The proposed Westridge Golf Course Community was a major topic at the Santa Clarita City Council meeting Tuesday night and before the Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission Wednesday morning, but the anticipated 800-acre development failed to win final approval from either government body.
Still, regional planning staff member Lee Stark said Westridge has only a short distance to go before the commission passes it on to the county Board of Supervisors to begin the final approval process.
Westridge, a development planned by The Newhall Land and Farming Co., situated west of Interstate 5, south of Magic Mountain Parkway and north of McBean Parkway, is expected to host 1,712 housing units along with an 18-hole tournament-style golf course.
Tuesday night, members of SCOPE (Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment) and representatives of the Oak Conservancy asked the City Council to appeal Westridge's approval by the planning commission to the board of supervisors.
But council members Frank Ferry and Laurene Weste, supported by Mayor Jo Anne Darcy, voted against the appeal.
"It hadn't yet passed the planning commission," Weste said. "Our staff had just gotten the final EIR (Environmental Impact Report), they didn't have anything to give us."
Stark said the final EIR was distributed just before Thanksgiving.
"It hasn't been approved by anybody yet, the (city) staff hasn't reported on the final EIR, so we voted to keep working on it," Weste added.
But mayor pro-tem Jill Klajic, who voted with councilmember Jan Heidt for the appeal, said a vote to appeal Westridge was "going to be contingent on (the planning commission's) approval. ... We should not just give up on these things. The philosophy that if we just go along with the county, they'll do what we want, is ridiculous. The county hasn't done what we want in 10 years."
But the planning commission stopped short of approving Westridge Wednesday, in what was expected to be a mere formality with the item on the consent calendar.
Stark said the commission "wanted some adjustment, some clarification on the findings and conditions for approval."
Specifically, Stark said, the commissioners want "to make it clear that the open space will be dedicated to a public agency," and that among other items "that the golf course design meets the standards of the International Audubon Society; the most substantial change is in making sure that the course is open to the public for 15 years."
The original plan called for the golf course to be guaranteed as public for 10 years, before possibly going to private membership.
Weste said of such changes, "It's movement from where we were. I battled this with Newhall Land, to keep the open space public, not private. And I would have like to have seen the golf course guaranteed for 20 years. The public needs to know, once they're given something, it's theirs."
SCOPE vice president Lynne Plambeck, who spoke before Tuesday night's council and attended Wednesday's commission meeting, lamented the lack of time between release of the final EIR and the commission's hearing, and while she said she was satisfied with the reduction of the loss of oak tress from approximately 250 to about 200, she expressed little confidence in the International Audubon Society.
"Fifty percent of their funding comes from golf course associations," Plambeck said. "They have nothing to do with the National Audubon Society. They just use the name to try to make themselves look environmental."
Weste disagreed, and expressed her confidence in the organization.
"They worked with the city on the course at Sand Canyon (Hunters Green)," Weste said. "They're very good. They're able to help write the guidelines and make it work."
Stark said the commission directed the planning staff to make changes "and come back to them next week. It won't be difficult to meet their conditions."
If those conditions are met, Stark said he anticipated that Westridge would be submitted to the board of supervisors "by the end of February at the earliest, probably closer to March."
