Sharing information as complex as the issue itself, a William S. Hart Union High School District boundary committee presented trustees with three intricate proposals regarding future school attendance areas at the district's board meeting Wednesday night.
The Hart district is hoping to build four new schools within the next six years: Rio Norte Junior High near the corner of McBean Parkway and Decoro Road, Golden Valley High School in the area of the same name; and Rancho Pico Junior High School and West Ranch High School in Stevenson Ranch.
The three school boundary plans, simply dubbed "1," "2" and "3," each detailed proposals through 2001, when a fifth junior high and high school are expected to be built, and 2004, when a sixth junior high and high school campus hope to open.
Plans 1a/1b focus on the "EPOD" theory — Equalization of Percentage Over Design Capacity. Under the plan, there would be parity in overcrowding at local schools based on their physical size, space availability and infrastructure. For example, because older campuses cannot accommodate a large number of students, they would be able to maintain smaller populations.
"We tried to equalize the percentage (of students) over (the capacity) which would affect the comfort level," said Plan 1a/1b spokeswoman Teresa Todd.
The 2001 plan helps relieve overcrowding at Arroyo Seco Junior High by sending students at Helmers and Mountainview Elementary schools, and a portion of students at Emblem Elementary School, to Rio Norte Junior High; the 2004 plan includes sending Castaic students to West Ranch High, relieving pressure at Valencia High School.
"As far as our subcommittee, this plan does not favor any one special interest group," Todd said. "It appears to be fair and impartial."
Plans 2a/2b immediately address the issue of overcrowding at Arroyo Seco Junior High, redistricting 271 students without the assumption of Rio Norte Junior High being open.
The plans also keep attendance areas at all but two of the 28 elementary schools intact; the exceptions are Emblem and Stevenson Ranch Elementary schools, which plan 2a/2b spokeswoman Nancy Mickel said all three plans had to split.
"Our objective in these two plans was to preserve the student clusters from kindergarten through high school," Mickel said.
Plans 3a/3b focused in part on travel ease and safety, using main streets as boundary dividing lines. A main priority, said spokeswoman Suzy Gue, was the concept of "feeder" schools, in which students at one junior high campus attend a corresponding high school.
Rochelle Neal, principal of La Mesa Junior High School, said she supports the idea of feeder schools because it keeps neighborhoods together.
"At my school, they come from way out in Valencia and east in Canyon Country," Neal said. "That's a lot of busing."
One characteristic of plan 3a involves filling Sierra Vista Junior High, currently underpopulated, to near capacity. Plan 3b would see the junior high campus at capacity.
Also in plan 3b, Placerita Junior High and Hart High schools have a relatively small boundary, while La Mesa Junior High and Golden Valley High's attendance area takes up a large chunk of the Hart district. Students who live in the Valencia Summit area would go to Rancho Pico Junior High and West Ranch High School.
Wednesday night's proposals were for the board's information only; a vote is scheduled within the next several weeks, after more study and public feedback. Detailed proposed boundary maps and lists of what elementary schools would feed into what secondary schools are forthcoming for public consumption.
The board may not vote on just one proposal; officials said they may blend parts of each for a final solution.
"If you laid these plans one on top of the other, you'd see there's more in common than there are differences," said Michael von Buelow, assistant superintendent of personnel for the Hart district, "but the differences are important and those are the areas our committee struggled over long and hard."
The boundary committee, comprised of nearly 35 representatives from every school in the Santa Clarita Valley, has met five times since June. Participants solicited input from their respective communities and studied maps, roads, future development plans and current elementary and secondary school boundaries as well as other issues.
Six criteria — designated school capacities, travel ease and safety, ethnic and socioeconomic balance, junior/senior high clusters, integrity of elementary school communities and transportation costs — were used in determining the best course of action for each plan.
"The committee recognized through their detailed work that not all the criteria ... could be met completely," von Buelow said. "(The process) was not nearly as easy as we had envisioned it might be."
One solution to the boundary crisis, said newly-elected Board President John Hassel, is unification with all local elementary school districts.
"Until that happens," Hassel said, "it's an endless battle."
Hart district Superintendent Robert Lee said all plans hinge on one very big condition: securing funding and building the four proposed campuses.
"Don't look at this and think there are absolutes in 2001 and there are absolutes in 2004," Lee told the audience and committee members. "Bringing (the schools) on line in this time frame is going to be a significant challenge."
