In the ongoing battle between the city of Santa Clarita and Transit Mixed Concrete Co. — the company that wants to expand mining in the eastern Santa Clarita Valley— one man has silently watched, waging his own war against the federal government and a mining giant.
Ben Curtis is a miner. Sand and gravel are his life, his family’s life. Mining is what he knows, what he is good at. He is a remnant of a time past, owner of one of just a handful of family-operated mining companies left in the state.
So, in the 1980s, when all the turmoil began over a spot where he mined sand and gravel just outside city limits in Soledad Canyon, Curtis went to war.
Curtis is fighting Southdown Corp., which through its Transit Mixed arm is planning to mine 78 million tons of material to produce 56 million tons of concrete aggregate from the deep, rich earth in Soledad Canyon.
Curtis owns the surface rights to the land above what could prove to be a prime source of raw materials for construction in both Santa Clarita and other parts of the county, particularly the San Fernando Valley. Curtis is a self-proclaimed mining man, and has been one on that property since 1969.
“This is a real basic business,” he said. “We employ about 70 people, mostly truck drivers who haul our concrete around town. We have a real low profit factor.
“It’s the only thing I know how to do. It’s all I’ve ever done in my life, it’s all my father did and his father before him, and it’s all my sons have done in their life and it’s our business. Once they move in, it’s all gone,” Curtis said.
* * *
“They” is Transit Mixed, aka Cemex, which recently finalized its purchase of Southdown Corp.
Under the merger agreement, Cemex— the world’s third-largest producer of cement— will run all of Southdown’s operations, with Clarence C. Comer, Southdown’s president and chief executive, becoming president and chief executive of the new division.
Southdown, the No. 2-cement maker in the United States, produces 11 million metric tons a year at 12 cement plants and is making investments to boost capacity to 12.8 million tons by 2002, primarily through expansions and new projects in California and Florida.
And then there’s Ben Curtis— a long way from Monterrey, Mexico, where the new parent of Transit Mixed is located.
At his office, his sons drop by at random times and dogs occasionally run past the door, which displays “BLM” in large letters with a red circle and slash through it. Curtis and his wife Dianne, manage the company with the help of sons Jason, 25, and Dale, 28.
Jason is the yard-rock plant supervisor. Dale is in charge of transportation at the quarry. The two also run No Limit Crushing, which turns concrete demolition debris back into building materials. Dianne is responsible for her trucking company Canyon Bulk Inc.
Dale comes in to get a piece of meat from his dad’s small office refrigerator.
“They’re burning down at the shop,” Dale said.
Jason is outside riding dirt bikes, a family hobby. He comes in later to talk to his father about a tricky bolt. While he is talking, he stands in front of a school picture that must have been taken when he was 12 or 13 years old.
With the community’s anti-mine sentiment running high, Curtis will tell you he would have mined that property, too.
He would also tell you that the community should not be against mining, but that it should be concerned that such a large company would want to invade the town. And he would also explain the nightmare it has been for him to try to hold on to that piece of land that has such a deep, rich supply of sand and gravel.
* * *
Curtis has no plans to quit without a fight.
“We’ve got a stake in this community,” Curtis said.
He had hoped to pass the mine on to his sons.
“When you’re in this business and you have the opportunity to buy a quarry like that, that’s got a lot of material, (it) will keep your family in business for decades to come,” he said. “There’s more than two billion tons of material there.”
Two billion? Curtis would know.
“No one knows that mine better than he does,” Jason Curtis said. Ben Curtis’ grandfather and two uncles brought their operation from Washington and started mining in Soledad Canyon in 1968, taking over an existing operation by A.E. Shirley and Son.
Curtis mined the property until a 1983 Supreme Court decision—Watt vs. Western Nuclear—put sand and gravel under federal ownership, and Curtis was forced to bid on a federal contract to mine his own land.
Mineral rights themselves came under federal ownership with the Homestead Act of 1916, and the 1983 court decision added sand and gravel to the list of minerals covered.
When the government owns the mineral rights to the land and a private citizen owns the surface rights, the property comes to be known as a split estate.
“This is not an unusual phenomenon, the concept of a split estate is not uncommon,” said Leroy Mohorich, a branch chief engineer for the federal Bureau of Land Management, a branch of the Interior Department.
According to the federal government, private ownership only goes so far, and in the case of mineral rights, it is the property owner who must make concessions to the government.
“Under the split estate the mineral is the dominant estate,” Mohorich said.
The BLM, which manages the ownership of those federal ownership rights, can issue permits to mine under private property. According to BLM officials, the only concessions required from those who mine the land are compensation for damage to agriculture.
“We don’t require them to work out a lease agreement,” Mohorich said. “Both property owners and those mining underneath the property have a right to be there” under federal law.
“It makes it difficult to manage sometimes,” Mohorich admitted.
In Curtis’ case, he felt the land was his to mine.
“It took us a couple of times in court to get the federal government to put the project up for bid,” Curtis said.
Officials from the BLM filed a notice of trespass when Curtis Sand & Gravel continued to mine the land, and a series of court proceedings resulted in the BLM putting the project up for bid.
“No one else bid the project, only Transit Mixed and us,” Curtis said.
Transit Mixed outbid Curtis Sand & Gravel for the future mining project, offering 50 cents per ton for 56 million tons, to Curtis’ 16.5 cents per ton for 100 million tons.
“This is probably the largest sand and gravel contract in terms of tonnage ever issued by the BLM,” Mohorich said.
Curtis defended his low bid by saying he never intended to take 100 million tons out of the mine, but that the agreement would have called for him to pay $16 million to the BLM.
He said that regardless of whether Curtis Sand & Gravel would have extracted 100 million tons or 10 million tons, he would have paid $16 million to the federal government, because that was the agreed figure.
In his eyes, bidding high volume, low per-tonnage was smart business, especially for a small, family-owned and -operated community business.
“They (Southdown) make $90 million in profit a year. I haven’t made $90 million in 10 years of total sales,” Curtis said.
But to the BLM, being outbid is being outbid, and following unsuccessful legal attempts by Curtis to nullify the deal, Transit Mixed was awarded two 10-year contracts.
In exchange, Transit Mixed has agreed to pay $28 million in fees to the government, of which more than $21 million would go to the Federal Land and Reclamation Fund and $5.6 million to the federal treasury.
According to the final Environmental Impact Statement for the project, prepared for the BLM by Transit Mixed, “four percent of the royalties (or $1.12 million) will go to the state of California, and half of those receipts ($560,000) will go to the county.”
The BLM approved the environmental documents for the project Aug. 1, despite a county rejection of the project. The proposed site is a little more than a mile outside of city limits; thus the city has had no official say in the project’s fate.
The Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission rejected approvals for the project last December, but Transit Mixed has appealed to the County Board of Supervisors. In October, the county supervisors granted a 90-day continuance for the public review period for the environmental documents for the Soledad mine.
The project, as approved by the BLM, is an alternative known as the North Fines Storage Area (NFSA) as identified in the environmental documents. The NFSA reduced the size of the project to 56 million tons mined in two phases, instead of 170 million tons in five phases, and reduced the visual impacts of the project.
In addition to mining, the site would also include a ready-mixed facility that would produce Portland cement concrete for construction in the local market area. The remaining aggregates would be shipped to other parts of greater Los Angeles, among them other ready-mixed concrete facilities in the San Fernando Valley.
Transit Mixed has not made it clear whether it would seek additional permits after the two permits are up, but Transit Mixed spokesman Brian Mastin has said it is a possibility.
* * *
In the face of heavy community opposition, Transit Mixed said it is legally bound to that contract with the federal government, sometimes— according to critics— hiding behind that fact. That posturing, along with what many consider detrimental effects to the quality of life in the SCV, is what caused the city to begin fighting Transit Mixed.
The Santa Clarita City Council conducted a study session in August, at which officials from Transit Mixed and Southdown tried to explain the project and offer answers to those who had concerns about the scope of the Soledad mine.
But to some, it just added fuel to the fire. Opponents said the felt that officials from Southdown sounded arrogant.
Twenty local organizations, elected officials and governmental agencies have filed appeals with the BLM’s decision to approve the mining operation. Among the opponents are the city of Santa Clarita, U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, County Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, the Castaic Lake Water Agency and the William S. Hart Union School District.
“(This is) one of the most threatening plans to ever be proposed in the Santa Clarita Valley,” Mayor Jo Anne Darcy said in a recent letter to community leaders. “If approved, this plan will devastate our quality of life in the Santa Clarita Valley.”
Darcy— who served as a field representative for Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich until her recent retirement—has known about the project since the early 1990s, said Curtis, when she and a handful of other Antonovich representatives visited the site of the Soledad mine.
“We brought them out here along with the people from the Regional Planning Commission and we took them up to the site. My wife made lunch for everybody, and we explained 10 years ago exactly what was going to happen to this community.” Curtis said.
Now that the city is in the mix, Curtis said he doesn’t feel so alone in the fight.
“I was a little concerned for a while,” Curtis said. “Because I was outside the city limits I didn’t think they would do anything about it.”
But now that the city has stepped in?
“We’ve been battling with (Transit Mixed) on and off since 1986,” Curtis said. “The folks who are just getting on the bandwagon have missed a whole lot of fun.”
Both the city and Transit Mixed have remained fairly silent since the last Board of Supervisors meeting, at which four of the five county supervisors— First District Supervisor Gloria Molina was absent— voted to postpone the appeal hearing until Jan. 23.
“Right now the city is researching environmental information in order to prepare for the next Board of Supervisors meeting,” said Stacy Miller, the city’s intergovernmental affairs representative.
City spokeswoman Gail Ortiz said if the Board of Supervisors rules in favor of Transit Mixed, the city will appeal the decision.
“The fact is this project is just too big,” Ortiz said. “We understand that this property is zoned to be a mine, but what we oppose is the grand scale.”
Since May, the city has spent about 25 percent of the more than $1 million it set aside to fight Transit Mixed, a memo from City Manager George Caravalho to the Mayor and City Council said.
“Of the total budget ($1,119,182) it is estimated that $898,158 will be spent towards consulting services,” the memo states. “The community outreach campaign is estimated to cost $103,023.68.”
The city has nine staff members committed to the project for a certain number of hours each week, which total 186 at a total cost per week of $6,337.61, according to a budget history prepared by the city.
“This project would be like nothing else the valley has ever seen,” Ortiz said.
How does Transit Mixed see the situation?
The firm, viewed by opponents as the mega-mining conglomerate that wants to arrogantly muscle its way in, only wants to find its place in the community, Mastin said.
He said the company prides itself on being a good neighbor to the communities where it operates, including Moorpark and Azusa where it has sand and gravel quarries, as well as areas of Southern California where it has ready-mix cement plants and smaller mines.
Mastin said the company will do its best to not have a negative impact on the community.
“We’re going to comply with all the permit conditions very carefully,” Mastin said. “In addition, we’re going to supply the materials the community needs to accommodate growth.”
Mastin said the company realizes the importance of community service as well as the mine’s history.
“A lot of the homes in the Santa Clarita Valley were constructed from materials that came out of that mine,” Mastin said.
* * *
For now, the property sits unused, and the equipment left behind has begun to deteriorate, lying idle in the silent canyon. And still Curtis fights, in the same way he continues to mine at another site a few miles from the Soledad mine site, because it’s all he knows anymore.
Curtis said his family have had a major part in laying the foundation for future mining at that site, and have a vested interest in keeping it.
“Who pays us for getting the zoning changed in 1969? Who pays us for pioneering the road and the pit? All that expensive pioneering has already been done and we don’t get a nickel. We’re a little frustrated,” he said.
Frustration aside, Curtis said he doesn’t want to fight the BLM or Transit Mixed. All he wants is to mine his land.
“Nobody can believe that No. 1, the government took away our minerals away from us like that, and number two that we don’t get paid for it,” he said.
The mine will outlive most of the people involved in it, but in his eyes, Curtis is trying to protect something that could potentially have been an investment for future generations for his family.
He is a man who is tied to the community, a man who donates time and money to several causes, a man who gives his phone number to neighbors and tells them to call him when they have a complaint.
The constant fighting has been difficult.
“These lawsuits keep us broke,” Curtis said. “When I make that kind of investment in a lawyer, that means that I’ve got to go ahead and not buy a new crusher or try and lower my price to get my volumes up to pay for it.”
And if the project gets approved, Curtis said he will try for subsequent contracts— although he admits it seems unlikely he would be able to compete.
“I’m sure there are going to be more than two 10-year contracts,” Curtis said. “It may be 100 years from now when I get my surface (land) back.”
He also said if he loses, he would still have to pay property taxes, which would jeopardize the future of Curtis Sand & Gravel.
“We’ll be pretty much out of business,” Curtis said. “And still paying their property taxes.”
