The Major League Baseball trading deadline has come and gone. Last Friday night was the final opportunity for teams to try and acquire (or buy) players in a free-for-all frenzy that has put several clubs on the brink of making the playoffs or reaching the World Series.
Sure, there was a couple of juicy deals made at the last hour. Hart High graduate Todd Zeile will be playing for the Texas Rangers, his third team this season. The Los Angeles Dodgers — at the expense of forking over several top minor league prospects — acquired a left-handed starting pitcher Carlos Perez and a shortstop Mark Grudzielanek from the Montreal Expos. The Anaheim Angels did nothing to improve and saw last month's five-game lead in the American League West evaporate.
So who did the best and worst at what many baseball fans consider the best day in the sport other than when the Fall Classic is being played?
What shrewd general manager added more security to his job and improved his team? Or what GM dug himself and his team a deeper hole?
First, the winners:
Houston Astros — Not only have the Astros been in first place throughout much of the season in the National League Central, they were able to steal Randy Johnson from the Seattle Mariners for a couple of prospects and a future player. Not only did Houston improve its pitching staff with a bona fide left-handed pitcher averaging close to 10 strikeouts per game, the Astros didn't have to give up any regular players. They probably have distanced themselves from the remainder of the Central and could pose some problems for teams such as the Atlanta Braves and San Diego Padres when the postseason begins.
Texas Rangers — The other team from the Lone Star state rebuilt the left side of its infield acquiring Zeile from the Florida Marlins and Royce Clayton from the St. Louis Cardinals. Zeile has already made a major impact offensively and should give the Rangers some much-needed stability at third base. Clayton, a shortstop, gives Texas speed and occasional offensive pop. However, Texas also got two-time World Series champion starting pitcher Todd Stottlemyre from St. Louis.
San Francisco Giants — The team from the City by the Bay swapped Ellis Burks from the Colorado Rockies for leadoff hitter Darryl Hamilton. Burks will provide the Giants, expected to move into their new ballpark next year, with some offensive protection behind Barry Bonds. Earlier, they pried Joe Carter away from the Baltimore Orioles. San Francisco didn't address their main concern — pitching. That could be a bane for the Giants the remainder of the season, but San Francisco should contend for the wild-card spot into late September.
Los Angeles Dodgers — Acquiring Perez and Grudzielanek were ideal moves for a team whose payroll is approaching nearly $60 million. Either interim General Manager Tommy LaSorda is a sudden genius or he's saving face for a team that has constantly underachieved and teased their fans throughout the season. Perez, subject of trade rumors all season, will give the Dodgers a quality left-handed starter. Grudzielanek, who was booed by the Montreal fans, escapes a small-market team and receives an opportunity to showcase his talent at ever-changing Chavez Ravine.
New York Yankees — The team with the best record in baseball did nothing to improve their team. But when you've won 70-plus games by the end of July, what more do you really need to do? Granted, they didn't get Johnson. But neither did the Cleveland Indians, who are expected to challenge the Yankees for the right to advance in the World Series. The Yankees would have had to reportedly surrender a starting pitcher (Hideki Irabu) and prospects (Ricky Ledee, Ramiro Mendoza and Homer Bush). New York Yankees owner George Steinbrenner eventually said no dice. The price was indeed too steep for the wealthy Yankees as Johnson is scheduled to become a free agent in the fall. Plus the Yankees can now negotiate with center fielder Bernie Williams and starting pitcher Andy Pettitte, who are also scheduled to become free agents after the season.
The losers:
Anaheim Angels — They stood pat and watched Texas improve. Anaheim General Manager Bill Bavasi actually said the Angels improved in that Seattle gave away Johnson. The problem is Seattle is at the bottom while Texas has leap-frogged the Angels. The Angels could have acquired Mark McGwire at the trade deadline last year and a proven veteran starting pitcher such as Tim Belcher this year. But they apparently weren't willing to part with Jim Edmonds or prospects. Disney, which owns the Angels, continues to make gobs of money and that will never change. But they will continue to remain a laughingstock in the eyes of the sporting world as long as they don't improve the Angels and their hockey team (Anaheim Mighty Ducks) on the other side of the State Route 57.
Seattle Mariners — Giving up one of the top pitchers this decade has not sat well with the players and fans in the Northwest. Johnson filled seats at the Kingdome and the team will be moving to a new stadium next season. Yes, they still have Ken Griffey Jr., Edgar Martinez, Alex Rodriguez and Jay Buhner, but whose going to get the precious outs on the mound? It won't be Johnson and it certainly won't be Seattle's troubled bullpen, which is partly responsible for Seattle's tumble.
Cleveland Indians — The Indians, who haven't won a World Series since 1948, have some young arms in Barton Colon and Jared Wright. The tandem gave the Yankees fits last year in the playoffs. Acquiring Johnson would have probably done the same thing this year. Now the Indians will have to rely on a pretty good offensive lineup to set the tone.
Atlanta Braves — Ted Turner's Braves still have not addressed its biggest weakness — a reliable relief pitcher who can close games out with authority. The "Team of the '90s" has won exactly one World Series this decade and opponents have beaten "America's Team" in past years by staying close in the final innings. The axiom is that if a team can hang in against Atlanta's strong starting pitching staff and get into their bullpen, then that team has a chance to beat the Braves. Getting a Randy Myers or Jeff Montgomery would have put that theory to rest.
* * *
Charles Rich is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Wednesdays. He can be reached at 254-8690, ext. 296, or via e-mail at [email protected] .
