They say familiarity breeds contempt.
For Alemany High coach Jim Bonds and Hart coaching brothers Mike, Rick and Dean Herrington it would never come to that, but it sure made for interesting football Friday night.
In a game between two teams featuring similar spread offenses, nearly corresponding defenses and the exact same mascot, the Hart Indians scored three times in the first half — once after a key interception by fill-in linebacker John Bourg — then held on strong defensively in the second half to beat the Alemany Indians 21-13 in a CIF-Southern Section Division III semifinal at College of the Canyons.
Hart, making its sixth championship-game appearance, faces St. Paul, a 49-19 winner over Valencia on Friday, in the Division III championship game next Saturday at either Cerritos College or COC, depending on the outcome of the coin flip this morning at the Southern Section office.
Leaving only seven days for Hart's coaches to try to get a right-side flip for an offensive line they viewed as a flop against freewheel-blitzing Alemany.
"They (repeatedly) ran one blitz and we couldn't pick it up," Hart offensive coordinator Dean Herrington said. "It was pathetic. We used to absolutely destroy teams that blitzed us. Not this team. We had guys open down the middle and Kyle (Boller) didn't have time to throw it to them. Absolutely pathetic."
Leading to Boller's absolutely worst performance of the season.
Hart's wunderkid quarterback completed only 14-of-25 attempts for 197 yards and two touchdowns. While that may look fine for most quarterbacks of the high school variety, it fell well below his 375-yard season average.
Boller's previous passing low was 265 yards against Valencia on Oct. 29.
Reason? Try blitz after blitz by an Alemany team where stealth seemed to matter more than strength.
"I didn't think they were tough at all," senior center Paul Dolinsky said. "They were blitzing three guys to one side. All we had to do was scoop it. It was Boller's call (to alert for the blitz). But it was impossible for him to see it, because the backers wouldn't come up right away."
Said running back Billy Brecht: "We knew where they were going to blitz, but we didn't know how they were going to blitz. It wasn't one of our best games. But we'll practice on it for next week."
Meanwhile, Bonds — a Hart graduate in his second year of coaching at Alemany — and his Indians gave Hart's all they could handle Friday. Barring three interceptions by quarterback Casey Clausen, who completed 14-of-38 for 163 yards, the game may have been even closer.
Alemany struck first, capping a nine-play, 59-yard game-opening drive with a one-yard run by Deon Scott. Hart quickly countered in three plays, Boller burning an Alemany blitz with a 61-yard touchdown toss to Shane Lavoie to tie the game at seven with 8:26 left in the first quarter.
Hart took the lead on its next possession, driving 63 yards in five plays to the Alemany 12 before Boller scampered into the end zone on a first-down play.
At that point it looked like the game would end up as a typical Hart runaway.
Not if Alemany had anything to do with it.
Alemany scored on the second play of the second quarter on a one-yard run by De'Andre Scott after a 68-yard drive. Hart's Jake Halladay blocked the extra-point attempt and Hart held on to a one-point lead.
After two Hart drives ended in punts, Alemany took over on its own 26. Two plays later, Clausen dropped back and threw a pass meant for Devin Montgomery. Bourg, inserted at linebacker after starter Chad Carlson suffered a concussion early in the game, picked off the pass at the Alemany 29-yard line and returned it 20 yards.
After a rushing loss by Brecht left Hart at the Alemany 11, Boller rolled to his right and hit Pat Norton in the end zone. That gave Hart a 21-13 halftime lead, eventually enough to win the game.
Hart's defense then worked Alemany in the second half. They allowed Alemany only one first down in the second half, leaving the visiting Indians with only 213 total yards. That's 12 yards under Hart's defensive average this season.
Undoubtedly a good thing for Hart, since the home Indians gained only three first downs in the second half and 281 total yards in the game. That was well below the 486 Hart averaged going into the game.
And what the Herringtons undoubtedly hope Hart reaches as a minimum in next week's championship game against St. Paul.
