Mike Kotch called it "an attempt at a political move, presented as an issue of attendance."
MICHAEL KOTCH
Tom Campbell countered that Kotch's attendance at Newhall County Water District meetings was the primary issue, which prompted the board to request Kotch's resignation Thursday night.
Neither side went away entirely satisfied.
Kotch, who serves as NCWD representative to the Castaic Lake Water Agency board, refused to resign, despite a 4-1 vote by the NCWD board asking him to step aside.
Campbell, who was elected board president Thursday evening, said NCWD may consult with its legal counsel as to what action it can now take.
According to Campbell, under NCWD board resolution 1996-1, "members serve at the pleasure of the board, and nominees shall be expected to tender their resignation if the board asks them to do so."
"They can't demand that anyone resign," NCWD general manager Tom Shollenberger said. "They can only vote to ask them to resign."
Campbell said the resolution was passed unanimously on Jan. 11, 1996, after being seconded by Mike Kotch.
Campbell added that, over the past year, Kotch has been absent for "19 out of 33 meetings, which is over 50 percent. We felt we weren't being effectively represented on the CLWA board by Mike."
Campbell denied there anything politcal behind the action.
"Absolutely not," Campbell said. "This was a topic a year ago. His number of absences is causing a concern, and this seemed like a good time to address it."
While Kotch admitted that he's missed meetings — "I can't give you an exact figure as to how many, but I think I've been there the important times" he said that the issue of his attendance "was never raised before. My read on the issue is they want to have their own person on the CLWA."
Kotch, president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Protecting the Environment (SCOPE), has been at odds with both the CLWA board and NCWD over what he perceives as attempts to stockpile water for the Newhall Ranch housing development, the largest planned community if the county's history.
By law, CLWA is restricted from acquiring water sources for projects until they receive final approval from the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors. Newhall Ranch is expected to be approved early next year.
Many of Kotch's views are shared by recently elected CLWA board member Ed Dunn. Kotch said the attempt to remove him as NCWD's representative to CLWA is "because of Ed Dunn's election. He makes a motion, I second it."
One issue, Kotch said, is a pipeline which "CLWA is obligated to provide to Canyon Country and they have not. The pipeline is owned by Newhall County Water District, and it's 14 inches (in diameter). It should be at least 21 inches under CLWA's rules. That's a big difference in water volume. ... Canyon Country is already starved for water, and they're running imported water at pressures that are far higher than safe, and we have problems with the wells in terms of supply in the area. We're in a situation where we're at the very brink of water supply, and we have no reserves."
Kotch said the pipeline isn't being installed, "because they're spending the money instead for imported water and for pipelines for Newhall Ranch instead of Canyon Country."
Campbell denied the allegation.
Kotch said he "appreciated the fact that there was a petition with 90 signatures supporting me, and approximately 10 people" at the meeting Thursday night.
Despite that, Campbell said the board still expects Kotch's resignation, adding that "we'll give him a chance to change his mind" before consulting with legal counsel.
"With the board's action," Campbell said, "I don't see how we can just let it go."
