Unfortunately, I had to be witness to something ugly.
Even now, as I sit here and recall this event, I feel my shoulders start to tense and my eyes begin to throb.
Let me set the scene.
A little league game was being played by teams of 9- and 10-year olds. These are kids who, for the most part, have already been playing a few years and are pretty good at the game, especially considering their age.
The game was a slugfest, with 10 runs being scored in the first full inning. The final score would eventually be 19-16 , but that really has no bearing on what happened.
It was the third of a six-inning affair. The game had yet to become really tense, meaning a win or a loss certainly wasn’t hanging in the balance.
Up to bat was Nick, a 9-year old. The batter’s box he stepped into had it’s lines blurred and rubbed out by this time, especially due to the fact that several kids had scored sliding into home. Only a feint remembrance of what used to be a batter’s box.
This was no big deal. In my 30-plus years of playing in and being part of baseball, I have never seen a batter’s box remain unscathed during a game.
Nick took a 1-0 pitch and drove it into right field for a single. From where I was I could do nothing but cheer, for this was the boy’s second hit of the season and this was the team’s eighth game.
But then, Nick started to walk off the field, crying. There was confusion for a moment as fans and coaches were trying to tell Nick to get back on base. But, with his head down and feet shuffling, Nick walked into the dugout and buried his tear-streaked face in his hands.
He had been called out by the home plate umpire for stepping out of the batter’s box.
No warning; no instruction. Just, “YOUR OUT!”
And Nick was reduced to tears thinking he had done something terribly wrong and that he had let his team down.
I’ve got a real problem with this.
Now I know umpires, especially the young ones, are instructed in little league games to “take control of the ball game.” But that has nothing to do with taking a kid’s self-esteem that has suddenly surged and throwing it into the ground right before his eyes.
This is a 9-year-old boy for crying-out-loud !
He is still trying to figure out some of the game’s fundamentals.
A perfect example of taking control of a game would have been for this umpire to call time, tell the boy he is standing to close to the front edge of the batter’s box (he was up in the box), take the boy’s bat and draw a line in the dirt where the line “should” be, and tell him if he steps over that line when he hits the ball he will be called out.
That’s taking control.
No coach would have objected to the umpire doing that.
No parent would have demanded an explanation as to why this strange man in blue was “talking” to his or her son.
Quite the contrary. Coaches and parents applaud that kind of umpire. We like seeing our kids being instructed to help them gain an even better understanding of a game that can be very complicated.
I have coached during a game in which an umpire has done this. It has happened several times. No one gets upset. No opposing coach feels the need to file a protest.
The opposing coaches know these are small boys too. Any opportunity to instruct is a welcome opportunity.
On this particular night, when the home plate umpire was asked how he could call such an out, he replied, “I imagined where the line was and he stepped over where I imagined the line to be.”
Re-read that last line and then join me in a resounding:
ARRGGHH!
I couldn’t believe my ears when I heard that one.
I like it when umpires take control of a game. I understand too that calls sometimes don’t go your way. Calls do go your way other times, which, I believe, has a funny way of making things even by the end of the season.
I respect umpires and am grateful that so many men and women agree to work these games, knowing they are putting themselves on the line with coaches and parents with their judgment calls. I know they honestly try to be fair, with home plate umpires making every attempt to be consistent with their strike zone.
But this little episode went beyond anything I’ve seen.
Umpires can take control of a game by being proactive and helping these kids learn and play the game. At every level, the “blues” earn respect by being champions of the game, not rulers of their realm. The games are more fun, and coaches know the games are being won and lost on the field by their players, not by the reactions of a skewed official.
As for Nick, he’s being told that the at bat in question is being recorded in the team’s scorebook as a hit. But it is also being explained to him by his coaches and his parents just what it was that happened so he can understand it. He’s having trouble with it, but he’ll come around. After all, for him any way, it’s still a game.
David Caldwell’s column appears every Tuesday in The Signal. He can be reached at [email protected] .
