The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has told Placerita Junior High School to change their uniform policy or risk being sued.
The ACLU is investigating two policies — a single-vendor rule and an opt-out policy — it says are in violation of state law.
According to the ACLU, policy wording doesn't clearly let parents know that uniforms are optional, not required for school attendance. Also in question is Placerita's request for parents to shop at one store.
Carol Graham, a parent whose son attends the school, wrote to the ACLU with her complaint after finding the policies too rigid.
For now, children who "opt out" must "get out" of Placerita, a regulation requiring non-uniform wearing students to transfer to La Mesa Junior High.
ACLU Associate Director Elizabeth Schroeder calls the rule "illegal" and says her organization plans to fight it. "If students opt out, no reprisals can be taken against them in any way," she said. "There's no wiggle room in the state statute."
The Long Beach School District fought and lost a similar case to the ACLU in February 1996, and Schroeder hopes Placerita won't follow the same example.
Currently, parents who don't want their children wearing uniforms must meet in person with Placerita's principal and the district superintendent. These face-to-face meetings are problematic, according to Schroeder, because working parents seldom have extra time during the day. Schroeder would like to see Placerita accept handwritten notes in lieu of personal conferences.
Should opting out become as simple as a note, Placerita Principal Ron Gapper believes the uniform policy would fade. "How effective do you think we'd be if some kids wore uniforms and others didn't?" he asked. "I'm defending a decision parents made. It wasn't the school board who decided on uniforms."
Lobbying the school board for Placerita uniforms was parent and UCLA law professor Gonzalo Freixes. He believes uniforms improved the school, describing the "old" Placerita as plagued with institutional hazing, daily violence and problems with vandalism.
"Uniforms promote discipline and order," Freixes said. "Why do you think the military and private schools use them? In Long Beach, violence on campus dropped 50 percent after going to uniforms."
Freixes said he knew he was on the right track when — shortly before the uniform policy passed — a student bullied his son on the playground.
"I'm a Democrat," he said. "But civil liberties go out the window when it's your child being banged around."
Freixes hopes Placerita stands tall against the ACLU. "I urge the school district to fight this," he said. "They have more to lose by waffling on the policy."
Graham admits she's not against uniforms — she just wants more flexibility with the rules, especially the single-vendor policy.
Cherokee, a national company specializing in uniforms, produces Placerita's line. Unfortunately, the style of uniforms Placertia chose is sold only at Santa Clarita School Uniforms in Canyon Country.
After noticing different Cherokee lines for less money in other stores, Graham got upset. "Target has a uniform department and Cherokee makes it," she said. "Wal-Mart has a uniform department and Cherokee makes it. I'm not poor, but I can't afford to waste money when I have three kids."
Graham wants Placerita to loosen its grip on brand-specific uniforms and allow her to shop where she likes.
"I question if this policy is wise," said Schroeder. "I know of no other district with such requirements. Forcing parents to buy uniforms is illegal."
Yet according to Graham, her last conversation with Gapper wasn't positive. A meeting between Gapper and representatives from Cherokee resulted in the uniform company denying the line marketed in larger stores.
Gapper defends the single-vendor policy because he says it ensures compliance with the schools "special fit" rules and makes campus security easier.
Outside of the security issue, Gapper says proper-fit rules keep brand names that are associated with gangs off school grounds.
"That argument doesn't hold water," said Schroeder, "No other campus has such security problems and the issue's never been raised. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to see someone's pants are three sizes too big. I think the school could easily identify that."
Gapper disagreed, saying, "We don't want kids to emulate something that's not healthy."
In theory, Schroeder understands his concern, but not when security is used to explain why parents must shop at one store.
"The spirit of the law was to ensure students are easily identified as being students of a particular school," Schroeder said. "They should dress for the business of school. It makes no difference if a girl wears a navy blue jumper from Target, or a navy blue jumper from Cherokee."
A seemingly small argument leaves the fate of Placerita's uniform policy hanging in the balance. For that, Freixes has one question: "I'd like to know if the woman who made the complaint is willing to ruin the whole system so she can save five dollars on a pair of pants?"
The answer to his question could be yes. "Unless there's more freedom with the policy," said Graham. "I will opt out and I will make it public."
