that the action was in violation of the Ralph M. Brown Act, California's "Open Meeting" Law, specifically section 54954.2 regarding the posting of the agenda for government meetings.
The law states that the agenda must be posted 72 hours before the regular meeting of the legislative body; items not posted are restricted from being discussed or voted upon, except under certain conditions as defined by the law.
In a letter to Mayor Jan Heidt from SCOPE President Michael Kotch, Kotch notes that the "agreement regarding the open space was reached Nov. 5. This was well in advance of the posting requirement and therefore the item should have been posted."
The Nov. 5 meeting was attended by city staff members and Councilwoman Laurene Weste, representatives from The Newhall Land and Farming Co., the developers of Newhall Ranch, a member of the county planning commission, and representatives from the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy and the Center for Natural Lands Management, who will play a role in the management of the High Country if the housing development is approved by the County Board of Supervisors.
Newhall Ranch is scheduled to come before the board Tuesday morning. After Nov. 10, the city council would not meet again until Tuesday evening, and according to city staff official Jeff Lambert, this was the reason the topic had to be brought before the council on Nov. 10.
"What we suggested to the council was that we needed immediate action," Lambert said. "We didn't want to take the chance that the board of supervisors would go ahead and act without the council's input."
Lambert added that, while the compromise was reached on Thursday, "there were still some items to be worked out." He also said that, as the City Council agenda is issued on Thursday, there was no time to add the Newhall Ranch item.
A Nov. 9 memo from City Manager George Caravalho informed Mayor Heidt and the city council that a 14 point agreement had been reached.
David Vannatta, deputy to Fifth District Supervisor Mike Antonovich, said that he was informed that a resolution of the high country and open space management topics had been reached, "and that makes it possible for the Nov. 24 hearing to move forward, because it's one thing to say this is a staff recommendation, and another thing entirely to say the City Council approves of this."
But Lambert said he talked to Vannatta on Nov. 9 — the day before the council met and approved the compromise — and told Vannatta "that all parties around the table had reached a conceptual agreement, and that we'd bring it to the council Tuesday night, and I'd call him the next day and let him know what the response is."
City attorney Carl Newton said, "Vannatta misunderstood. He may have misconstrued what Jeff said from the fact that a member of the City Council (Weste) was present" on the compromise committee.
Newton added that the late announcement and the council's action on Newhall Ranch was within the law, citing section 54954.2, sub paragraph (b) (2) of the Brown Act.
"When the matter came up, this issue was presented as an immediate action item," Newton said.
The section Newton cited states, "Upon a determination by a two-thirds vote of the legislative body ... that there is a need to take immediate action and that the need for action came to the attention of the local agency subsequent to the agenda being posted."
"The need," Newton said, "was for the council to take a position (on the management of the High Country), because it was the only chance they'd have before the Nov. 24 board of supervisors meeting. The board could conceivably take final action on that date, and if the city's input isn't in there, it could be detrimental."
Vannatta said that the Nov. 24 hearing would not be "the final approval on Newhall Ranch. It's an intent to approve," but he added that final approval would probably not take place until early 1999.
The SCOPE letter calls upon the city, within 30 days, "to either cure or correct" its activities of Nov. 10 regarding Newhall Ranch, "or inform us of your decision not to do so."
Otherwise, the organization said it will ask a judge to overturn the city's action.
