Several times a month, the lobby of the Santa Clarita Sheriff's Station is the setting for a scene of what could be considered high drama — or simply commonplace human tragedy.
Several times a month, divorced parents are required by the court to meet in the lobby of the sheriff's station, and exchange their children for weekend visitations.
"It works out pretty well for us," Lt. Carl Deeley said. "It saves us from having to answer too many domestic calls; you know, 'I showed up and the kids aren't here,' or the two of them get into a fight and it gets ugly in front of the kids. It usually goes pretty smoothly with them having to come here. Still, it's a pretty sad situation when things have to get to that point."
But according to most, the whole matter of child custody in Los Angeles County is "a pretty sad situation." Custodial parents — the majority of whom are women — complain they're not receiving court-ordered child support payments, either from their ex-spouse or the district attorney's office once the money is collected.
Non-custodial parents — mostly men — charge they're being persecuted by a court system which drives them into financial ruin and then fails to protect their visitation rights.
The county Board of Supervisors has held numerous hearings and demanded answers from District Attorney Gil Garcetti, who has defended his office against charges of fraud and sought to stave off moves to privatize child support collections.
And somewhere in the middle are the children, voiceless in the courts, alienated from — and by — their parents, victims of a system which claims to have their best interests at heart.
'The System Is Broken'
Los Angeles attorney Gloria Allred is a nationally recognized figure in the area of child support procedures, and the recipient of awards from President Ronald Reagan in 1986 and the National Association of Federal Investigators for her work on behalf of children.
Allred calls D.A. Gil Garcetti's office "a dismal failure. ... There are 745,000 cases of uncollected child support that we know of. That probably means more than a million children affected. ... The issue of child support hasn't been a real priority with (Garcetti). ... They're the worst in the state, and possibly the worst in the nation."
Allred said the D.A.'s office has "millions of dollars kept in a trust account, on the theory that they can't find the parents to whom it's due," but independent investigators were able to locate those who were owed within three days.
Fifth District Los Angeles County Supervisor Mike Antonovich also terms the DA's Bureau of Family Support Operations "a failure." At the county Board of Supervisors meeting on Dec. 15, after months of investigation and weeks of hearings, Antonovich proposed turning the bureau's collection operations over to the private sector and the board agreed.
"From the thousands of letters and public testimony at our public hearings (such as the child support conference held at College of the Canyons in October), the District Attorney's office continues to fail in their child support mission. ... We've heard horror stories of one man who had his wages garnished by 50 percent to pay support for a child already in his custody. Another witness testified that he had the same name as another man who owed child support. Even though they were of different height, weight and ethnicity, the wrong man received a bill for $71,000. Others told of how mistaken support billings have destroyed their credit ratings. ... The system is broken and the time is past due to fix it."
Antonovich added that Mel Shaw, president of United States Credit Bureau, Inc., which has reported success in collecting support payments in other states, testified that, during a pilot program, his firm traced 5,000 cases which the district attorney had deemed uncollectible.
"He located parents in 47 percent of those cases," Antonovich said, "and 90 percent of those located voluntarily paid the support owed."
Allred has called for "a complete investigation of the system" to look into allegations of "fraud, waste and mismanagement," which allowed the Bureau of Family Support to continue receiving federal funds.
But Allred was not satisfied with a recent response from the Federal Inspector General's Office, Department of Health and Human Services.
In a letter dated Nov. 25, Vicki Shepard, Regional Inspector General for Investigations, told Allred, "I have determined that these concerns and allegations (of fraud and mismanagement) have little or no merit and I do not have information/documentation that substantiates undertaking a federal criminal/civil investigation."
"They only had their investigation open for three and a half weeks," Allred said. "They failed to contact witnesses and do the full investigation they were required to do. I asked them, who are you trying to protect? Certainly not the children of L.A. County."
Congressman Howard P. "Buck" McKeon (R-25th) fired off a letter to Shepard on Dec. 14, requesting that DHHS reopen the investigation.
"In the six years I've represented northern Los Angeles County," McKeon told Shepard, "my office has received numerous complaints from constituents about inadequate service from the Bureau of Family Support."
McKeon outlined the complaints as ranging from non-custodial parents who were not being obligated to pay child support, to reports from non-custodial fathers whose payments were current "but are subjected to erroneous claims and harassment from the district attorney's office. I am very concerned that this pattern of problems ... could be related to the aforementioned alleged fraud."
If, McKeon concluded, DHHS is "unwilling or unable to investigate the matter properly, it may be necessary for me to request the U.S. Department of Justice to conduct a more thorough investigation."
Garcetti On The Defense
In an appearance before the board of supervisors on Nov. 17, Garcetti claimed there has been "much progress in the last five years and substantial progress in the last year alone. Our increase in collections last year exceeded the performance of the rest of the state."
Garcetti condemned reports "which fail to reflect this progress (and) are misleading to the public and unfair to the employees of BFSO (Bureau of Family Support Operations)."
Garcetti said "the most important move towards improved performance" was the engagement of Price Waterhouse "to prepare a top to bottom management audit" which has become "our bible." Garcetti quoted the report as stating, "Los Angeles County has perhaps the most difficult caseload of any jurisdiction in the nation, certainly more difficult than any other in the state."
And Garcetti went on to cite the report as praising BFSO's new automated computer system, staff increases, and customer call center.
"We are committed to continuing to improve and have undertaken many internal initiatives, principally focusing on better serving the public," Garcetti told the board.
In the wake of the supervisors' move to privatize collections, Garcetti, on Dec. 15, proposed hiring a chief operating officer to oversee BFSO's child support program. But such measures have done little to placate the supervisors or the public.
"The custodial parents are unhappy either because they don't see the money, especially if they know the ex-spouse is working," said Shauna Jackson of Antonovich's staff. "Or custodial parents later find out that the ex-spouse did pay the D.A., but there's been a delay from the time the money is paid until it is credited (and the custodial parent receives it). There hasn't been an explanation for that."
But Jackson said Antonovich's office has also been inundated with complaints from non-custodial parents, in most cases fathers.
"They're the ones who have highlighted that there's an access to justice problem," Jackson said. "They say we have a court system that only cares about the money, when the custody issues are really what's important. They feel the system — lawyers, government officials, judges — are profiting, rather than looking at what's in the best interest of the child."
Disneyland Dads
Allred estimates that in 90 percent of divorce cases in California where there are children involved, custody is granted to the mother, despite the fact there has been a joint custody law on the books for 10 years. The father receives visitation, and more often than not, a monthly child support payment.
"Generally, courts like to keep children where they are, so as not to cause a lot of disruption and change in their lives," Allred said. "So physical custody stays with the mother."
But activists like John Smith, of the Alliance for Non-Custodial Parents Rights (ANCPR), said the situation is far more complicated than that.
Smith said studies show that in 80 percent of the cases where couples divorce, it's women who initiate the court action.
"Women are told, divorce him and you'll get the house, the car, the kids and 20 percent of his income," Smith said. "For years there had been an incorrect statistic, put forward in a study by Lenore Weitzman of Harvard, which said that a woman's standard of living decreases by over 70 percent when she divorces, while men's increased by 40 percent. The study was discredited, and Weitzman finally admitted that it wasn't accurate."
Two things, Smith added, need to be removed from the child custody scenario: greed and revenge.
"The child support system is a mess," Smith said. "States that are highest in child support and welfare payments rank lowest in child well-being (how well off the children are emotionally). ... Band-aid measures such as privatization and call centers will not help. ... We need to adopt a plan which would focus on shared parenting. The fundamental problem with our laws, they're all based on money, and none of them are focused on parental involvement. And that's the key."
Smith added, "There's a feeling of hopelessness when fathers go into court. The wife goes to court and says, 'Look how much he's making, I need an increase (in child support payments),' and she gets it. Look at the tremendous disinclination (for the father) to work hard and make money."
Eric Silgero, a Santa Clarita firefighter, is one such father. He and his girlfriend had a child out of wedlock 11 years ago, but Silgero said he didn't try to duck his responsibility. Without a court order, he said he was mailing checks of $150 a month while laboring as a seasonal worker, even though, for the first three years, his ex-girlfriend "didn't allow me to see my daughter."
Circumstances changed, Silgero said, when he became a Los Angeles County firefighter in 1993.
"I went to court because I wanted regular visitation, not just to see my daughter for an hour in a park. I thought I'd get a fair judgment; that didn't happen."
Silgero sought 50/50 visitation: "Every weekend, two weeks alternating in the summer, and shared birthdays and holidays, odd and even years."
Silgero said he expected his child support payments would increase. He was given an order to pay $663 per month, and told he would have 20 percent visitation time: Every other weekend, and every other week in the summer. Birthdays and holidays would alternate, odd and even years.
But Silgero soon found out that, as a "visiting father, you have no parental influence on your child, and she has no type of relationship with a father parent, not with seeing her only four days a month."
Since 1993, Silgero said he's gone back to court several times to request more parenting time, and has gained about five percent.
"They add up the hours," Silgero said. "So I'm able to pick her up at 4 p.m. Friday from school, rather than 6 p.m."
But due to his yearly raises as a firefighter, Silgero said he now pays $729 per month in child support, plus 15 percent of any overtime he works. Now married with a new family, on an approximately $45,000 yearly salary, Silgero said there's not much left over.
"It ultimately hurts my daughter," Silgero said. "When she comes here and she would like to do things, we don't have luxuries. Everything is very much budgeted."
But besides the money, Silgero said, the worst part is the on-going struggle to see his daughter when the court has said he can. He was scheduled to have her for Thanksgiving this year, but he said his ex-girlfriend refused at the last minute. When Silgero took his complaints to a county commissioner, Silgero said he was told, "That's just the way it is."
"Non-custodial parents are treated as criminals," Silgero said. "Custodial parents can take you to court with the backing of the district attorney. Fathers have nowhere to go. ... She wants me to go back to court. If I go back to court and complain about the visitation, she'll ask for more money and get it."
Silgero said there are several changes he'd like to see in the system.
"Make the custodial parent accountable for the money being spent," Silgero said. "Make sure it's being spent on the children. If someone is paying child support, make it tax deductible. ... What's needed is more parental involvement and less child support collection. I will never be just a Disneyland Dad."
