One day later didn't change a thing for Kevin Gilfoy. He still shook his head over Thursday.
That's the day the proverbial big one got away.
"I can't believe I missed that fish," he muttered, sitting behind a worn desk in the back office of the Castaic Mobile Mini Mart. "It was a nice one, too. I wouldn't say I got upset. I just made a nice, loud 'pssst' noise and kept casting."
Quickly getting another hit.
Hey, can't stay mad forever while fishing. Besides Gilfoy has become accustomed to the hits. One big one gets off the hook? No problem. There's another just a cast away off Gilfoy's homemade lure, dubbed the K-Fin.
Like a number of other bass fishing aficionados, Gilfoy entered the rivalry to create the perfect fishing lure for Castaic Lake — sort of a local '90s version of the space race. Unlike many of that same number, Gilfoy saw his lure quickly become a success, quietly gaining a following among serious anglers.
He's only 23 and on top of a world piled with fish look-a-like baits such as AC Plugs, Tru-Trouts, Castaic Softbaits and Castaic Hardbaits flood the largemouth and striped bass angler market. With new models appearing faster that improved computer microchips, the Valencia resident's K-Fin is the hottest thing going right now. Everybody who's anybody on Castaic already has or wants one of Gilfoy's lures in their tackle box.
Because as the K-Fin proves all to frequently, it catches fish.
"It's an excellent lure," Castaic-based pro guide Pat Buckley said of Gilfoy's K-Fin. "It has a unique action to it, one that the striped bass can't seem to lay off of. They're not the flashiest lure. But the action sure brings on the fish.
"Right now it's the No. 1 lure I'm using because of the way it swims. The way it's designed and put together it seems to swim better than some of the others."
And when it comes to look-a-like baits, swimming action was key for Gilfoy.
An angler for as long as he can recollect, Gilfoy began working on his own lure last year. He took ideas from other crankbaits, interestingly getting much of his influence from a wooden saltwater trolling plug.
"It's a (unfinished) natural grain plug and it always gets bit," Gilfoy said. "I've always said that if I can make a chunk of wood that could swim, it would get bit. Painted or not."
He still ended up painting his first lure, a wooden topwater crankbait constructed in three segments. He attached a plastic bill to the front to get the lure to dive, then fitted a plastic tail to the aft to get the bait to create a wake. He decorated it to look like a rainbow trout, with big golden eyes.
He took the mock trout out one day last November, setting out across the Castaic dam face with two buddies. He casted his creation and minutes later hauled in a 15.5-pound striper.
"Timing had something to do with it," Gilfoy said. "It was right after a trout plant. But I was the only one who caught a fish between me and the other two who were with me."
He sat back and smiled.
"We all know it's just luck."
Somehow the self-assessment is a little harder to swallow than his lures, which take 3-4 hours apiece to construct.
He's quick to say that he's proud of the angling acumen he's gained at such an early age and the accolades his lures have already collected. It's all payoff for a guy who takes fishing so seriously that he keeps a journal of every angling trip he takes. From far out in the Pacific going for tuna, or up on Bishop Creek in the Eastern Sierras casting for trout, Gilfoy keeps a synopsis of his fishing adventures that includes baits used and details of weather and water conditions.
Must be a pretty thick journal, considering he spent more than 200 days fishing just this year alone.
The knowledge he's gained over the years serves him well — and the customers of the Mini Mart, where Gilfoy serves as a sort of resident pro. He answers fishing questions for the Mini Mart's e-mail site and advises novice walk-in customers on what to use when fishing Castaic.
It's a role he enjoys filling, especially when he's right. Whether it's recommending a specific bait to a customer or making another of his hand-made K-Fins, the bottom line for Gilfoy is the final result.
"I'm a guy who's able to sandbag well," he joked when questioned about his fishing knowledge. "No, you have to be careful. If you sit there and tell someone way too much information they're going to think that you're flexing your muscles or you're going to leave them in the dust. So you have to feel out each situation. It's so nice when you get results."
Even if a big one does get away every now and then.
