Since the Castaic Lake Water Agency began negotiations Tuesday to purchase Santa Clarita Water Company, questions have arisen over the legality of the move.
CLWA is the Santa Clarita Valley's water wholesaler. SCWC purchases water from the agency, along with retailers Valencia Water Company and Newhall County Water District.
Privately owned SCWC is the valley's largest water retailer, with approximately 21,000 households and businesses as customers.
Mike Kotch, the representative from Newhall County Water District to the CLWA board, expressed doubts about the agency's ability to combine the wholesale and retail aspects of the area's water business.
"I don't think CLWA is geared up to do that," Kotch said.
Kotch added that CLWA "is restricted under their enabling act from becoming a retailer."
But CLWA officials disagreed.
"The enabling act sets up the agency, like a company having an employee policy," said CLWA spokesperson Kiza Stratton. "The laws have overriding authority over the enabling act. I don't believe there's any legal basis under which the agency can not operate as a retailer."
Stratton cited both state and statutory laws as giving CLWA authority to operate a retail water system.
Under Article 16, section 17 of state laws, Stratton said, "CLWA is authorized to acquire stock in water corporations when the stock is acquired or held for the purpose of furnishing water for public purposes. By ownership of such stock, CLWA has the same rights and obligations imposed by law generally on water corporations."
Statutory law, Stratton added, gives the agency "authority as a state water project contractor to sell water at retail. ... It means CLWA is one of 29 state water contractors, and there many others in northern California who are also retail and wholesale."
But local activist Allan Cameron also expressed doubts about legality. Cameron cited state law AB4175, which "specifically prohibits them from being a retailer."
When CLWA sought to purchase SCWC in 1994, Cameron said, "they realized they were legally unable to do so unless special legislation was passed, and that was proposed and failed."
Cameron also said the "conflict of interest would be labyrinthian, and so corrupt it boggles the mind. ... CLWA would be retailing water to itself, operating a for-profit entity and competing with the other retailers."
But CLWA board president Bill Cooper said the purchase would "provide a tremendous cost saving" for both the agency and customers and enhance water quality in the valley.
