A Los Angeles County Superior Court judge Thursday denied a legal motion by the William S. Hart Union High School District seeking a ruling on whether the district must release to The Signal the full terms of an insurance settlement for the auditorium at Hart High School.
Judge Haley Fromholz denied the ex-parte request, the outcome of which would have determined whether The Signal would gain access to the complete information, requested by the newspaper Dec. 10 under the California Public Records Act.
"He just found no reason for an emergency order," said court spokeswoman Leslye Kasoff.
The Hart district filed a lawsuit Sept. 20, 1996, against Arthur J. Gallagher, the insurance broker responsible for the auditorium, after a technical glitch prevented the company from paying damages the auditorium sustained in the Jan. 17, 1994, earthquake. As part of the November settlement, the district signed a nondisclosure agreement.
While such agreements are common in private party lawsuits, an attorney for the California Newspaper Publishers Association says it is illegal for public agencies to enter into such nondisclosure deals.
In a 1984 ruling on The Register Division of Freedom Newspapers Inc. vs. County of Orange, California's Fourth District Court of Appeal ruled that documents relating to a public agency's lawsuit settlements are not exempt from disclosure under the Public Records Act.
A letter sent to The Signal Tuesday from Bowie, Arneson, Wiles and Giannone, the district's legal counsel, stated the Hart district will receive approximately $810,000 to repair the quake-ravaged auditorium. The letter further assured the newspaper that the requested documents would be released to the newspaper "on or about" Wednesday.
However, full terms of the settlement have not been disclosed.
Hart district superintendent Robert Lee said the district went to court from the perspective that it wished to release the information, but was concerned about the possibility of a breach-of-contract lawsuit by RLI, one of the settling insurance companies.
"We went into court based on our need and desire and belief that we should release it," Lee said.
Brian Smith, an attorney with Bowie, Arneson, Wiles and Giannone, said Wednesday in a letter to The Signal that RLI is threatening legal action against the district to prevent disclosure of the settlement terms.
The letter, sent by fax at 5:57 p.m. Wednesday, informed The Signal that a hearing on the Hart district's emergency motion would occur before Fromholz in downtown Los Angeles at 8:30 a.m. the next day.
Board President John Hassel said Thursday the district has received the money from the insurance settlement. "It's beyond in the mail," he said. "It's in our hands and in the bank.
"They said, 'Take this,'" he continued, "which in the opinion of legal counsel was a very good settlement, or go to court and take our chances along with the expenses."
Hassel estimated it will take nearly $2.3 million to repair the auditorium; that figure includes fixing earthquake damage and modernization of the facility.
In addition to the insurance settlement, the district has received monetary contributions from community organizations and the city of Santa Clarita. The issue of funding from the Federal Emergency Management Agency is thus far unresolved, hinging, in part, on resolution of the insurance lawsuit and accompanying settlement, Hassel said.
Fromholz' decision Thursday means the Hart district must refile the motion in regular legal fashion, setting a date for a future hearing and notifying all parties within 20 days of inking a hearing date.
No date for the future hearing was set Thursday, court spokeswoman Kasoff said.
This latest legal action may impair the auditorium's reconstruction schedule, Hassel said.
