Paul Broneer had a tough decision to make Monday.
The Canyon High girls basketball coach was about to inform one of his star players, Janette Garcia, that she no longer could play for the Cowgirls this season.
The reason: Her GPA had dipped below 2.0.
Although Garcia wouldn't officially be ineligible until Wednesday, Broneer has a long-standing team policy that anyone with a sub-2.0 GPA cannot participate.
That integrity went to the test Monday, the day before Canyon played its biggest game of the season against crosstown rival Hart, which entered with a 44-game Foothill League winning streak.
Some coaches may have circumvented policy just to sacrifice principles for a victory. For example, Everett Bryson on Canyon's boys team was allowed to play in Tuesday night's game against Hart, even though he became ineligible on Wednesday.
So why didn't Broneer make an exception?. Canyon had not defeated the Indians since 1991. And with fellow star player La Tricia Fleming suffering from flu, Broneer easily could have played Garcia one last time.
But once Broneer discovered Garcia's report card, he never hesitated in making his final decision. Vice Principal Bob Messina backed his decision, as did other school administrators and coaches.
Canyon Girls Athletic Director Ardyce Masters said Broneer received criticism to play Garcia. After all, she's a returning all-league guard, averaging 10 points per game.
"Every girl on my team knows our team rules," Broneer told a Signal staff member before Tuesday's tough 49-47 loss to the Indians. "There are no surprises on this team. When you become my age, you become pretty predictable."
Broneer's decision was reminiscent of another coach's bold move earlier this season in Northern California. Richmond coach Ken Carter took his team off the court for a week until the entire program improved its grades. He had every player sign a form before the season pledging to achieve at least a 2.0 GPA in the classroom. When the team failed in that promise, the coach acted.
Broneer, an honors geometry and pre-algebra teacher, said academics must come first before athletics. Too often, students put more emphasis on making baskets, scoring touchdowns or hitting home runs over learning U.S. history, physics formulas or Shakespeare.
"I can't speak for 'Netta," said Broneer, who helped tutor Fleming this summer, making her eligible after missing her sophomore season at Monroe High in the San Fernando Valley due to grade deficiencies. "The system's there, but I cannot play for them. I cannot do their homework for them. She should have asked for help. She did not fulfill her responsibilities in the classroom."
Even so, Broneer did get one request from a player to allow Garcia to suit up against Hart. She begged and pleaded with her coach.
"She said we could use her," Broneer said. "And that's what we would have been doing — using her. I will not do that. I am a teacher before I'm a coach."
Cheers to Broneer. His steadfast philosophy serves as a positive example of why high school athletes need to be students before they are players.
* * *
More comments and tidbits from around the Santa Clarita Valley:
Canyon High's girls basketball team will not win the Foothill League title this season, but the future looks very solid. The junior varsity team is 20-2. Its lone losses came from undefeated Crescenta Valley and Buena. The freshman team also only has two defeats. Players to keep an eye on are Victoria Woodhouse, Courtney Koenig and freshman Michelle DeFalco. ...
With Hart's Kyle Boller signing with Cal, the Golden Bears stand a good chance to rank among the nation's top 25 in recruiting classes. Cal also landed standout RB/DB Atari Callen from De La Salle-Concord. ...
The Master's College forward Elizabeth Hansell is just 33 points shy of becoming the school's all-time leading scorer. Kim DeVries, who played with Hansell two years ago, owns the mark at 1,475 points. Hansell posted her eighth double-double of the season in Tuesday night's 55-52 win at Western Baptist of Salem, Ore. ...
According to Cal-Hi Sports, Santa Clarita Christian senior center Andrew Duncan ranks fourth in the state in scoring at 32.1 points per game. ...
College of the Canyons women's soccer coach Phil Marcellin is doing his best to land local talent to his fledgling program, but he's likely to lose out on two of Valencia's best players, Christine La Salle and Heather Zubis. Vikings coach Tony Scalercio said the two All-SCV performers are looking to attend Grossmont College in San Diego. ...
When the girls soccer season began, virtually everyone thought Hart would win its sixth straight Foothill League title, with Canyon close behind. Nobody figured Saugus into the mix. But the Centurions can capture the championship by winning their final two games. Of course, they play Canyon and Hart to close out the season. ...
No at-large berths are expected to be handed out for the upcoming CIF-Southern Section Division II girls soccer playoffs, meaning one of the local teams will be the odd-man out. Hart, Canyon, Valencia and Saugus are all deserving of postseason berths. But in basketball, a fourth- or fifth-place team is likely to gain entry into the postseason with an above-.500 record. Where's the justice? ...
COC football coach Chuck Lyon said he's expecting some 120 players out for football this summer. But one player in jeopardy of not returning is all-conference running back Jason Parks. Lyon said Parks could be academically ineligible this fall. ...
Valencia running back Manuel White has been named to Student Sports magazine's Junior All-America team. Other prominent California players picked to that team include quarterbacks Casey Clausen (Alemany) and Zac Wasserman (Westlake), defensive lineman Travis Johnson (Notre Dame) and running back/linebacker D.J. Williams (De La Salle-Concord). ...
* * *
David Shefter is The Signal's senior sports writer. His column appears Tuesdays and Thursdays. He can be reached at 254-8690, or via e-mail at [email protected] .
