These days, people come to churches and synagogues in search of relevance. They want to know, “What does religion have to do with our daily lives?” As the ongoing debate over stem cell research reminds us, the answer to this question is “everything.”
Last week, President George W. Bush authorized limited federal support for research on embryonic stem cells. The president permitted federal funds for research on stem cell lines that had already been produced from human embryos.
At the same time, the president forbade the use of government moneys to harvest additional stem cells from embryos, and appointed a commission to study the entire question.
The president was the first to admit religion played a major part in his decision. During his last meeting with the Pope, the president devoted a great deal of time to discussing stem cell research.
Scholars from the major religions testified before congressional committees. And, according to the president, the entire cabinet engaged in a great deal of prayer and reflection before the final decision was made.
Cynics might suggest that president Bush’s decision panders to those religious groups opposing stem cell research in an effort to maintain their support in 2004. To be sure, a healthy skepticism is always helpful when analyzing the decisions of our political leaders. But in this case, there is more involved.
Like many Americans, Bush recognizes that the world’s great religions have spent hundreds, even thousands of years wrestling with the core questions raised by the stem cell debate. “When does life begin?”
“How do we weigh the loss of a potential life against the possibility for saving actual lives?”
“Is aggressive medical research and treatment an intrusion on God’s role as Creator, or the fulfillment of our charge as partners in creation with God?”
Up until now, religion has played a very healthy role in helping to answer the questions that science raises. But in our uniquely diverse country, there is a downside to the involvement of religious groups in setting policy. On stem cell research, as on so many other questions, the great religions differ. Catholics and Christian evangelicals oppose embryonic stem cell research. Judaism and many Mainline Protestant groups favor it.
In the short run, the involvement of religious groups in the stem cell debate has only muddied the waters. No doubt, the differences among religious groups helped to convince Bush not to take a firm stand on embryonic stem cell research.
Instead, the president chose to put off the largest part of the question, and offend each of the religious groups just a little with his decision.
Some people might wonder how religious groups could have such different views on embryonic stem cell research. Catholics, Protestants and Jews, for example, all share the Hebrew Bible as sacred scripture. The Book of Genesis provides each of these groups with a framework for answering questions like: “What is origin of life?” and “What is God’s role as Creator?” Yet, in different religious traditions, these same sources of wisdom lead to very different conclusions.
For example, my tradition, Judaism, teaches that life begins at birth.
Prior to birth, the fetus is viewed as a potential life, whose value is not equal to that of a living human being. If a fetus endangers a mother’s life, preserving the mother’s life always takes precedence.
In fact, the fetus’ status is determined by its growth. A fetus within the first 40 days of gestation is regarded “as if it were water” according to the Talmud. This statement might reflect the Talmud’s awareness that many fetuses are miscarried during this early period of pregnancy. As the fetus develops through the second and third trimester of pregnancy, Jewish law grants it stronger protection. As a result, while Judaism restricts abortion in general, the restrictions are far more stringent in the second and third trimesters.
It’s easy to see, then, why Judaism does not oppose embryonic stem cell research. Drawing stem cells from an embryo discarded by a fertility clinic, as thousands are every year, does not equal taking a life. More important, research on embryonic stem cells has the potential to save a great many lives. And Judaism has always viewed healing as a religious imperative. The rabbis of antiquity learned from the Bible that humans have an obligation to God to do everything possible to heal the sick. According to Jewish tradition, we must all see ourselves as instruments of God’s healing. In the Jewish view, the healing potential of embryonic stem cell research certainly justifies the use of embryos that are being destroyed already.
The Jewish position on embryonic stem cell research differs markedly from the more publicized views of some other religious groups. As a rabbi, I would not presume to try to explain the positions of these groups in detail. In general, as I understand it, our differences revolve around the key questions I mentioned earlier; especially, “When does life begin?” and “What role does God want us to play in the healing process?”
And while this difference of opinion makes the decision-making process slow to a crawl, in the end, all this debate might be a good thing. We do not live in a theocracy. There is no state religion, no national worship place. But religion has an important role to play in the public debate.
When religious groups join a national discussion of an important issue, the quality of discourse invariably rises. Religions raise important questions, and present well thought out perspectives. As long as the representatives of religious groups seek to contribute to public debate and not to stifle it, we all benefit. And so do religions. Because religion can provide its adherents with meaning and relevance only when it attempts to grapple with the thorny questions that life in our post-modern world raises so often.
Steve Conn is the Rabbi at Congregation Beth Shalom in Santa Clarita.
