A proposal to add eight housing units on 2.4 acres to Happy Valley in Newhall met with lengthy discussion but little opposition at Tuesday night's meeting of the city of Santa Clarita Planning Commission.
The primary focus of the two-hour discussion was whether sidewalks should be allowed on both Valley and Maple streets, or on only one side of the road in the project being developed by Williams Homes, Inc.
While there are numerous oak trees in the L-shaped lot at the northeast corner of Valley Street and Maple, south of Lyons Avenue, Jennifer Reid of the city planning staff told the commission that builder Lance Williams "isn't proposing that any trees be removed, and the applicant is planning to plant an additional eight live oaks," a scenario that met with the approval of Cynthia Neal Harris, vice president of the Santa Clarita Oak Conservancy.
The approval Williams sought included a permit "to encroach into the protected zones of 10 (oak) trees."
But as part of the "condition of approval mechanism," Reid added, the building plan can be "brought back to the planning commission for further public discussion if a situation arises where there will be any future impact on the oak trees."
After an extended discussion over whether sidewalks would balance safety issues with the area's rural atmosphere, the commission voted unanimously to construct a sidewalk only on the Maple Street side of the development, and to allow an adjustment to reduce the front yard setback of the homes by 20 percent, from the required 20 feet to 16 feet.
